Emilia (I) (2005) User Reviews

disgusting bad

[atzenklo · 1/10 · 7 March 2019]

I watch this movie in class and it's bitterly so bad that every 10 seconds someone starts to laugh. the story as it seems it the normal story but in lessings old German. it is just as bad as it sounds. I would like to give 0 out of 10. don't watch this rubbish peace of movie and history rape

Slick, thoughtless 'modernization'

[powelllar · 1/10 · 25 September 2012]

Other reviewer is right: this is pretty poor. One wouldn't mind a modernizing version if it were done intelligently, but this is trivial and shallow. Watch the East German (DEFA) version from 1958 instead - it isn't ideal, but is generally on a much higher level. (I was interested in film versions since I teach this play to German literature students quite often, and wanted a film to accompany the reading.) I suspect German reviewers and viewers may have thought similarly, since this director has never done anything since. The 1913 version by Friedrich Feher (a significant director) looks intriguing, but do not know if this is available anywhere.