The examination scene was terrible! Det. Benson waas clearly in charge, not the nurse. Benson's the one who comforts the patient and explains what's happening and why. This is insulting to real forensic nurses. In real life, the police aren't even in the room.
Now for the key issue. I, the juror, find the defendant....
Not guilty. His lawyer's closing argument was compelling. Nothing in his past indicated that he was capable of that type of violence. Unfortunately, the same couldn't be said for the young woman. She threw a bottle through the back window of a cab, and only mentioned rape when she was about to be arrested. Then she falsely accused Det. Stabler of sexual abuse when he was trying to help her. Then she faked a suicide attempt to get sympathy from Benson. Very discrediting. Of course, the professor show very poor judgement himself, but poor judgement isn't a crime.
I can't see enough evidence to find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, so I'd find the defendant not guilty.