"Stargate SG-1" Babylon (TV Episode 2005) Poster

(TV Series)

(2005)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
The Warriors of Sodan
claudio_carvalho14 September 2019
While exploring a planet of rebel Jaffa known as The Warriors of Sodan, Colonel Mitchell is captured by the Jaffa. He is accused for the death of a warrior that indeed is recovering at the SGC. Now Mitchell has to fight for his life in a showdown against the warrior´s brother.

"Babylon" is an episode of "Stargate SG-1" independent from Ba'al storyline. The episode has a good surprise in the end with the fate of Colonel Mitchell. My vote is seven.

Title (Brazil): "Babylon"
11 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Jidaigeki Ori?
Doc_Rancher27 March 2015
Warning: Spoilers
This story reminds me in no small part of the Jidaigeki genre or its western derivatives. An honorable warrior of a group of legendary warriors living in solidarity for thousands of years teaches a foreign (western?) warrior how to fight properly to be in a ritual fight to the death. The fighting techniques and philosophy are very similar to (stereotype) martial arts. As is the fact that the training is very hard and Cameron Mitchell slowly gains the respect of Jolan. But these Ronin (Samurai with no lord), pardon, Sodan have lost their path because they begin to worship the Ori now. And this is what makes this episode interesting. If even Jaffa who abandoned their believes in false gods thousands of years ago can be converted the Ori might be unstoppable. And they gain some pretty good fighters on this planet. I wonder if we will see more of the Sodan in the future. By the way, I don't think these Jaffa are morons. They attack SG-1 because they were told they are the enemy and Haikon listens very calm and even with some interest to Cameron, he just doesn't abandon his new believe because of this conversations.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Spock and Kirk, At the Amok Time
fcabanski2 October 2015
Warning: Spoilers
True Sci-Fi (genre, not the channel) will understand the title. The writers gained points by mentioning the Star Trek connection.

It doesn't make sense that the Sodan, who were the first Jaffa to abandon the false gods, so quickly move to worship the Ori. The Sodan believe the Ancients are the god-like beings to worship. The Sodan know the Ori aren't the Ancients, but the Sodan are still willing to worship the Ori.

Some of the Sodan come to understand the problem with the Ori. But given the Sodans' history, they should want to know more about these non gods before taking a knee.

The writers, as do many people, don't understand the difference between faith and belief. The writers use "faith" to describe what is clearly belief. But there's a nice moment when Col. Mitchell describes "our" meaning his relationship with God.

Overall it's not a bad episode. It moves the Ori story forward. That's a good thing.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Candyman
Calicodreamin10 April 2022
What the heck was the candyman doing leading a group of Jaffa? Decent storyline and new characters had depth. Effects and action coordination looked authentic.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Cigarette Smoking Man visits Stargate
XweAponX25 January 2016
Actually I don't know if the great William B Davis (Cancerman from The X-Files) shows up in this, yes he does. Which was why I enjoyed this and rated it 10. Actually I rate the whole show 10 and each episode gets the same figure. Smallville for instance gets a 1 from me, and that is for the show itself and for each episode. I rate a show for one thing and one thing only, if I enjoyed it. If I enjoyed it, it gets a 10, if I didn't, it gets a 1. It's a simple as that. If i like a show it's generally all 10's, except for Season 1 "Emancipation" which I gave an 8, because I don't think Captain Carter was as attractive with short hair in fatigues as she is with long hair and wearing a dress. So I thought it was highly unlikely that the local natives would have gone Bugsputz over her while wearing combat fatigues. Now... Kari Wuhrer in combat fatigues worked... In Sliders. But she was acting across from the great Roger Daltrey of The Who.

Now there are a few things about Stargate that bother me, how all of the planets they visit always look like Canada. They did a lot of location shooting on SG-1. Sometimes a location was appropriate, sometimes it was not. It was, in this episode.

