- Amanda Rollins: [as Rollins and Hasim prepare for their undercover assignment] Okay, what color is my toothbrush?
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: Blue, and you sleep on the left side of the bed. You always spoon me.
- Amanda Rollins: And what about my siblings?
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: One sister, but you're not in touch.
- Amanda Rollins: She's troubled. You can say that.
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: But hot.
- Amanda Rollins: Hey.
- Lina Vasquez-Boyd: Ms. Benson, can I talk to you?
- Olivia Benson: Sure, Lina. Is everything all right?
- Lina Vasquez-Boyd: I can't testify.
- Olivia Benson: Why not? Lina, did your husband...
- Lina Vasquez-Boyd: No, no, no, no. He doesn't know anything yet.
- Olivia Benson: We really need you to testify.
- Lina Vasquez-Boyd: I can't. I'm sorry.
- Olivia Benson: Why?
- Lina Vasquez-Boyd: I just found out I'm pregnant. I'm praying this baby looks like Joe. This is not about O'Toole or any these women anymore. My baby needs a father and if Joe thinks for a second that this might be O'Toole's baby? He could never know.
- John Buchanan: [to Carisi] My client had a long, dark night of the soul to think about this.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Well, there's not a whole lot to think about. It's all over but the hard time, O'Toole.
- John Buchanan: Back up. Hold on a second.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: No. I'm done waiting. Tomorrow, Rosamie and Maggie are gonna take the stand, but before they do, we're gonna bump the charges from Rape Three to Rape One, and when they're done testifying, the jury and your client will be in tears.
- John Buchanan: Let's show a little compassion for a fellow officer, Counselor.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Oh, the same compassion that he showed his victims?
- ICE Agent Rory O'Toole: I was doing my job. I've been serving my country on the front lines of a foreign invasion for 20 years.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Serving your country? By dipping your wick?
- ICE Agent Rory O'Toole: It was a test. It's the only way to know if they really love their husbands.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Okay, okay. Now, you told me before that if they really loved their husbands, they wouldn't sleep with you.
- ICE Agent Rory O'Toole: That's right.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: But when they refused you, you threw 'em in jail, and if they did sleep with you, you gave 'em their green card. Now, you can lie to yourself all you want, but you raped these women.
- ICE Agent Rory O'Toole: No, absolutely not. I was just doing what I had to do to protect our borders.
- John Buchanan: Rory, he understands...
- ICE Agent Rory O'Toole: He doesn't understand it. I'm holding the line between more mouths to feed, more people on Medicaid, in our public schools and our hospitals, okay? Taking our jobs. These people are bleeding the system dry and I stop that from happening.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: All right, stop. Not one more word from you. What you did to these women how many of them have had to live with your violation in secret, in fear? You took advantage of them when they were at their most helpless, their most vulnerable, and you used the power of your government position to force them to demean themselves. They came here hoping for the American dream, and you made their lives a nightmare.
- [to Buchanan]
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: I'm sick of your client, Counselor. You want to talk deal? He needs to shut his mouth and nod yes.
- Amanda Rollins: Mr. Varick here was just telling me he takes the Z train every day.
- Duane Varik: Fact. And today, it was really crowded, so any touching was accidental.
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: Then why run? Why smash your phone?
- Duane Varik: Because my father had that conversation with me when I was a boy. Badge or no badge, I know you understand that, my brother, and in case you don't, I want a lawyer. Mm.
- Deputy Chief Christian Garland: Race card, the lawyer card. Smarter than he looks.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: So our subway grinder gave up his boss at Citizenship and Immigration as a rapist?
- Odafin Tutuola: Duane says this guy O'Toole holds up green cards in exchange for sex.
- Olivia Benson: He preys on attractive immigrant women and threatens deportation if they don't comply.
- Amanda Rollins: It's a squeeze play. They can't report. They can't tell their husband.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Did Duane give you any proof?
- Odafin Tutuola: Well, he said O'Toole took a file off his desk, then he came in the next day with a big smile on his face, saying, "The best cure for blue balls is a green card."
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Eh, it's poetic, but it's not probative.
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: Lina backed out?
- Amanda Rollins: She's pregnant.
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: I get it. That changes everything.
- Amanda Rollins: Yeah, it means O'Toole's gonna walk.
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: What about Rosamie Klein?
- Amanda Rollins: You heard her. She doesn't want to hurt her husband.
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: Maybe I can talk to him. Jew to Jew.
- Amanda Rollins: You're Jewish?
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: On my mother's side. Part Muslim on my father's. It's a long story.
- Amanda Rollins: Sounds like everybody in New York has one of those.
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: You want to take a ride to Ocean Parkway, talk to the Kleins?
- Amanda Rollins: As my Baptist grandmama would say, it's worth a Hail Mary.
- Amanda Rollins: I spent two days pretending to be married to you. I don't know the first thing about you.
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: I guess I consider myself Middle-Eastern American.
- Amanda Rollins: Middle-Eastern American? So, not Muslim?
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: Mm-mm. After 9/11, I was really ashamed to admit that I was part Muslim.
- Amanda Rollins: Hmm.
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: So, actually I passed for black in Brooklyn. It was easier.
- Amanda Rollins: Well, my story is pretty much the exact same.
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: [sharing a laugh] Oh, yeah? Yeah, but your sister's really not crazy, right?
- Amanda Rollins: No, that part is true.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Well, it took a while, but reality finally caught up to Rory O'Toole. He took the deal.
- Olivia Benson: Ah. Did you make it hurt?
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: He's gonna be in a world of pain till he's eligible for Medicare.
- Olivia Benson: Good work, Carisi.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Nah, it wasn't me, it was Rollins. I don't know how she did it, but getting Rosamie to testify? That's what broke this whole thing.
- Olivia Benson: It wasn't just Rosamie. It was about getting the husband to understand and Rollins said that that wasn't her. It was Sergeant Khaldun.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Nah, I'm sure she's just being generous with the credit.
- Olivia Benson: I don't think so. She said that Khaldun spoke with Eddie in Hebrew mensch-to-mensch.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: In Hebrew?
- Olivia Benson: Yeah. And apparently it's better than his Arabic.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: What?
- Olivia Benson: He's a pretty interesting guy.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Eh, for a cave cop. I'm sorry, Transit Unit.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Rosamie Klein still won't testify?
- Olivia Benson: She doesn't want to hurt her husband.
- Odafin Tutuola: And it turns out Maggie Quigley's marriage was a fake. Her husband's gay and she is too.
- Deputy Chief Christian Garland: So they lied about their green card which is itself a federal offense. There's already a lot of blowback. If this case implodes... . where's Hadid on this?
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: She's not shying away from the fight. O'Toole's attorney, Buchanan already approached us with a slap-on-the-wrist deal for misdemeanor official misconduct. Hadid said no way.
- Olivia Benson: Well, what does she want to charge him with?
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: At a minimum, rape three. Plus felony charges of official misconduct and receiving a bribe.
- Olivia Benson: I would argue that threatening to deport victims to countries where they face violence constitutes forcible compulsion.
- Deputy Chief Christian Garland: That's rape one.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: That makes the case much harder and Hadid wants O'Toole to go down for this.
- Odafin Tutuola: And if he doesn't, you do?
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Probably. I mean, I can add on misdemeanor sexual misconduct, coercion, official misconduct...
- Olivia Benson: He deserves no less than 15 years.
- Odafin Tutuola: Throw the whole book at him.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: I'm trying, but I don't have textbook witnesses. I got Duane, the subway groper. Rollins and Hasim. Buchanan's already salivating about his cross.
- Olivia Benson: And Lina. She's credible, she has no reason to lie, and everything to lose.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Just make sure she shows up.
- Odafin Tutuola: [to Garland about O'Toole] Our working theory is he goes after attractive female applicants with red flag cases.
- Olivia Benson: Well, he looks for discrepancies in age, race, religion, social status. At first, he interviews the couple separately at his office.
- Odafin Tutuola: Then he meets the women in his minivan where he tells them, "You want the green card? I deserve a little loving, too."
- Olivia Benson: And if they turn O'Toole down, they wind up in ICE detention, pending deportation. Plus, he can deport their families, too.
- Deputy Chief Christian Garland: This abuse of power sickens me.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Your Honor, two more witnesses have come forward. The prosecution intends to call Maggie Quigley...
- [the court doors open and Rollins leads Rosamie and Eddie in]
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: ...and Rosamie Klein.
- John Buchanan: Your Honor, this is the first we're hearing of these witnesses. I need time to prepare. I request an adjournment for the day.
- Judge Felicia Catano: So granted.
- John Buchanan: [quietly to Carisi] Where the hell'd you pull these two out of?
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: The back of your client's van. My guess, he's not gonna want to hear their testimony in open court.
- [joining Benson]
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: You see O'Toole's face? He's gonna fold.
- Olivia Benson: Make it hurt.
- John Buchanan: I want to give you an early out here. My client is a respected USCIS investigator. His job is to uncover scams for green cards, which is what he did. This was a fake marriage.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Nice try. O'Toole was extorting sex in exchange for a green card.
- ICE Agent Rory O'Toole: Please listen to the tape. Everything I said, it was a test.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: You had a mattress in the back seat.
- ICE Agent Rory O'Toole: Well, it has to look real. That's part of the setup.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: The setup? We found traces of your DNA on the mattress.
- ICE Agent Rory O'Toole: It's my mattress.
- John Buchanan: Did you find any of your supposed victims' DNA? I didn't think so. He wasn't going to sexually assault your UC; he was trying to find out how far she would go.
- ICE Agent Rory O'Toole: It's like with a narc cop, right? You buy the drugs, and then you make the bust.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Okay, so you were gonna sleep with her?
- John Buchanan: No! And you don't know that because your team stepped in before Mr. O'Toole had the chance to bust her.
- ICE Agent Rory O'Toole: If the wife is willing to cross the line to infidelity for a green card, how real can the love be?
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Okay, none of this is DHS protocol, and I don't see any jurors buying it for a second.
- John Buchanan: You need 12. I only need one.
- Odafin Tutuola: NYPD. Put your hands on the wheel.
- Katriona Tamin: Miss, you're not in any trouble. Come with me.
- ICE Agent Rory O'Toole: I'm a federal officer. I'm on the job.
- Odafin Tutuola: Not anymore, you're not.
- Olivia Benson: Rory O'Toole, you're under arrest for sexual extortion.
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: We go out to uh, dinner. Nightclubs.
- ICE Agent Rory O'Toole: As an observant Muslim, though, you don't drink.
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: No. No, I don't.
- ICE Agent Rory O'Toole: Does your wife?
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: Yes. She loves her martinis.
- ICE Agent Rory O'Toole: And how do you feel about that?
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: I fell in love with Mandy as she is. I don't want or expect her to change. That's the beauty of America. Everyone is free to be who they are. If I get my green card, inshallah, I'll be free, too.
- ICE Agent Rory O'Toole: You said Special Victims. So this is sexual in nature?
- Olivia Benson: Well, I can't comment on the investigation.
- Odafin Tutuola: What does Duane do here?
- ICE Agent Rory O'Toole: Duane works for me. We're investigators like you. We vet marriages, make sure they're not green-card romances. Please, have a seat.
- Odafin Tutuola: Well, this is a tough job, but between us, he may not be right for it.
- ICE Agent Rory O'Toole: It's that bad, huh? Well, what do you need from me?
- Olivia Benson: We need access to his computers, his search history, and to make sure he didn't upload any photo files.
- ICE Agent Rory O'Toole: For something like that, I'd have to go through legal, HR, the union.
- Olivia Benson: My D.A. wanted to subpoena you, and I told him the last thing that your bosses need is bad publicity.
- Odafin Tutuola: We go to court, this office becomes a punchline.
- Olivia Benson: Look, you're an investigator. How about you check his search history and if you think that there's nothing there, we walk away.
- Amanda Rollins: Rosamie, how are you?
- Rosamie Klein: Better when I heard O'Toole go to prison.
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: Rape three, three counts. He'll do 15 years.
- Rosamie Klein: Good.
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: You and Eddie; things okay?
- Rosamie Klein: Yeah. After you talked to Eddie, before I agreed to testify, he and I talked a long time. He said he was so sad what I had to go through, and how much he loved me. We cried together. It's better now. Even better than before. I don't have to keep secrets from him anymore, so... thank you.
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: You, uh... you tell stories, Eddie, so I'm here to tell you a story. It's... um, it's a sad love story about a man who has a beautiful home, beautiful family, a beautiful wife, who loved him so much that she had to do a terrible thing to save their love.
- Eddie Klein: Tell me, Detective, is this story also about a man named Rory O'Toole?
- Lina Vasquez-Boyd: [to Olivia] I know O'Toole had been arrested, but now my husband... he's asking me non-stop if I cheated on him.
- Olivia Benson: Lina, you didn't do anything wrong. You were assaulted. Yeah, but I swore to him nothing happened. If we tell him that you weren't the only one, that you and the other women were forced, you had to...
- Lina Vasquez-Boyd: But even if he does believe me, he's always gonna be thinking about it. I have to get everything ready for Sebastian and Mavis before their mother comes home.
- Olivia Benson: Would it help if if I talked to him with you?
- Lina Vasquez-Boyd: No. He's already going crazy with jealousy. He's checking my text message, he's following me around...
- Olivia Benson: You sound like you're afraid of him.
