. . . there probably are not very many people alive today who will split hairs arguing about the merits of Hornbacker OR Murphy, since they were pushing geezer-hood in 1894 and are most likely dead today. (In fact, when you do the math, less than a couple dozen of the billions of people alive in the 1800s are still kicking today, and EVERYONE born in the 1700s has bit the dust already; something to think about, since our 1900s come next!) The talking head guy from Yale says that world heavyweight champ Corbett's bout against some dude named Courtney was the highest-grossing kinetoscope (Edison peep show) flick of all time, making Corbett himself $15,000 in film royalties. Whichever of the two boxers in THIS film happens to be Eugene Hornbacker (the DVD gives no clue) is sleep-walking compared to Corbett, and probably got $15 from notorious tightwad Tom Edison (if they were lucky). As the man from Yale notes, prior to T.A. Edison trying to move America into concrete houses (sounds a lot like cemetery vaults!), his film company set the tone for U.S. movies for all time: his 1894-95 shorts were all about sex, strippers, and violence (while Frenchmen, such as Lumiere, focused on moms, family, and patriotic sights). Though there's little violence or sex in THE HORNBACKER-MURPHY FIGHT, there's even less of mom and apple pie!
3 Reviews
Packs A Lot Of Action Into A Brief Running Time
Snow Leopard29 November 2005
This short boxing feature by the Edison Company catches a lot of action in a very brief running time, although the level of skill demonstrated by the two boxers is not particularly impressive. It's certainly true that much of this is probably attributable to the styles of the time, but it is also the case that these were two nondescript athletes who would long ago have been forgotten if the Edison Company had not made this movie of them.
Boxing films were one of the first genres of movies to attain widespread popularity, and this one followed the format used for a number of features of the era, with the two boxers fighting an exhibition match of five rounds of 20 seconds each. It looks as if only one round has survived.
Eugene Hornbacker was little known, and of Murphy not even his first name has been recorded. Neither boxer seems to know how to do much except to flail away as hard as possible, but it does make for a lot of whirlwind activity. The background is also interesting, with several spectators looking on in what was likely a staged arrangement. The referee also takes an active role in directing the match.
This feature was included in one of Kino's excellent collections of early movies, but it was unfortunately shown under an incorrect title, and was erroneously labeled as a Glenroy Brothers movie. With the apparent help of film historian Charles Musser, they repaired the mistake in their more recent DVD collection of Edison Company features, in which this is included as an extra, under its proper title. (This later Edison collection also includes a genuine Glenroy Brothers feature.)
Boxing films were one of the first genres of movies to attain widespread popularity, and this one followed the format used for a number of features of the era, with the two boxers fighting an exhibition match of five rounds of 20 seconds each. It looks as if only one round has survived.
Eugene Hornbacker was little known, and of Murphy not even his first name has been recorded. Neither boxer seems to know how to do much except to flail away as hard as possible, but it does make for a lot of whirlwind activity. The background is also interesting, with several spectators looking on in what was likely a staged arrangement. The referee also takes an active role in directing the match.
This feature was included in one of Kino's excellent collections of early movies, but it was unfortunately shown under an incorrect title, and was erroneously labeled as a Glenroy Brothers movie. With the apparent help of film historian Charles Musser, they repaired the mistake in their more recent DVD collection of Edison Company features, in which this is included as an extra, under its proper title. (This later Edison collection also includes a genuine Glenroy Brothers feature.)
The Boxing Genre Continues
Tornado_Sam14 November 2017
By the time "The Hornbacker-Murphy Fight" had come out, the boxing genre for the Edison company appears to have gone into decline. In their earliest camera tests, boxing was a frequent subject they used for mock demonstrations performed by amateurs; the genre had given rise when some of the most famous boxers of the day got called to the Black Maria studio to be filmed (such as Mike Leonard, Jack Cushing and James Corbett); and now, having run out of popular boxers, the company was forced to shoot matches between little-remembered champions. Murphy (his last name hasn't been put in the record), appears to be in this case the underdog, with Hornbacker probably being the championship boxer since his full name is documented. Additionally, while only one round survives there was probably originally five or six; and once more, from the footage here, their isn't any way to know who won.
The Edison company would eventually drop the boxing genre by 1895, with their last known recorded match (at least to my knowledge) to have been "Billy Edwards and the Unknown". I've got no proof or anything, but I could at least say that the reason this was so was probably because more companies (like Lumière) had started shooting subjects on location and the black backgrounds of the Black Maria were getting a little tiresome. By 1896, this was finally the case with Edison too, some prime examples being "Shooting the Shoots" and "Mess Call", both of that year.
The Edison company would eventually drop the boxing genre by 1895, with their last known recorded match (at least to my knowledge) to have been "Billy Edwards and the Unknown". I've got no proof or anything, but I could at least say that the reason this was so was probably because more companies (like Lumière) had started shooting subjects on location and the black backgrounds of the Black Maria were getting a little tiresome. By 1896, this was finally the case with Edison too, some prime examples being "Shooting the Shoots" and "Mess Call", both of that year.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