The choice of guest actors as well. In this episode, the also-great Tony Todd (Commander Kurn and Worf's Brother from Star Trek/Next Gen), as "Lord Haikon", the leader of a rare group of Jaffa, the "Sodan" that are very much like samurai- Jaffa that Teal'c respects. Also Jarvis and Jason George, I didn't know are actual brothers, and this was also appropriate. Colonel Mitchell becomes "The Last Samurai" much like Tom Cruise, basically he's trapped during the winter in a samurai village and he goes native over time. I think the Cameron Mitchell character would do this, but Astronaut John Criton would not. At least not until season 4 of Farscape, where he learned to curse in Klingonese.

The irony here is that Mitchell is being tutored for a fight to the death while not knowing who is tutoring him.

This group of Jaffa have been visited by an Ori Prior (William B Davis) and have even "done a few jobs for him", IE, killed off infidels. This is also irony, because the Jaffa are free, yet they keep choosing to go back to the same kinds of slavery they have always lived under. Because while this story elapses, Gerak, the leader of the Free Jaffa, is also being suckered by The Ori - They even give him a Prior Staff. After finally getting free from the rule of the Goa'Uld and even finding a drug that frees them from having a Symbiotic parasite living in their pouch, they go back just like a dog to it's vomit.

In reality, I don't know how realistic it is for a freed people to just willingly and en mass go back into a slave situation. But it happens, it happens on Earth.

But this culture of Jaffa are a unique culture and an honorable one, as Mitchell learns and begins to respect. But there are Ori Priors are everywhere, and they don't go away, unless they come back to kill you.

So there are all of these little drawn out dramas (like the ones that used to be drawn in the margins of Mad Magazine) going on, on earth, on Chulak, and if you don't pay attention to each one, you miss something. This episode introduces the Sodan Invisibility shield, and as I have said, nothing is ever wasted in Stargate SG1.

This episode also sets the stage for a confrontation with the William B Davis Prior character which happens in the next episode, while also setting up what ultimately happens with Gerak and the choices he makes. So it is a bit like Jidaigeki, but only the parts about Mitchell and the Sodan.
3 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Bah!
uncleoyster1 February 2011
Warning: Spoilers
Yet another really annoying Jaffa, spouting meaningless bulls**t about honour and vengeance while refusing to listen to reason. Isn't this getting old? Don't the writers see how downright stupid this is?

Anyway; while the concept isn't all bad for this one, the execution is. SG-1 are looking for a group of Jaffa called the Sodan. Naturally, they're hostile morons who attack without warning. Mitchell gets hit and captured, but not without wounding one of the Sodan, whom gets taken back to the SGC. The way this is done seems a bit contrived, but all in the name of plot I guess.

A Sodan named Jolan trains Mitchell in the fighting ways of the Sodan so he can get killed in a ritualistic fight against the brother of the Sodan he shot. He also tries to convince the Sodan that the Ori are false gods. SG-1 try to get Mitchell back while working on an anti-Prior device AND convincing "their" Sodan that the Ori are false gods.

The clever (though not original) twist of this episode is that Jolan turns out to be the brother of the Sodan Mitchell shot, and also that Jolan tricks both his brethren and Mitchell in order to save him. This episode is an utter mess, but for this twist I'll give it a 2.
8 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
The last samurai
martinbrisiak-6397028 September 2020
Rip-off of a movie... Bad rip-off with afro-samurai with japanese architecture and culture
2 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
It had to happen
spockedblocked17 March 2021
Like clock work. You could set your watch to it. Had this Colonel Mitchell, Jack replacement character. for a few shows. Was sort of thinking... what? maybe... safe to watch again? Seems some what logical, of course for a military disposition. Even was noted how he was all service, business. logic thinking, leadership... then, I could just see some producer saying, "ya know what? I think we need to bring back the asinine, one-liner idiocy of Jack, which irritated people so much. They'll love it! I'm so brilliant to know what dumbed down people want."

And, in one episode, the Jack-assness come forth. Baseball hat on backwards, check. Campy idiocy acting, check. Depth of beer and monster trucks, check. No more leadership. Started acting the jack part as if always was never anything prior. God, make it stop.
2 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed