Wrangling Coach Rankin is a mockumentary depicting the quest of a motley group of men who achieved unexpected success playing on the Nilton High School Baseball Team. It seemed as though the Team would have a dream season, until a crushing and embarassihng loss in the championship game. Fifteen years after this defeat, the members of the original squad try and locate and convince their cantankerous baseball leader, Coach Rankin, to coach them in a Rematch. They not only seek to reclaim their glory years, but also seek to erase some of the scars that the loss left behind.