The First Saturday in May (2007) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
14 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
A buoyant and energizing film experience
howard.schumann4 October 2007
Every year since 1875, the first Saturday in May is the time for the Kentucky Derby, a race of three year old thoroughbred horses over a mile and a quarter track that has been called the most exciting two minutes in all of sports. 40,000 thoroughbreds are born each year. Of these 23,000 will race and of those, only 20 will make it to the Derby. For owners, trainers, grooms, and jockeys it is the World Series, The Indy 500, and the Super Bowl combined into one. For two years, brothers John and Brad Hennegan followed the daily activities of those horses and their trainers that they thought had a chance to make it to Churchill Downs, shooting over 500 hours of film on a minimal budget in diverse locations such as New York, Florida, California, Arkansas, Dubai, and Kentucky. The result is The First Saturday in May, a buoyant and energizing film experience that may just be the best documentary of the year.

First Saturday is primarily a film about horses but is also about families and especially children who provide some of the most entertaining moments of the film. The Hennegans show the ups and downs of the path to the "run for the roses" and the emotional investment of the trainers and their families preparing their horses for the ride of their life. Trainers include Dale Romans who grew up only a few miles from Churchill Downs, Dan Hendricks, trainer of Brother Derek, who is paralyzed from the waist down, Kiaran McLaughlin, who suffers from Multiple Sclerosis, Michael Matz, trainer of Barbaro who won an Olympic medal as an equestrian, and others. Another human interest story is that of 61 year old groom Chuck Chambers who has worked tirelessly all of his life for this opportunity.

In order to qualify for the Derby, horses have to compete in stakes races scattered throughout the country and only the top twenty three-year olds in earnings will qualify. The film follows six horses: Barbaro, Achilles of Troy, Brother Derek, Lawyer Ron, Jazil, and Sharp Humor through their months of preparation and shows us races - lots of races in which survival in the Derby competition is at stake. These include the Wood Memorial, the Santa Anita Derby, The Gotham Stakes, and many others, one more heart pounding than the other. For some there is triumph and for others tragedy as one horse on the verge of qualifying, breaks down during a race and is pulled from further competition.

The most emotionally compelling moments in the film are those showing the rise and fall of the horse Barbaro from his astonishing 6 ½-length win in the 2006 Kentucky Derby to his breakdown in Pimlico and his subsequent fight for survival. The sequences are shown with admiration and respect for the suffering of the horse and the breakdown is hidden from the camera. The film does not touch issues such as gambling, and race fixing told in Hollywood films until they have become a cliché.

The Hennegan Brothers, whose father was a racing official at Belmont Park and who have had a lifelong interest in the sport, wanted to show the positive aspects of racing, the excitement it generates, and the lives of the real people involved. Of course all roads lead to Louisville and the thrilling 2006 Derby run is one of the highlights. The film ends on an upbeat note informing us of the subsequent successes of the individuals shown in the film and the birth of Barbaro's brother Nicanor, a potential Kentucky Derby participant in 2009. The First Saturday in May may not be the most publicized documentary of the year but, like Hoop Dreams did in 1994, once it finds its audience, it will be a swift ride to the winner's circle.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Surprisingly excellent
exsailor664 November 2007
My wife and I saw this film at The Savannah Film Festival. Although having no expectations, we loved the film from the start. You actually care about the people and the horses, and it takes you on an emotional journey. I don't even like horse racing, but it is so well done that the horse racing is only a vehicle for the talented construction of this film.

You don't get lost for an instant, and you want to know what will happen next. It brushes upon the technicalities and behind-the-scenes work that goes into the theme of the movie, without becoming annoyingly too "in-depth". The bonus is that we learned something...a good thing to happen each day of our lives.

We weren't surprised that the film was an award-winner at the Festival. Well worth watching. I hope it is put on wide distribution so that everyone can see it.

Bravo!!!
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Excellent Documentary
TxEx8422 April 2008
My daughter convinced me to go since she's a big horse racing fan. I wasn't expecting much, but I completely enjoyed this movie. You get a behind the scenes look into the horse racing industry and all of the joys, disappointments, hard work, and tragic losses that goes with it.

The makers of this movie were very lucky in the horses they choose to follow. They have crews documenting Barbaro, Achilles of Troy, Sharp Humor, Jazil, Lawyer Ron, and Brother Derek as they make their quest for the Kentucky Derby. Five of the six eventually make it into the 20 horse field. You become very attached to the horses and their trainers as the film takes you from race to race leading up to the Derby.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Sure Winner
joeryan4 June 2007
Fabulous film that is more about people than horses. Tells a moving realty show of courage, skill and tenacity. Trainers overcome personal adversity (paralyses and M.S.),their wives bask in the excitement of the race-world (one is a jockey, another a fashion model), and the children can't resist cutting school to witness the race (one places a bet for the teacher, the other drops out to work full time at the stable). The by-line story of the rise and fall of famed horse Barbaro from the track is told with grace, respect and admiration. And the filmmakers' travel on-site to the tracks (including Dubai)coupled with the musical score add the spice and variety that make this film a sure winner.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Six trainers try to qualify their horses for the Kentucky Derby
blanche-229 April 2008
Six trainers prepare for "The First Saturday in May" in this excellent 2007 documentary currently playing limited engagements in select theaters. The good news is that the producers, the Hennegan brothers, have found a distributor, and the film is due to be released on DVD.

The documentary follows the trainers of six horses who are close to qualifying for the 2005 Kentucky Derby, including trainer Matz and the horse he trains, Barbaro, whose story is well known. The trainers are all lively personalities from different parts of the country (Arkansas, Florida, New York, Kentucky). We get to know these men, their histories, their children and their love of horses. The statistics were interesting - of 40,000 foals born every year, only 20 make it to the Derby. Of these six, not all make it. And one who did meets a cruel fate.

There are laughs and tears to be had in this absorbing film. I'm not a particular fan of horse- racing - for the horses who aren't winners and put out to stud, it can be a horrible life. Racing young horses can cause harm to many an animal and has. Viewers, however, will be struck by the sheer beauty of these animals, their trainers' stories and the drama, pathos and humor of this documentary.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Brilliant documentary with characters that you couldn't make up.
bpr361216 April 2008
I saw this wonderful film at the Tribeca Film Festival last year and was so happy that it will be seen nationwide. During the "Q & A" after a Tribeca screening a youngish member of the audience asked a question that I thought, by virtue of its content, was the ultimate compliment that could be paid to a documentary. "What that based on a true story?", the young lad wondered. With docs you can never know going in whether there will be a story to tell. Nor can you know whether the characters have enough depth and substance to make the telling of the tale compelling. First Saturday's editing accomplishes both. The Hennegan brothers had me shaking my head as I left the theater wondering how they did it.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
AWESOME Film
cchurch7416 April 2008
This is an AWESOME film! I was lucky enough to see it twice before - once at Delaware Park and then at SilverDOCS - and I'm going again. You'll laugh, you'll cry, you'll cheer.... The Hennegans, aside from being great guys, are incredible film-makers.

Even if you're not an avid race fan, you will still get a lot out of this film. The Kentucky Derby is an internationally known sporting contest (the Queen even attended last year, for goodness sakes). No other movie shows the in-depth behind the scenes preparations that take place in getting a horse to the Derby. What also makes the movie so poignant is that it features some great scenes with ill-fated Derby winner, Barbaro. He was a true champion. The Hennegans handle his injury in the Preakness and his death with great sympathy, but they don't let it overtake the entire movie.

Go see this film if its playing near you, and if not make sure to get the DVD when its available!
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
wonderful film!
emilyjcowen18 April 2008
absolutely fabulous film. I am an avid horse racing fan, so I was bound and determined to see this movie the day it opened. I was not disappointed! You can really tell the makers love horses and racing, and that love comes through loud and clear. The people, from the horses to the jockeys, trainers and grooms are well developed and captivating. You find yourself rooting for EVERYONE to win, even though you know what's coming. The horses are captured in a way that horse people (and non horse people!) can appreciate- shows their charming personalities and sometimes rogue behavior.

and then there's Barbaro.

I tried to tell myself I wasn't going to cry, but it was impossible. I know the story well, but it still pulls my heart strings to see the story unfold again. I believe this was a perfect tribute to this amazing animal, a horse that touched the hearts of so many people. It makes me happy to know that Barbaro has been immortalized in this wonderful movie.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Extremely enjoyable!
srahhh3316 March 2008
This documentary captures the excitement and unpredictable nature of horse racing while adding moments of humor seamlessly! Featuring in on six horses, the movie not only talks about their journey to Churchill Downs, it features the stories of their trainers and their families. Although the subject matter is horses, this is truly a movie about interesting and intriguing people, not just horses, and the great characters you find around the track. Lots of candid moments around the track that are priceless, as well as racing footage featuring the chosen horses. This movie will be enjoyable for anyone who likes an interesting story, this is it!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Goosebumps...
nadine-bradley21 April 2008
I have had the privilege of not only seeing this film 4 times so far, but also got to meet and hang out with the wonderful directors - Bran and John Hennegan.

This film never ceases to give me goosebumps throughout. It will make you laugh, maybe even shed a tear or two, but you will walk away feeling like you got a very rare and private insight into the world of horse racing. It is not only about Barbaro (although the footage of him is precious and exclusive!) but more so about the "entourage" behind each of the 6 horses featured. The people are so unique and real that not even the best writers could have come up with their characters! I urge you to go see the film and spread the word to friends, family and random strangers.

SUPPORT INDEPENDENT FILMS!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An excellent film. Very well done.
marr200117 April 2008
Warning: Spoilers
This is an excellent production and will appeal to both horse racing fans and non-fans alike.

I saw this film at both the Tribeca and Austin film festivals and audience reaction was extremely positive at both.

The directors do a remarkable job of allowing the characters to tell their stories. And the stories are about much more than racing; they are about hope and striving to get to the top in an environment where the odds are stacked against all participants.

You can't help but root for all of the characters in this film, but in the end, only one can win. Only one can get to the top. The film reminds us of the painful reality that once at the top and seemingly unconquerable, there is no guarantee you will stay there.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Sheer heart!
luvcinema24 April 2008
Austin, TX is not much of a horse racing town. In fact it's pretty devoid of any decent amount of horse racing fans. I included myself in that group of non-fans until I was talked into seeing this film at the Austin Film Festival. My friend had heard a little bit about the film and was a fan of the sport, so off I went.

My how things change... and quickly! I've seen this film 3 times and am anxious to own the DVD (and I never buy DVDs!!) I can't get enough! The Hennegan Brothers, who graciously answered every question at the film fest screening, have done something amazing. They've created a gem of a movie that engages the audience with a brilliant story of inspiration, aspiration and sheer heart. (Wait a minute... this was a documentary? I don't cheer at documentaries!)

It takes a lot of effort, energy and money to get an independent film this far in the game. Not an easy task. Hats off to the H Bros. and everyone involved. You've done a tremendous job with a film that truly deserves it. — The Kentucky Derby will never be the same. And for the first time, I'll really be watching.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
EXCELLENT - Very well done documentary
bennk22 June 2008
The coverage is balanced - horse, trainer, jockey, owner, stable, . . . - a tough thing to do. Well done and engaging throughout. Though spouse is the "horse" person, I enjoyed it as much. The insight to the processes and practice and the drama builds as you watch each of the stakeholders build their commitment and expectations.

Well done story, well done documentary, well done film making (very tasteful).

Great example of indie film Great example of contemporary documentary Great story on all the "hearts" of horse racing (horse, jockey, trainer, owner)

I highly recommend this film. Well done - to the two brothers that did the film.

Would like to see a story/documentary on the making/release of this film.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A Winner
JohnDeSando29 April 2008
"You have to do it with confidence." Michael Matz, Barbaro trainer

Out of the gate, the documentary First Saturday in May is a winner, whose neophyte directors, brothers Brad and John Hennegan, capture mostly the glamour of the kingly sport before and at Churchill Downs once a year. Although the editing is choppy, the camera angles uninspired, and the lighting weak—no doubt due to the fact that I saw it from projected DVD before prints were cast—it gently carries a romantic aura of the race to qualify and the big race.

This is the famous 2006 race with the incomparable, tragic winner, Barbaro. That the brothers had enough sense to spotlight this undefeated, favored thoroughbred is much in their favor; that the doc must end in the horse's eventual put down from a Preakness Stakes leg injury is a dramatic counterpoint to the upbeat scenario that went before it, a gift so to speak from the Fates to a film that could have been judged sugarcoated without the dark ending.

Prior to the big race the doc traces several stables and their trainers as they prepare to qualify for it or for the race itself. Notably from good ol' slow Kentucky boy Dale Romans looking for his first win to chatty New York assistant trainer Frank Amonte, whose kids take after him in accent and attitude but not in casual expletives from their dad every time he has a setback.

The usual goofballs are present on the day of the derby such as the rube with the spinning horses on top of his beanie and the chubby preadolescent kid who pulls a wad of money from his pocket while mom proudly exclaims, "Horses and poker, that's his thing right now." The doc doesn't need fancy photography to catch the regal nature of this all American event (notwithstanding an owner sheikh from Dubai). It's a winner.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed