The Story of Shirley Yorke (1948) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Dinah and Derek in delirious drama
Greensleeves8 July 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Upper crust Dinah Sheridan is naive enough to believe that raffish Derek Farr loves her for herself and not for Daddy's money, but behind her back the bounder is playing the field. When he gets shipped off to the colonies to fight he promises to write but Daddy has the dashed bad luck to die on a fox-hunt and it turns out the old boy was heavily in debt. With no further word from Derek and the mansion sold off to pay the debts what's a poor gel to do but tramp the streets of London looking for a job? After falling in front of some traffic she is deposited in a Lyons corner house by a good old London Bobby where she meets formidable Matron Margaretta Scott who dispenses tea and sympathy and a job at the local hospital. All goes swimmingly for Dinah until she travels to help our boys abroad and bumps into that bounder again, after that it's all downhill until she meets John Robinson (doing his best Noel Coward impersonation) and realises she is in love with him during a game of 'Perfect Pussy' (I'm not making this up). He is working on a miracle drug and gets his chance to try it out on wealthy invalid Beatrix Thomson who although bed bound has been working overtime on the hair and makeup to keep up appearances. Desperately ill Beatrix needs a live in nurse so Dinah moves in to give her the requisite shots much to the chagrin of Mrs Danvers look-alike Barbara Couper. Barbara gives Dinah the evil eye but casts far too friendly an eye over her cousin Beatrix however soon all eyes are on Derek who turns out to be the newly wedded husband of old moneybags Beatrix. Barbara cottons on to the fact that there is more to Dinah and Derek than meets her evil eye and concocts a cunning plan to reveal the truth to bewildered Beatrix. Beatrix has an uncanny ability of being able to impersonate the voice of others at will (both men & women) in fact they are so good you could be forgiven for thinking that the voices are dubbed in. Beatrix puts her talents to good use by phoning Derek and pretending to be Dinah and dastardly Derek is rumbled. Beatrix collapses into a heap with shock and is swiftly finished off with a lethal injection but administered by who? At the coroners court the culprit is revealed and makes a dash for it but no-one gets past policeman Arthur Mullard and the murderer makes a hysterical confession in the dramatic finale.

Well you won't see the likes of this melodrama again stuffed as it is with unlikely coincidences and improbable impersonations. It is also stuffed full of long forgotten stage actors who turn the whole farrago into compulsive entertainment. You simply have to see it!
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
"Danny" Reborn !
howardmorley15 May 2017
I would recommend viewers to see Hitchcock's "Rebecca" (1939) before watching the subject film and marvel at Dame Judith Anderson's immortal portrayal of "Mrs Danvers".In this film Barbara Couper plays the scheming Muriel Peach, cousin of Lady Camber, played by Beatrix Couper.There are obvious parallels which fall short of overt lesbian tendencies portrayed in "Rebecca", more pathological jealousy when Sister Shirley Yorke (Dinah Sheridan) arrives to help her doctor colleague use a new drug he has developed to help multi- millionairess Lady Camber recover.This change of medical personnel puts Muriel Peach's "nose out of joint" and causes friction and professional jealousy.Into the emotional mix Dinah Sheridan comes to tend Lady Camber having been engaged to Gerald Ryton (Derek Farr) before the war but who has now married Lady Camber for her money and become a Lord due to convenient deaths in his family.Previous reviewers have provided the basic user comments which I agree, the long arm of coincidence is stretched in this film.Look out for "Carry On" actor Charles Hawtrey who is given an unaccredited role as a wounded army major recovering in an overseas hospital who "plays" Robert Schumann's Traumerei to cheer up his fellow patients.I was surprised I had never seen this film before as I am an aficionado of 1940's movies, so thank you Youtube for uploading it.When I checked it had a mediocre rating of 5.5 so I have now bumped it up to 7/10.Also it was pleasant to see Margaretta Scott playing Matron Alison Gwynne.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Plodding Remake
malcolmgsw17 May 2015
Warning: Spoilers
This is an extremely undistinguished remake of Lord Cambers Ladies(1932)The film has an exceptionally silly storyline through which Dinah Sheridan has to suffer during the whole turgid time.She is let down twice by nasty cad Derek Farr,She is so deluded that she cannot even believe the reports in the paper of his marriage to a wealthy older woman.She has a responsible job as a nursing sister.then because she is good at her job she is whisked away to treat a sick patient with an untried drug.Of course it turns out that she is the wife of Farr,who has now become Lord Camber,Safe to say that it is not long before he starts making advances to her again.there is one patently absurd scene where the wife impersonates Sheridan on a phone call to her husband to try and trap him.Lets just say the sound editor did a good job.The wife dies by poisoning and Sheridan is accused only to be cleared at the end and finally gets to romance the doctor.It is a very dated period piece.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Call Sister Yorke!!
richardchatten26 December 2019
A shoestring second film version with Dinah Sheridan in the title role of a 1915 play by H.A.Vachell originally called 'The Case of Lady Camber'; remembered today because the earlier version 'Lord Camber's Ladies' (1932) was produced for British International Pictures by a young Alfred Hitchcock.

The shift in emphasis to the nurse (then called Janet King) played in the earlier version by Benita Hume is indicated by the fact that the film is now not only named after her but follows her life before she becomes a nurse and then falls foul of a vengeful & manipulative Miss Danvers figure in the form of Barbara Couper as Lady Camber's cousin Muriel Peach.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Overlooked Classic of 40's British Cinema.
ChetChester21 May 2017
I purchased this as a reduced item in HMV, when there was one near me !. It turned out to be a very watchable drama, reminding me of some of the best of Bette Davis and Joan Crawford of the 40's and 50's. It was also produced at the Nettlefold Studios in Walton-On-Thames, Surrey UK. It certainly deserves a much higher IMDb rating.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Captivating Romantic Melodrama
wilvram7 March 2012
Warning: Spoilers
This is one of several intriguing British films of its era that's been in obscurity for decades, and which most of us must have given up all hope of ever seeing. Three cheers then for Renown Pictures Ltd, who've unearthed a print and brought it out on DVD recently.

It's a very loose adaptation of the play LORD CAMBER'S LADIES, which had been filmed in 1932 and produced, though not directed, by Alfred Hitchcock. This version focuses on ten years in the life of the eponymous heroine; how she is jilted by unfaithful fiancé Gerald Ryton, finds she is penniless after her wealthy father dies broke, discovers her vocation as a nurse, then is betrayed by Gerald for a second time. Later, she's appointed to nurse Lady Camber, who has heart disease and whom it turns out is married to Gerald, who inherited the title off his uncle. Before long , Shirley is accused of murder...

Unashamedly melodramatic, and not afraid to tug on the heartstrings at times, the film holds the interest more than a summary might suggest. The beautiful Dinah Sheridan demonstrates a quiet inner strength as Shirley, and Derek Farr gives one of his stronger performances, making the shallow, opportunistic Ryton a recognisable human character, rather than the stage villain some other actors would have offered. Margaretta Scott is good too, as the kind of authoritative hospital matron whom has long disappeared from British hospitals, and not for the better it seems. Charlie Hawtrey as an army officer was unusual casting though.

More attention could have been devoted to the court scene, which is somewhat rushed, and resolved by one of those theatrical "Yes, I did it!" outbursts, which the writers of the Perry Mason TV series were so fond of. The film is an enjoyable one of its kind however, and it seems it was granted the rare accolade for a Butchers' production of playing as the main feature. The current IMDb rating seems ridiculous; have all those who voted actually seen it?
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Surely, you can't believe Shirley capable of murder.
mark.waltz21 September 2022
Warning: Spoilers
A fantastic 40's melodrama about betrayal and murder has Nurse Yorke (a fabulous Dinah Sheridan) recovering from her own breakdown and going onto take care of the neurotic dying heiress Beatrix Thomson, discovering that her husband is old lover Derek Farr. Absolutely nothing goes on between them, but Thomson's jealous cousin and companion Barbara Couper goes out of her way to make trouble for Sheridan and Farr by playing on Thomson's jealousy which has tragic results.

Dressed in designer outfits but playing the type of characters that Judith Anderson, Gale Sondergaard, Rafaela Ottoano and Mary Nash excelled at, Couper is a fantastic villainess (sounding like Gladys Cooper while physically resembling Anderson), obviously pathologically insane but able to hide it. Margareta Scott is Sheridan's head nurse and confidante, and John Robinson is a doctor in love with Sheridan. Complex but fascinating, and based upon a play which became an early Hitchcock movie, a fabulous metaphor considering his development in transferring Mrs. Danvers from the novel of "Rebecca" to the classic film version. Slow but never boring, this ends in a riveting trial that is truly gripping.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed