"Buffy the Vampire Slayer" The Killer in Me (TV Episode 2003) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A fairly average episode
katierose2958 September 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Kennedy is really annoying, but even she can't completely ruin "The Killer in Me." It isn't the most thrilling BTVS episode, but it does have some important moments in it. It finally gets that chip out of Spike's head and it gives Willow a chance to address some of her unresolved issues surrounding Tara's death. Plus, it proves that Giles isn't the first. (Although, he does act weird this whole season. I'm still half-way convinced that he's a robot. It happens. See "Angel" season five's "Lineage.") Basically, you could skip this episode and not miss a lot of the story arc. But, it will play into some character development stuff later on.

"The Killer in Me" revolves around Spike and Willow. Spike's chip is malfunctioning. It keeps misfiring, shocking him even when he's laying perfectly still. Buffy is concerned that Spike might die. She tries to contact Riley, thinking that he and the government can help. Meanwhile Giles takes that Potentials out on that First Slayer vision quest thing. (He took Buffy on one, too, back in season five's "Intervention.") And Willow and Kennedy end up on a date together. When Kennedy kisses Willow, though, Will turns into Warren. She looks just like him and she panics. After telling all the Scoobies to let her fix the problem her way, she goes to UC Sunnydale's Wicca group for help. (They were last seen in season four's "Hush.") Bufy and Spike head to the Initative to look for pain killers for his chip problem. Riley's men find them there and offer Buffy a choice: take the chip out or repair it.

Meanwhile, The Scoobies to worry that Giles might really be the First. No one can remember him touching anything recently. Anya, Xander, Dawn and Andrew head out into the desert to investigate. They find Giles and tackle him, proving that he's Giles. Willow sinks deeply into Warren, taking on his personality traits. Kennedy realizes that Amy is behind the spell and tries to fight her. Amy teleports Kennedy into the Summers' backyard, just as Willow storms up with a gun... Just like Warren did in season six's "Seeing Red." She threatens to shoot Kennedy for killing "her" and it soon becomes clear that this is all about Tara. Willow feels guilty for finally accepting Tara's death and Amy's spell is feeding off of it. Kennedy comforts Willow as she dissolves into tears.

There are some good parts to this episode. I think Warren and Willow switching back and forth works really well. The two of them do a great job of sounding and acting alike. It's especially fun when "Warren" is trying to deal with Andrew, Xander and Buffy all at once. And I'm glad to see Amy again. It's a shame that she and Willow don't get a real show down in this episode, but it's cool that the show brought her back. Too bad she didn't recognize "Warren," since they all went to high school together for a semester. Maybe Warren enrolled during the time Amy was a rat. I also like Anya, Dawn, Xander and Andrew going on a car trip together. I wish that Xander and Andrew had more scenes together. Because their shared interests in comics and sci-fi movies is just funny. Xander tries to ignore Andrew, but the kid is winning everybody over. "If you don't take me along, I'm going to do something evil." And when they finally tackle Giles and realize that he's corporeal, you just have to laugh. "You think I'm evil if I take girls camping and DON'T touch them?" Finally, I'm REALLY happy that Spike finally got his chip-ectomy.

On the down side, the Initative never gave Spike any pain killers for the chip in his head. He didn't even know that he HAD the chip until he attacked Willow in her dorm room in season four's "The Initative." If there had been pain killers that allowed him to bypass the shocks, wouldn't Spike have gone looking for them before now? Like back when he was desperate to remain evil and kill the Scoobies? Also, didn't the general guy in "Primeval" say that the Initative's whole facility was going to be covered in cement? What happened to that plan? Why can Spike and Buffy just walk right in? And where is this entrance suppose to be? It isn't the back way into the Initative that Spike and the Scoobies used in "New Moon Rising" or the front way through the frat house that Riley and the guys always used.

Also, I just don't like Kennedy. She's a pushy, annoying and know-it-all. Willow could do better. Honestly, I don't think that Willow should have relationship at all this season. Tara was her life. Their connection was so deep that Willow's grief nearly destroyed the world. And now this bratty Potential comes along and Willow just starts dating again? I'm not buying it. Tara and Willow got each other's jokes, shared an interest in magic, adored each other completely, and it would take more than a few months for Willow to recover from her death enough to even notice another woman..

My favorite part of the episode: Spike and Buffy's "Who ya gonna call?" conversation. "God, that phrase is never gonna be usable again is it?" I just like the idea of a 120-something vampire and the Slayer both having seen the movie "Ghostbusters."
40 out of 53 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Guilt trips
ossie8515 September 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Three storylines for this episode, with the major one being Willow physically turning into Warren. Spike's chip is now hurting him all the time and Buffy tries to contact Riley for help. Xander and the others get a call that suggests Giles maybe dead and he is actually The First.

Why It's So Good - The finest Greenberg script to date and a continuity fest with so many previous episodes involved. But the highlight of the episode is Willow's guilt both around her killing Warren, and moving on after Tara. And hats off to Adam Busch for a great effort this week. His character of Warren is rightfully hated, but that is actually a complement to Busch's performance.

Watch Out For - Giles getting in trouble for going to a camp and not touching the girls.

Quote - "There are other stories from kindergarten. Non yellow crayon stories in which you don't come out in such a good light. An incident involving Aquaman underoos, for example. You want me to start talking?" - Willow/Warren to Xander.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Amy's back
Joxerlives14 May 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Oh my god, this is ep 135, we're into single figures left!

The Good; Always lovely to see Amy again, sadly her last appearance although she's back in the comics. Nice subplot with 'Is Giles the First?' and some creepy stuff in the old Initiative, very Halloween (the movie not the ep).

The Bad; I find the whole Willow/Kennedy storyline not that involving frankly and I'm normally a Willow fan. Rather ruins the surprise reveal of Amy when EAA's name is in the titles.

Best line; Spike; "Who you gonna call? You know that's never going to be usable again, is it?" (tell that to the 118 118 boys!) but also like; Initiative officer (of Spike) "We're here to help ass-face (noting Buffy's look) Those were agent Finn's exact words"

Women good/men bad; Pretty much all the Warren stuff

Jeez!; Will slapping Amy is shocking

Kinky dinky; When Buffy tries to tell the Initiative that Spike's 'chip' is malfunctioning they seem to think she's referring to something else. Andrew grabs Will's breasts, he and Dawn take the opportunity to feel up Willow/Warren and all the Scoobs grope Giles in the final scene. Giles is affronted that the Scoobes think he's evil because he'd take a group of nubile teenage girls on a camping trip and NOT touch them. Xander appears to wear Aquaman underwear, how does Willow know this? Amy's top is very revealing, I never appreciated how hot she was until this ep.

Captain Subtext; One big lesbian seduction of Willow by Kennedy. Kennedy says that Willow is sexy when she pouts, quite true. Kennedy presumes Willow is gay but Will never actually says so. She asks how long has she enjoyed sex with women (well doesn't EVERYONE?). Interestingly Will says she didn't fall in love with WOMEN but with one WOMAN. Will's mum hardly met Tara. Kennedy says she was first attracted to women when she was five (!) after watching Rhett sweep Scarlett up the staircase in Gone with the Wind. This scene is widely considered to be marital rape but then as a potential Slayer Kennedy has that dark sexual side we see in Faith and Buffy and in 'Get it done' we find out why. Note that Kennedy wishes to play the Rhett role who's the sexual aggressor just as Kennedy is courting Willow. Kennedy tells Willow she doesn't worry about her "Being too butch". More signs of Andrew and Xander bonding, love Anya and Dawn's little look at him. Dawn and Anya snuggle under a blanket. So, does Amy actually have a gay crush on Willow and is this all the result of jealousy? Certainly Amy at the end seems to be coming on to Kennedy, saying "You must be good" after the revelation about the kiss. Kennedy thinks Willow's freckles are 'lickable'.

Guantanamo Bay; The Initiative's new front is a flower shop, what is it with Buffy and florists?

Missing scenes; Presumably around this time Dawn receives her phonecall from Angelus but we never see it. Also the Scoobies never seem to notice the eternal darkness in LA or Jasmine but then they have their own worries.

Scoobies in bondage: Spike continues to keep himself chained up

Kills: one demon for Buffy

Scoobies go evil: Willow, big time Giles: 1 Cordy: 1 Will: 4 Jenny: 1 Angel: 1 Oz: 1 Joyce: 1 Xander: 4 Anya; 1 Dawn; 1 Buffy; 1 Spike; 1

Alternate scoobies: Willow as Warren Buffy: 8 Giles: 4 Cordy: 1 Will: 6 Jenny: 2 Angel: 3 Oz: 2 Joyce: 2 Xander: 4 Tara; 1 Dawn;1 Spike; 1 Anya; 2

What the fanficcers thought; Read an interesting one where Willow's guilt manifest's itself differently, she's visited by Warren every night and he cuts skin from her body. In the follow up story she forgives him and then forgives herself, making him disappear and only dreaming of Tara from then on 'Deserving'. Another good one has Willow confronting Amy and we find out that this is all due to an unrequited gay crush from Amy for Willow. Amy tries to stab Will with her Bringer dagger and Xander shoots Amy with the gun Willow-as-Warren bought. She collapses and dies in the arms of a tearful Willow 'Catch me if I fall'.

Questions and observations; Weird to see flashbacks all the way back to season 4, seems a world away. SMG seems rather hoarse in the first scene. The series seems to be running out of money to judge by the commentary, all that CGI expensive. It strikes me that Spike has moved into the basement just as Xander moves out. Robson the Watcher has survived, the Watcher's Council is not entirely gone and can help Buffy and co in season 8. Shouldn't Xander pack some weapons when he heads off to the desert?

So is Amy working with the First (she uses it's catchphrase, 'It's about power')? But when she talks to Kennedy she seems to not even to be evil, that this is petty jealousy of Willow. OR maybe she's bitter at Willow having killed Rack and left Amy to have painful rehab on her own?

Is the leader of the Initiative team the same guy from the series The Unit? What a shame they couldn't have got Graham back. In the end where we see Warren weeping and saying "I'm sorry baby" is he actually grieving for Katrina?
5 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Poor episode and Poor Warren
The_Brave26 February 2008
Once again, the annoying and boring Warren returns to the show. It was an interesting episode for Riley's return, but it was not so. Finally, once again, Warren, the worst character of all seven seasons of "Buffy the Vampire Slayer", is newly the focus of attention.

I will not understand why Riley left the show. He was the one of the Scoobies with everyone could identify easily. He was a great character and Marc Blucas did a good job. His love story with Buffy is powerful and honest. Homewer, in season 6 and seven, the show turns into a kind of parody, with the Trio.

I really did not like the Trio. For me, they were very annoying. And for me is a nightmare have to see again Warren. To my eyes, he's the most stupid character of the show. Nothing to see with other great "Bads", like The Master, Glory, Adam or Drusilla. Warren is a parody. He's a bad for cartoons, not for "Buffy"

Riley would have been at series finale. Without him, the show started to jump the shark.

Producers and writers shouldn't always read all that people says at Internet. For example, Ana Lucia, a character from "Lost" was killed because a lot of fans in Internet hate her. But only a few people that see the show write on Internet. There are a lot more that don't like that events.

Sorry for my bad English.
15 out of 107 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
In defense of another great episode
BuffyTheVampireSlapper21 March 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Sailing against the wind apparently, I have to sing the praises of this episode.

It's a classic Buffy storyline - a supernatural occurrence becomes a metaphor for what a character is going through, a way to act out what they're feeling. So in order to move on from Tara, Willow has to feel like she's finally accepting that Tara has died. She has to put her in the past tense (which she corrects herself over in the Bronze scene). And because of this, she feels like she's killing Tara. And so she becomes Tara's killer (thanks to a hex from Amy that lets the victim's subconscious punish them.)

So many fans are down on season 6, because it was dark and depressing. But that was the whole point of it. And the moment in this episode where Willow turns up in the back yard with the gun... it's spine-tingling. And the way Alyson Hannigan and Adam Busch blend their performances, which become increasingly emotionally charged as Willow wrestles with the fact that Tara is really gone and, is amazing, very well done. "Please baby, I'm so sorry... come back..." it's kind of a surprise when you realize that each actor says half of the line. I'm reminded of when Buffy and Faith swapped bodies and there were a lot of little subtle changes to the Gellar/Dushku performances in the way they mimicked each other.