- [notices Lina's face is injured]
- Olivia Benson: Lina... did he do this to you? Okay, listen to me. There's another option okay? You don't have to stay married to Joe. You were the victim of a crime and we can get you a U visa.
- Lina Vasquez-Boyd: So if I leave him, I can stay in this country?
- Olivia Benson: Yes. If you testify against O'Toole.
- Lina Vasquez-Boyd: But my husband's a good man, but he already doesn't believe me. I can't live like this anymore. I'll testify.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: The judge released O'Toole on his own recognizance. He claimed that he knew the marriage was fake and he was just trying to draw her out.
- Deputy Chief Christian Garland: You'd have a stronger case with someone he assaulted. What about his victims? Can we go back to them now that he's been arraigned?
- Olivia Benson: The two victims are terrified that their husbands will find out, and a third is sitting in ICE detention afraid that her husband will be deported.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Then try 'em all again. Three would be great, but if I have one, there goes his defense.
- Olivia Benson: We have two confirmed rapes, one jailed for saying no.
- Deputy Chief Christian Garland: They're not willing to testify.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: I can ask the U.S. Attorney for a warrant on O'Toole's minivan, but if I do that, the feds are gonna take the case.
- Deputy Chief Christian Garland: Yeah, it's so politically charged over there right now. I'm not confident they'll fight for these victims.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Agreed, but for these women to admit what happened to them is-is to risk losing everything.
- Olivia Benson: What if we brought in our own victims? I worked a joint task force with Homeland. I have a great contact over there. Let me see if I can get her to push a new green card application across O'Toole's desk.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: A green card honey trap?
- Deputy Chief Christian Garland: Do you have the UCs for it?
- Olivia Benson: I think that I do.
- Maggie Quigley: Four interviews, me and my husband sailed through. Then O'Toole says, "Flag on the play, darling." He needs one more meeting with me, after hours.
- Odafin Tutuola: Then what happened?
- Maggie Quigley: He picks me up in his minivan. Dirtbird had a mattress in the back.
- Katriona Tamin: What did he say?
- Maggie Quigley: He says if he grants the green card, me husband can make love to me any time. He says, "I deserve some loving, too." I told him I'd rather put the tailpipe of his minivan in me mouth.
- Odafin Tutuola: Then what'd he do?
- Maggie Quigley: He puts me in this effin' jumpsuit. Maybe I should've just shagged him. Got on with me American life, like.
- Katriona Tamin: You're the victim of a crime. If you agree to testify, we can get you a U visa and you won't be deported.
- Maggie Quigley: My husband Patrick's here on a green card, too. O'Toole finds out I'm testifying, first thing he'll do is try to deport Patrick back to Belfast. Then he'll have screwed us both.
- Deputy Chief Christian Garland: Do other employees back up Duane's story?
- Olivia Benson: Duane is O'Toole's number two in charge of case assignment. He's the only one who knows that O'Toole is cherry-picking them.
- Odafin Tutuola: You want proof, Chief? Get us access to O'Toole's computer and his phone records.
- Deputy Chief Christian Garland: We're dealing with ICE, too? Best not to ask for warrants until we have corroboration. Tell your subway groper to think harder. We need more names.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: I'll start with forcible touching, assaulting an officer.
- Olivia Benson: You know, if you get us a warrant for his home and office computers, we'll get more charges.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: He's immigration? That's Homeland Security.
- Deputy Chief Christian Garland: Yeah, they're their own fiefdom. We ask for a warrant, it'll be tit for tat.
- Olivia Benson: What if we don't ask?
- Amanda Rollins: Posting upskirt photos of women from your desk computer at your federal job? That's a class E felony. Duane, you're in a lot of trouble.
- Counselor April Andrews: Did you have a warrant for that?
- Odafin Tutuola: We don't need one. It's government property.
- Duane Varik: That pervert O'Toole dime me out? Makes sense. Last thing he would want is you going through his computer.
- Odafin Tutuola: Why is that?
- Counselor April Andrews: Hold on. Duane?
- [he leans over and whispers indistinctly in her ear]
- Counselor April Andrews: My client may have something to offer.
- Amanda Rollins: [after testifying] I didn't help you in there, counselor.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: It's okay. We're laying groundwork. Once Lina testifies that he did follow through, his whole defense falls apart.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Our scheduled witness is not available at this time, Your Honor. We move for a continuance.
- John Buchanan: Objection. I have a defense prepared. I'd like to move ahead with my case.
- Judge Felicia Catano: How long do you need, Mr. Carisi?
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: A few days, Your Honor.
- Judge Felicia Catano: I'll give you 'til 9:00 tomorrow.
- John Buchanan: At which time, if there is no further prosecution witnesses, we'll be moving ahead for a dismissal.
- Judge Felicia Catano: Don't get ahead of yourself, Mr. Buchanan.
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: Detective Rollins and I posed as a mixed-ethnicity, interreligious couple. We were hoping to draw Mr. O'Toole's attention, which we did.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Did he do follow-up interviews?
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: Not with me, but he asked for a private, night-time meeting with Detective Rollins in his minivan.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Thank you, Sergeant Khaldun.
- John Buchanan: So, you lied to a fellow officer about your religion, your marriage, your job, about every detail of your life?
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: It was an undercover operation.
- John Buchanan: In other words, it was a fake marriage. And my client figured it out.
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: I believe he thought our marriage was real, but the red flags it raised gave him leverage to sexually extort Detective Rollins.
- John Buchanan: You mean your fake wife. So, your testimony is that you're a good enough liar to fool a trained investigator with 20 years' experience?
- Sergeant Hasim Khaldun: You could put it that way.
- John Buchanan: How about a jury?
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Objection.
- John Buchanan: Withdrawn. Nothing further.
- Maggie Quigley: O'Toole's going to prison?
- Odafin Tutuola: If you testify.
- Maggie Quigley: What about my husband, Patrick?
- Katriona Tamin: O'Toole's under indictment awaiting trial. He can't have Patrick deported.
- Maggie Quigley: And I'll get that U visa? Stay in the U.S. as long as I want?
- [Kat nods]
- Maggie Quigley: Okay, I'm in. I'll testify.
- Odafin Tutuola: We're gonna need all the exact details. Dates, places, times.
- Maggie Quigley: O'Toole called me from a burner.
- Odafin Tutuola: So that would be on your cell phone?
- Maggie Quigley: Uh, they don't let me have that here.
- Katriona Tamin: What about Patrick? Does he have it?
- Maggie Quigley: Do you have to go through him? I never told him about this.
- Odafin Tutuola: He doesn't have to know. Not yet.
- Amanda Rollins: Mr. O'Toole told me I had to meet him in private in his minivan. And as you heard on the tape, he said if I wanted the green card, then I had to have sex with him.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: And what were his exact words?
- Amanda Rollins: That he deserved some loving, too.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Thank you, detective.
- John Buchanan: But you didn't have sex with my client, did you?
- Amanda Rollins: No.
- John Buchanan: He never assaulted you in any way?
- Amanda Rollins: No, but his intent was clear and graphic. He said we needed to go to the back of the van where there was a mattress.
- John Buchanan: And did you go to the back of the van?
- Amanda Rollins: No. My support team pulled open the doors before that could happen.
- John Buchanan: So, isn't it possible he was testing you to see if you were really a faithful wife?
- Amanda Rollins: Please. That is not what was going on.
- John Buchanan: Well... you were playing a role. Isn't it possible that he was playing one, too? Please answer the question, Detective.
- Amanda Rollins: Yes. Anything is possible.
- Duane Varik: And all the immigrant women Mr. O'Toole requested that I sent him were young, attractive, diverse, and desperate.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Desperate. How?
- Duane Varik: They fled gangs, war, poverty. They were terrified of being sent back.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: So terrified of being deported that they gave into Mr. O'Toole's sexual demands?
- John Buchanan: Objection. Calls for speculation.
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Withdrawn. Mr. Varik, is there a reason that your boss pulled these particular women's files?
- Duane Varik: Yes, he called it his Baskin-Robbins file. One in every flavor.
- John Buchanan: Mr. Varik, you made a deal with the prosecution to testify today?
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Your Honor, the jury already heard this on Mr. Varik's direct...
- John Buchanan: Yes, that's right. You were charged with forcible touching and unlawful sexual surveillance. That's upskirting, isn't it? Good thing I wore pants today.
- Judge Felicia Catano: Move along, Mr. Buchanan.
- John Buchanan: After you were arrested, the detectives found your upskirting files on your work computer?
- Duane Varik: Yes.
- John Buchanan: Who gave them access?
- Duane Varik: My supervisor, Mr. O'Toole.
- John Buchanan: And that's when you decided to play "Let's Make a Deal"?
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Objection.
- John Buchanan: I'll rephrase. According to your own testimony, you were aware of this egregious behavior for years, but you never reported it, never said a word about it to anyone?
- Duane Varik: I'm not proud of that.
- John Buchanan: You have a lot not to be proud of, Mr. Varik. Enough to make up charges like this to save your own ass?
- Dominick Carisi Jr.: Objection.
- John Buchanan: Withdrawn. Nothing further.