User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Edgar Kennedy back in the director's chair!
JohnHowardReid27 January 2007
Australian director Alf Goulding who made the wonderful Tip Tap Toe (1932) here has an amusing hit at Poverty Row producers whose only concern was making a movie with a minimum number of slates. Natty little Nat Carr is the perfect Poverty prototype who insists that Edgar shoot each set-up with a minimum of two takes. He doesn't mind if Edgar takes all day because the cast and crew are hired by the day, not the hour. His petty concerns are limited to the amount of raw film stock used. Hence, a maximum of two takes.

Bungling, impatient Edgar, of course, goes about his task the wrong way and starts shooting almost as soon as he sits in the chair, instead of rehearsing for hours and playing about with dummy camera runs. And the star, naturally, resents Edgar's elevation—a fact that is also delightfully true-to-life. On a movie set, the assistant director has nothing at all to do with the stars who receive instructions solely from the principal director. Stars despise assistant directors and here Miss Temperament has to be coaxed into accepting Edgar by the executive producer.

After mollifying his star, the executive producer hurries off and we don't see him again until near the end of the day—again true-to-life.

It's a pity we are not shown more of the mechanics of movie-making (we see loads of the clapper-boy but the hairdresser, the make-up man and even the photographer don't get a look-in, though we do glimpse a couple of the operators) but at 19 minutes there's not time for everything.

The comedy mostly revolves around the device of having Edgar's idiot family visit the set and continually disrupt shooting. This is most definitely not true-to-life, but, as these incidents induce more than a few laughs, I don't suppose many patrons will object.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
With a family like this, I'd direct myself to divorce court!
mark.waltz31 August 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Dizzy, nonstop chatty wife; Obnoxious brother-in-law; Harridan mother-in-law at home, and a temperamental leading lady at work has short tempered assistant director Edgar Kennedy on the verge of exploding. He can't sleep in at home after working late, and when he's called in to actually direct a scene, dealing with all of these issues has him on edge. Kennedy's character is somebody everybody can relate to, exaggerated of course, but we all have those days. The family disrupts his set, completely oblivious to the fact that if a success, his character could go further as a Hollywood director. Florence Lake flitters like a swarm of chirping wren's, cute to look at, but torture over a long period of time. The stereotypes work here because his life is supposed to be a complete exaggeration, one dimensional but total parody. Kennedy gets a lot of laughs just by reacting in different ways, each one funnier than the last.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Lights! Camera! Mayhem!
ExplorerDS67899 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
What happens when Edgar Kennedy becomes a director? Well, technically, he was a director for a while during the silent era, and at least he didn't have an annoying family hounding him at every turn, but times have since changed. Edgar and his family have moved to Hollywood where he's an assistant director for Magnet Pictures, and they've got a real diva of a starlet giving everyone a hard time on set, so much so that the director's had a nervous breakdown. Now who's going to finish the picture? Well, just after Edgar's family gives a him a hard time about how they want to see a picture made and figure he'll never make it as a director, the producer calls up and asks Edgar to direct the last scene on the movie they're making. Brother ends up volunteering him, then Florence and Mother provide Edgar with a new set of clothes they'd procured for when he would finally be a director: riding britches, a beret, and even a bullhorn. So, Cecil B. Kennedy reluctantly goes to the studio to pick up where the director had left off. I like how the producer tells him that "a good director never takes a scene more than twice." Just wait til this guy gets a load of Stanley Kubrick. And I also love how every time Edgar tries to take a scene, his family interrupts by trying to enter the set. Yeah, they gained access to the lot by taking Edgar's studio pass and simply added "& Family" in front of his name. Pretty sure that wouldn't fly in real life, they would've had a better chance sneaking in behind Milton Berle. Some security this lot has, as they can't stop three troublemakers from entering a sound stage, which isn't even a sound stage if they can hear racket from outside. I realize Edgar is only a novice director, but I'm surprised he doesn't try to rehearse the scene before rolling the cameras. Had he done that, his family wouldn't have blown two takes already. It's not until after those idiots force their way onto the set does Edgar make an attempt to have his actors rehearse. Once that's done, they're ready to roll... until Mother in-law recognizes Carol Bonet and barges on set to ask for her autograph. Despite Edgar saying she's temperamental and seeing how she treated the producer, she must be a hell of a lot nicer than she's lets on, as she signs Mother in-law's autograph booklet. I mean, I know there are plenty of nice stars in Hollywood like, say, Tom Hanks, but I'm pretty sure if a fan burst on set and asked him for an autograph while he was rehearsing a scene, he'd tell them to hit the road.

The next take goes bad because Mother ended up sitting on a camera crane that ascended at a crucial moment, then the next take was blown because Brother switched on a giant fan, blowing papers all over the place. He scampers away up a scaffolding to hide from Edgar, and when a 1000 watt light is requested, Brother drops a bulb on him. It's time like these that I decide to start asking logical questions, like why on earth doesn't Edgar simply call studio security and have his family arrested for trespassing? I know they have a forged pass, but just simply adding "Family" to it wouldn't fly. I'll bet you no other director in movie history would tolerate what Edgar's going through. You think James Cameron would stay quiet if his family crashed the set of Titanic? Suppose Orson Welles' in-laws got in his way while filming Citizen Kane? What if the mechanical shark in Jaws wasn't Steven Spielberg's only headache if he had some annoying relatives hounding him on set? Yes, I know this is just a comedy short, but if you drill enough holes into the logic, then it comes a little hard to tolerate. Well, speaking of Titanic, the production of Edgar's movie was sinking fast. Finally, on take 52, the film was able to proceed. Makes me wonder how they family fumbled every other take before that. Well, being Edgar's family, I'm sure they found a way. That's when the producer comes on set to see how they're doing. See, he's determined to get this movie finished by 5:00 or Miss Bonet would receive a $10,000 bonus. Ha, well, if time and money were of the essence, why didn't Edgar rehearse the scene before filming, and why couldn't he bar his family from set? Well, it's not HIS money being spent, but it is his job. Anyway, how do you think this take went? Surprisingly well, Edgar could frame and take a decent lovemaking scene between a guy and a gal... unfortunately, Brother soon got the drop on them. Literally. Then the set erupts into a frenzy as we see some really terrible fight choreography. Look at those punches. I've seen children play-punch each other in a more convincing way. Oh, and guess what? Edgar gets fired. I'm also guessing Carol Bonet walked away from set ten grand richer. Hopefully she thanked Edgar for that.

This short, among many of Edgar's early Average Man shorts are much more frustrating to watch, because the family is more annoying. Basically all the damage done here is their fault. I know Edgar made a lousy director and the studio security were as effective as a wall made of toilet paper, but you just can't fathom how annoying and entitled these jerks are. It starts at the very beginning of the short, where Edgar had a tough night and asked to sleep in, only for his noisy neighbors to wake him up. He's even taken up drinking, as evidenced by all the empty beer bottles on the front porch... either that, or they were just renting a house from W.C. Fields. Mother in-law was on a kick about getting autographs, and I think we can see where I Love Lucy drew inspiration for their Hollywood episodes. I mean, can you imagine what would've happened if Ricky were chosen to direct a picture and Lucy kept crashing the set and causing trouble? I know there was one episode where Lucy had a chance to be in a movie, but she kept upstaging her co-stars because she wanted the spotlight. Well, sir, Ricky would've put her over his knee and played Babaloo on her fanny, something Edgar should've done with Florence. No, I don't condone spousal abuse, but for crying out loud, he needed some cajones here. The nerve of that family thinking they were entitled to see a movie made. Maybe Edgar should rent a camera and film his own movie, starring his family: the very first snuff film. In closing, do I recommend Wrong Direction? Well, I mean it's alright. If you like Edgar Kennedy and films from the 1930s, then you'd enjoy this. But be prepared to chuck logic out the window. Going back to what I said about Kennedy being a real director during the silent era, I think a lot of the problems presented for him here would've been solved had it been a silent movie they were filming. Chaplain and Keaton sure had it easy when making their movies.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Just too loud and unpleasant...
planktonrules21 June 2011
Starting a couple years earlier, RKO began a long series of short films featuring Edgar Kennedy and his family--consisting of his wife (Florence Lake), mother-in-law and brother-in-law. And while Kennedy was quite good, the wife and family were over-written. In other words, the characters came on way too strong--making you hate them and wonder who would ever put up with such hateful and obnoxious people?! I mentioned Lake in particular because her shtick was defending her awful mother and brother no matter what they did AND laughing like a brain-addled idiot throughout the film. She was SO annoyingly unfunny I can't believe the series continued until Kennedy's death in 1948!

Like several of the other films in the series I've seen, this one is too difficult to watch because the family is so awful you just want to see them die--and you wonder why Edgar doesn't just kill them--I know I would have!! It begins with Edgar playing a guy much like himself--an actor and assistant director (yes, he actually directed some films). He gets his big break when the studio asks him to direct the final portion of the film by himself. However, his god-awful family invite themselves to the studio and repeatedly ruin the picture. Their antics might have been cute in smaller doses, but they were such uncaring and terrible people that I think it just went too far (once again) and the comedy got overwhelmed by the nastiness of these characters. Had they toned it down a bit, it might have worked--but here it just lacks any semblance of subtlety or grace. Loud and unpleasant much of the time. Kennedy does the best with what he's got, but even Laurel & Hardy would have had a hard time making this one work.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
What An Annoying Family
Michael_Elliott20 March 2016
Wrong Direction (1934)

* 1/2 (out of 4)

Edgar Kennedy plays a movie director who is trying to get some sleep at home but his annoying wife (Florence Lake), mother-in-law (Dot Farley) and brother-in-law (William Eugene) won't allow that. Soon he's called to the set for his big break. He needs to get one scene done or else the studio will lose a lot of money. Edgar is up for the job but soon his family shows up and chaos follows.

WRONG DIRECTION is another entry in the "Average Guy" series from RKO where Kennedy played the husband constantly being tortured by his relatives. For the most part this series was rather annoying because the family itself was just so stupid, so hated and so mean that you couldn't really get any entertainment from them. I know the family was made stupid to make you feel bad for Edgar, which you do but at the same time there simply aren't any laughs to be had here. There are just two funny moments here and one comes from a murder gag at the start of the picture and then a fight towards the end.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed