Buffalo Dance (1894) User Reviews

Not as interesting or renewing as "Sioux Ghost Dance".

[Boba_Fett1138 · 5/10 · 17 March 2010]

This Edison short got filmed on the same day as "Sioux Ghost Dance", though I have the feeling that that short was the more interesting one. Not just because it was the first (or was it? Guess we can only assume so) but also because of the way how the scene got set up.

Thing I didn't liked too much about this short was that it cut right in into the action and the natives are right in the middle of their dance already when the camera gets switched on. The Indians in it also seem to be very aware of the camera, as they are constantly looking up, right into it. The whole movie just because of that doesn't feel very natural or interesting.

They again used some real native, that were part of the Buffalo Bill's Wild West show. Unlike "Sioux Ghost Dance", the names of the performers are actually known by their native names Last Horse, Parts His Hair and Hair Coat. Guess all the cool names already were taken when they were born.

Not that interesting and also not as renewing or well set up, especially when you compare it to "Sioux Ghost Dance".

5/10

http://bobafett1138.blogspot.com/

Wild west on film

[jluis1984 · 6/10 · 17 May 2007]

In the year of 1972, former soldier and frontiersman "Buffalo" Bill Cody decided to enter show business by creating a traveling company dedicated to perform little plays based on his very own adventures while living in the wild west. 11 years later, in 1883, what started as a little company would become the "Buffalo Bill's Wild West" show, an enormous spectacle conceived as a Western-themed circus where Buffalo Bill and company would perform many stunts or shows and bring the experience of the Wild West to the East. Soon Buffalo Bill's show became the most popular attraction of the 19th Century and so, in 1894, members of his show were invited to Thomas Alva Edison's "Black Maria" in order to participate in the making of Kinetoscope films about the show. The legendary "Buffalo Bill's Wild West" show was now part of cinema history.

"Buffalo Dance" is one of several movies done by members of Buffalo Bill's show in those days. What makes this one stand out is that its one of the two (along "Sioux Ghost Dance") done about the Native Americans of the show, as the shooting of the two films (on September 24, 1894) represents the first time Native Americans appeared on film. As the title implies, this movie shows three Sioux Indians performing the "Buffalo Dance", while two others appear in the background playing the music with their drums. The Buffalo dance seems to be more ancient than the ritual Ghost Dance, and this movie captures it in a very good and detailed way, making it an invaluable source about Native Americans in that period (it also helps that the footage has survived in pretty good condition).

As it has been pointed out many times by critics and historians, it's pretty interesting how the dancers instinctively stare at the camera, truly surprised by it and probably wondering about the point of performing the dance in front of a device like that (film camera's wouldn't become common until 1895). Unlike "Sioux Ghost Dance", this movie captures the dance in a better way than the other movie, in part because the number of dancers is considerably minor, but also because director William K.L. Dickson (inventor of the Kinetoscope) makes a better use of his camera to capture the event. According to the noted on Edison's catalog, the dancers were known as Hair Coat, Parts His Hair and Last Horse; those were the names of the very first Sioux in the history of cinema. 6/10

This brief Buffalo Dance from the kinetoscope of Edison was a fascinating find on Internet Archive

[tavm · 6/10 · 18 August 2008]

Well, here's another early film from The Edison Company that depicts something that was popular during that time. In this case, it's the "Buffalo Dance" as we see three American Indians dancing in the Black Maria studio seemingly conscious of being on camera the whole time while two other of their tribe are playing instruments-drums-as accompaniment. They're all from "Buffalo Bill's Wild West Show", the one chronicled in Irving Berlin's Broadway show and movie Annie Get Your Gun where Annie Oakley and Frank Butler fight and fall in love. Since this is only a few seconds, my rating is mainly based on how fascinating a document this was and how audiences might have reacted when they watched this on their kinetoscopes-those peepshow machines that you twirl on one side that are probably still available for viewing at Walt Disney World for a penny. I just found this on Internet Archive. Probably the earliest thing I've reviewed here on IMDb.

Probably Entertaining To Its Original Viewers, Interesting For Different Reasons Now

[Snow Leopard · 9 January 2006]

As one of several features that the Edison Company made of performers from the Buffalo Bill Wild West exhibition, this was probably interesting to its original viewers as a chance to see a more or less authentic 'Indian dance'. As is often the case with the earliest movies, it's of interest now mainly for other reasons.

Like the companion feature "Sioux Ghost Dance" made at the same time, this movie shows several Sioux performing one of their rituals for the camera. This "Buffalo Dance" differs slightly in having only three dancers, while two others accompany them with drums.

What stands out in this one is the unfeigned interest in the camera that the dancers show, frequently staring right at it. It certainly doesn't seem to fit in with the dance itself, and it looks like an unintended but honest reaction to being filmed - which was just as novel an experience for these Sioux as it would have been for anyone else at the time.

These frequent stares at the camera, plus the somewhat artificial background of Edison's 'Black Maria' studio, make it hard to determine to what degree the movie portrays the dance as it would have been done on its own. But it does give this little feature a point of interest.

Native-Americans show off their moves...

[kobe1413 · 1/10 · 14 July 2014]

Partners W.K.L. Dickson and William Heise filmed this seventeen-second short for Edison Laboratories. They filmed three Native-American dancers recreating what the title call "the Buffalo Dance".

Not much to recommend here as a film, other than its dubious value as a cultural artifact. These Native-Americans are obviously performers, so it is hard to determine the authenticity of their wardrobe and movements. This film may be more of how the white filmmakers Heise and Dickson viewed Native-Americans. I do like how one of the dancers never takes his eyes off of the camera, staring it down as he dances.

I rate it a 2 out of 10.

Indian culture 120 years ago

[Horst_In_Translation · 2/10 · 4 September 2013]

It's basically 15 seconds of Indians (one of them quite a porker) dancing to another Indian playing the drums. This one was released in 1894, just like the Dickson Experimental Sound Film, even pretty much at the same time month-wise. Sadly we have no sound in here. Otherwise it might have been easier to go back in time in our minds and feel the vibe the Indians were getting during the production of this little short film.

What I find most interesting about it is how one of the three dancers is clearly interacting with the camera and the viewer. He seems to have understood this new medium much more than the other two who are basically just doing their show as if nobody else was in the room.

A slice of American History

[PeterJordan · 25 February 2003]

Another clip from the shots taken on September 24th 1894 in Edison's Black Maria studio with William Heise behind the camera. This 15 second (20 fps) clip features the three named Native American dancers (from Buffalo Bill Cody's Wild West Show) plus three drummers. It is interesting to note that the three dancers are particulary aware of the camera and appear to act to it on occasion, although this may be merely a feature of the Buffalo dance itself or quite possibly under receipt of direction from Movies first ever acting coach/director behind the camera.

Nice History

[Michael_Elliott · 19 April 2009]

Buffalo Dance (1894)

*** (out of 4)

Another interesting piece of history, this Edison short runs just fifteen-seconds but it's very entertaining. We see three Indians doing a "buffalo dance", which was a ritual they'd do as part of the "Buffalo Bill Wild West Show". I'm sure fans back in the day got a great kick (and laughter) out of seeing this but the movie remains interesting today just as a part of history. It's great seeing an actual show of what people back in the day were watching and with that in mind, this is the main reason why I love watching these older films. Those expecting some ground breaking action will be disappointed but silent film buffs will be entertained.

Better than Sioux Ghost Dance, if somewhat cartoonish

[cricket30 · 30 January 2013]

I have been to many pow wows in real life, but I have never seen a Native American dancer with a giant set of black tail feathers sticking up from his butt a mile high like the chunky dancer in this short Edison film. The other two dancers have more recognizable feather gear, in the form of about two head feathers each. The dancer in the forefront most often takes a lower, almost snakish approach to his performance, which put me in mind of some of the old Warners Brothers cartoons portraying Native Americans as savages who could slither like eels to sneak up on the white folk that we used to watch in the trailer growing up when the babysitter was over. Ten generations of kids have been exposed to those cartoons, which you still can buy sets of in the dollar stores for a buck, so it stands to reason that the original animators of these films may have been drawn from the preceding five generations of kids who were exposed to these Edison Kinetographs growing up. I guess therez a saying that what goes around comes around.

P.S.--Drummers never get any respect. I know from my pow wow experience that Native Americans do not dance without drumming, but from the information on this site you would have no idea that there are 2 NI drummers behind the 3 dancers in this flick!

Second Filming of Native Americans

[Tornado_Sam · 20 December 2017]

"Buffalo Dance" is actually one of two 15-second documentaries shot the same day by the Edison company, starring members of the Sioux tribe. (The other one, not to be confused with this one, is "Sioux Ghost Dance"of the same year). Together, both films helped make up a much bigger output of a series of movies starring performers from Buffalo Bill's Wild West Show, of which this routine was no doubt part of. Reportedly, this series of Wild West performance acts (including sharpshooter Annie Oakley, show manager Buffalo Bill and others) was not only used to promote the show further in America, where it had already become quite popular, but Europe in addition, where film distribution was beginning to blossom. (I assume these movies were among the first Kinetoscope shows shown in Europe at the time; it would not be until a year or so later when Robert Paul would introduce the invention further in England). The performance here starring native Americans Hair Coat, Parts His Hair, and Last Horse is not only of true Indians, it also provides a glimpse into the rituals and dances frequently performed by the Sioux at the time. In this case, the short dance routine was probably a ritual performed by warriors or hunters before going hunting their prey, as a sort of superstition that the 'spirits' they believed it (whoever they were) would bring them success. In that sense, it's interesting to watch this type of thing to get a sense about the Indian rituals of the time period.

Additionally, while both films tend to be put together in their own special grouping since both feature native Americans, there is no doubt plenty of difference between the two. In the case of "Sioux Ghost Dance", the performance filmed includes a larger variety of Indians, from small children to older adults. Little recognition of the camera seems to take place, and as a result of the amount of performers, none of them appear to have any space to move around in. With "Buffalo Dance", the performers are warriors; there are only three of them, thus giving them more space to move in, and an additional detail of a drummer providing accompaniment in included. One of the most interesting aspects of this particular short is not the costumes or the dance itself, but the way the youngest Indian stares the camera down, smiling in the most amusing way as if someone told a joke or as if he thinks everything's just a big put-on.

This particular routine performed by the Indians was no doubt only among the many acts they did as part of the show. Edison probably neglected to film some of the more active performances put on by the natives, such as hunting, horse-riding contests and other various feats of skill. Either way, to see real Indians from over a hundred years ago is a blessing in itself, since today films like these serve as historical artifacts more than entertainment because of being the only known filmed records of native American life. Certainly this would make it worth watching.