The Outer Limits (TV Series) Nightmare (1998) User Reviews

Better Get Those Fail-Safes in Place

[Hitchcoc · 8/10 · 5 June 2014]

This episode is really painful to watch as a group of military people are tortured and prodded. They were on board a space ship that crashed and are now under the control of a deep-voiced overlord who brings them in one at a time for interrogation. He also plants seeds of dissension among them so that they begin to threaten and distrust. What is hardest to watch are the scenes of torture and pain. These aliens also have the ability to cause blindness and other maladies. The crew are all trained in different ways and have what appears incredible resolve. The Captain tries to keep everyone in line, but eventually chaos ensues. Some of them have worked together for good and have trusted each other. This is a new version of one of the old Outer Limits episodes. It is well worth watching for what eventually happens. There is little subtlety here.

Not a nightmare, but not a complete loss either

[hung_fao_tweeze · 7/10 · 29 April 2019]

The original 1963 version of 'Nightmare' was that exactly. It was hallucinogenic. It pulled it off really well, too. The performances of the actors involved were compelling and solid. The dialogue was thoughtful, intriguing. The Ebonites were startling yet more humane to the humans than they tend to be to each other. Ultimately, the story and its conclusion lingered in your brain afterwards. In my case, since 1963. It dropped little clues along the way that messed with the viewers mind. It was successfully frightening in many instances.

This 1998 rewrite is merely similar. How could they do a credible rewrite of one of the best original episodes? Well...it seems that they didn't try too hard. The characters are not nearly as deep or defined as they were in the original. There is nothing terribly hallucinogenic to draw you into the story or provide background into the characters. Like the original, the crew is captured while trying to deploy a device on a planet believed to be uninhabited. It wasn't and they are captured by the Ebonites to be placed in a cell. Like the original, they are taken singly from this cell and questioned. Also, like the original, distrust grows among the captives. Unlike the original, it is less than fascinating. So, as I was viewing this I was becoming disheartened. It wasn't a 'nightmare'. I was puzzled that the creators of this updated series would drop the ball on what should have lived up to the title of this episode.

But then....the ending.

It saved the episode for me and made me smile. It was a very satisfactory twist to an experiment that worked far too well. I give it a 7 because the story is good, but I feel that they could have been able to develop the characters like the original did so that each demise would feel more personal.

Not a good remake

[dpincgk-04079 · 1/10 · 14 August 2020]

Overacting and cheesy dialogue. Could have been so much better!

Why remake this episode? Why?

[petewood-59951 · 2/10 · 12 March 2020]

You know, the first time they did this episode in 1963, it wasn't exactly Citizen Kane, but the characters behaved sensibly for the most part and it had Martin Sheen. Why they felt the need to remake it is a complete head scratcher. If I had to pick the biggest difference between the old series and the new series, it would be that the 1960s version had logical endings and the new series goes out of its way to have unhappy endings, often with a twist that comes out of absolute nowhere. The characters in this episode are not likable and they behave like morons. And, please, for the love of God, explain to me why you would give subjects of sadistic psychological torture access to a machine that can destroy the entire world. Does that even begin to make sense? From a plot point of view it makes no sense. From a survival of the human race point of view it makes no sense. Why have such a machine in the first place? And, why not have an off switch? Don't watch this episode. It'll just irritate you.