Okay, to the fans it may seem like Kennedy is brash, arrogant, pushy. But really what she is is emotionally secure and not needy. She's got no idea about magic and stuff. She just knows she likes Willow. Her emotional security is exactly what Willow needs to lean on.

So full marks for Kennedy for being awesome, for Adam and Willow for merging together so well, and for the series for cranking out another 42 minutes of genius out its classic formula. It's not 10/10 simply because we have to have somewhere to go for Hush, don't we?
20 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Lots of stuff going on in this episode.
skay_baltimore10 August 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Giles and the new girls -- sans Kennedy -- go off on a vision quest.

Spike's chip goes on the fritz.

Kennedy reveals that she faked being sick so she could hang around and seduce Willow. Except...after their first kiss...Willow morphs into Warren. Huh, you say? Me too. But not to worry, because, uh...it's like...her subconscious guilt transformed her into the person she killed. Huh, you say? Amy's behind it? Is it really Amy? Amy cast some kind of curse because she was jealous of Willow. Kissing Kennedy -- even just for that one moment -- released the bond between Willow and Tara, and caused Willow pain. Kennedy then kisses Warren to bring Willow back. Magic...oh, what a tangled web...

At 21:24 the Scoobies decide that maybe Giles is The First. By 32:46 they conclude that he's not. So we had to wait 5 episodes to pick up on the cliffhanger ending from "Sleeper" (the weapon zeroing in on Giles's neck) because of some irrelevant stupid sub-plot arc about Giles NOT being The First that took up all of 11:22. And we still don't see how Giles dealt with the attack until the next episode. Totally lame.

"Buffy's Choice" -- To chip, or not to chip? That is the question.
1 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The One Where Willow Becomes Warren...
taylorkingston22 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
I love this episode. It's so interesting. I love to see how the guilt brings Willow to tournament herself, and that may sound cruel, but it just makes for a good episode.

In this episode, Willow and Kennedy share their first kiss. Awww! But then, Willow transforms into Warren. She tries so hard to change back, but she can't. Since she's still wrecked with guilt, she thinks this is her brain's way of punishing her. She tries to find out a way to change and she runs into an old friend, Amy. But it turns out that Amy might've had more to do with the transformation than Willow thinks. Meanwhile, Buffy tries to find out answers and Spike's chip causes him great pain, leading to it being removed. Also, the gang suspect that Giles might actually be The First. Spoiler Alert: He's not, don't worry.

Fun Fact: All of the shows involving Warren-Willow were shot twice, once with Alyson Hannigan and once with Adam Busch.

Overall, I give this episode an 8 out of 10, which in my ratings book is: Awesome.
4 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Willow Shapeshifts Again
Samuel-Shovel15 January 2019
Warning: Spoilers
In "The Killer in Me" a kiss shared between Willow and Kennedy causes Willow to take the form of Warren. The gang tried to figure out how this happened while Giles takes the rest of the Potentials on a spiritual journey into the desert. In the end, it turns out Amy placed a he on Willow for revenge. Buffy helps Spike try to fix the chip in his head as it starts to malfunction.

This is the definition of a filler episode. Spike's subplot arc is mildly entertaining as he attempts to sort out life with a soul. The script's explanation for the Warren/Willow swap is doubtful at best. This episode felt long and meandering.
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Tawdry and tacky
RogerBorg17 October 2019
The love affair between Willow and Tara was slow, gentle, beautiful, respectful, and magical in every sense.

The relationship between Willow and what's-her-name as presented here is forced, exploitative and predatory.

It pisses on the memory of what went before and cheapens the whole Buffyverse.

The rest of the episode is mostly filler, and instantly forgettable.

Poor bloody show.
16 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Willow and Kennedy
exuberantloquacity12 November 2021
This isn't the first time I've written about this: an adult liking a minor in this series. The Potentials are 15, right? Willow is 22. Crikey, Whedon, you've done it again. The whole adult-preying-on-a-child phenomenon appears far too many times in Buffy. Overall, the episode is pretty good. This age thing is the biggest problem with it.
3 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed