
| Humphrey Bogart | ... | Mr. Alfred 'Gloves' Donahue |
 | Conrad Veidt | ... | Franz Ebbing |
 | Kaaren Verne | ... | Miss Leda Hamilton |
 | Jane Darwell | ... | 'Ma' Donahue |
 | Frank McHugh | ... | Barney, Gloves' chauffeur |

| Peter Lorre | ... | Pepi, the piano player |
 | Judith Anderson | ... | Madame, at Continental Art Gallery |
 | William Demarest | ... | Sunshine |
 | Jackie Gleason | ... | Starchy (as Jackie C. Gleason) |

| Phil Silvers | ... | Louie, at Charlie's restaurant |
 | Wallace Ford | ... | Spats Hunter, Gloves' lawyer (as Wally Ford) |
 | Barton MacLane | ... | Marty Callahan, Duchess Club owner |
 | Edward Brophy | ... | Joe Denning, Callahan's partner |
 | Martin Kosleck | ... | Steindorff, at meeting of spies |
 | Jean Ames | ... | Annabelle, Barney's wife |
 | Ludwig Stössel | ... | Herman Miller, the baker (as Ludwig Stossel) |
 | Irene Seidner | ... | Anna Miller |
 | James Burke | ... | Police Lieutenant Forbes |
 | Ben Welden | ... | Smitty, Diamond Cab dispatcher |
 | Hans Schumm | ... | Anton, Continental Art Gallery cashier |
 | Charles Cane | ... | Sage, a cowboy |
 | Frank Sully | ... | Buck Spence, a cowboy |
 | Sam McDaniel | ... | Deacon 'Saratoga', Gloves' valet |
| rest of cast listed alphabetically: |
 | Louis V. Arco | ... | Shortwave radio man (uncredited) |
 | Leah Baird | ... | Woman (uncredited) |
 | Egon Brecher | ... | Art gallery watchman (uncredited) |
 | Walter Brooke | ... | Reporter (uncredited) |
 | Gertrude Carr | ... | Mrs. Novak (uncredited) |
 | Eddy Chandler | ... | Police sergeant (uncredited) |
 | Chester Clute | ... | Westmore Hotel clerk (uncredited) |
 | Clancy Cooper | ... | Police sergeant (uncredited) |
 | Roland Drew | ... | Reporter (uncredited) |
 | Al Eben | ... | Pastry chef at Charlie's Restaurant (uncredited) |
 | Dick Elliott | ... | Husband of bidder who loses to Gloves (uncredited) |
 | Chester Gan | ... | One of Gloves' rescuers at Nazi meeting (uncredited) |
 | Bud Geary | ... | Callahan's henchman (uncredited) |
 | Sol Gorss | ... | Gunman at warehouse (uncredited) |
 | Oscar 'Dutch' Hendrian | ... | Callahan's bouncer (uncredited) |
 | William Hopper | ... | Reporter (uncredited) |
 | Hans Joby | ... | Watchman at warehouse (uncredited) |
 | Robert Kimball | ... | Ebbing's henchman (uncredited) |
 | Mike Lally | ... | Callahan's bouncer (uncredited) |
 | Al Lloyd | ... | Man at toy maneuvers discussion (uncredited) |
 | Mira McKinney | ... | Lady behind Gloves at auction (uncredited) |
 | George Meeker | ... | Reporter (uncredited) |
 | Ray Montgomery | ... | Reporter (uncredited) |
 | Carl Ottmar | ... | Lichtig, at meeting (uncredited) |
 | Paul Panzer | ... | Waiter (uncredited) |
 | Emory Parnell | ... | Policeman outside warehouse (uncredited) |
 | Bob Perry | ... | Callahan's henchman (uncredited) |
 | Lee Phelps | ... | The turnkey (uncredited) |
 | Otto Reichow | ... | Muller, meeting admittance guard (uncredited) |
 | Cyril Ring | ... | Reporter (uncredited) |
 | Mary Servoss | ... | Woman (uncredited) |
 | Charles Sherlock | ... | Ebbing's henchman (uncredited) |
 | John Sinclair | ... | Ebbing's henchman (uncredited) |
 | John Stark | ... | Ebbing's henchman (uncredited) |
 | Charles Sullivan | ... | Callahan's henchman (uncredited) |
 | Don Turner | ... | Policeman (uncredited) |
 | Philip Van Zandt | ... | Assistant auctioneer (uncredited) |
 | Henry Victor | ... | Meeting receptionist (uncredited) |
 | Frederick Vogeding | ... | Doctor, at meeting (uncredited) |
 | Regina Wallace | ... | Woman (uncredited) |
 | Billy Wayne | ... | Chef #2 at Charlie's Restaurant (uncredited) |
 | Leo White | ... | Chef #1 at Charlie's Restaurant (uncredited) |
 | Lottie Williams | ... | Lottie, the flower vendor (uncredited) |
 | Charles C. Wilson | ... | Police lieutenant at Miller's Home Bakery (uncredited) |
 | Wolfgang Zilzer | ... | Frascher, spy asked to steal plans (uncredited) |
A very funny war era movie. Bogart had played a gangster in comedies (Brother Orchid with Edward J. Robinson), but played it straight as a tough guy. This movie highlighted Bogart's great comedic timing which was also evident in harder edged movies from the same period: The Big Sleep, Casablanca, and the Maltese Falcon. All Through the Night makes a fun companion piece to these movies and like the others, has a great supporting cast.