"Family Guy" When You Wish Upon a Weinstein (TV Episode 2003) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Not offensive, but just not that good
gizmomogwai22 September 2009
Warning: Spoilers
Family Guy is known for having potentially offensive humour, and this one in particular took a while to actually be aired on television. The concern was that with its storyline and jokes about Jews, the episode would look anti-Semitic. However, Seth MacFarlane claims the script was endorsed by two rabbis as not offensive. Indeed, I agree the episode isn't anti-Semitic; it's not as funny as it should be, however.

The Griffins run into financial problems and Peter becomes convinced that since Jews are known for their skills with finances, he needs a Jewish accountant. He wishes for one with a song and eventually comes across a Jewish accountant named Weinstein, who indeed solves Peter's problems. Impressed with Weinstein's intelligence, Peter reaches the dubious conclusion that converting his son Chris to Judaism will also make him more intelligent.

I liked a few jokes about Jews here, like Weinstein getting upset when Peter sings he now has a Jew, and when Lois says Jews built the pyramids (a Biblical reference). The episode avoids racism, however, when at the end Peter realizes Jews are no better or worse than other people, though this message is expressed without any subtlety. Peter demonstrating to Weinstein how his son isn't too bright is also funny. But other parts of the episode aren't as funny. For example, Peter soiling himself twice is just puerile. As someone interested in Jews, this episode was slightly disappointing. But it shouldn't be censored.
12 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Season Three Review
southdavid29 February 2024
I wish, perhaps, I hadn't started to try and review these seasons of "Family Guy". There's several reasons for it, Because I'm generally only watching one or two a week, it's taking me months to get through these seasons and I'm struggling already to remember which episode were in this season. It's all so similar too, that comparing the seasons is proving difficult.

Season three of "Family Guy" sees the family move to south in Witness Protection. Peter (Seth MacFarlane) discover his secret black heritage. Brian (Seth MacFarlane) and Stewie (Seth MacFarlane) head on a road trip to England, whilst Peter and Lois (Alex Borstein) follow KISS on tour. Peter discovers that the solution to all his life problems is a Jewish accountant.

The show was cancelled again prior to the release of this season, so for a while it looked like this would be all she wrote for what would become a long running show. The healthy DVD sales and repeat viewing figures on adult swim would save the show though. The season also includes to previous banned "When You Wish Upon a Weinstein" episode - which doesn't actually seem that controversial, when you actually see it. It also has a return for the "Road to" concept, which again sees a musical adventure for Brian and Stewie.

Again, there's no obvious downturn in quality for these epsiodes. I laughed a few times across the run and was generally amused by them throughout. I'm going to keep going on to season four.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Bittersweet...
Analog_Devotee27 January 2022
This was another episode honing in on some stereotypes surrounding a certain group of people, and I remember plenty finding it to be offensive.

This was a great episode, but so, so bittersweet. It was the last to be aired before the cancellation which would leave us without new Family Guy episodes for almost two years. Sad, indeed.

I won't say that I hate the next few seasons of Family Guy, but to say they only pale in comparison would be a massive understatement. The original feel, the tone, was gone; gone forever.

This is the final one to retain that feel.

Savor it.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed