La santa muerte (2007) Poster

(II) (2007)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
Interesting topic, horrendous treatment.
jlms9 October 2007
Warning: Spoilers
First the context: there is currently an small boom of a cult to the "Santa Muerte" (Saint Lady Death) in Mexico which obviously is grabbing the attention of many people in the country. People in the Catholic community in Mexico has derided this cult in many different ways going as far as equating it with Satanism, this is important because the movie has clearly this bias.

The film presents three different histories whose only connection is the involvement of the Saint Lady Death as an object of cult, although the film mixes characters of the three different histories in the same shot, the histories do not touch each other (which makes these gimmicky shots frankly unnecessary, no Amores Perros here I'm afraid). Needless to say, this being a propagandistic film, the Saint Lady Death cult is portrayed as something negative, the characters rejecting it having happy endings, the ones that don't suffering as a consequence.

The biggest history of the three follows the troubles of a little girl who gets cancer and is declared terminally ill. The parents in desperation try every remedy under the Sun until the mother in a fortuitous way finds the cult and this seems to cure her daughter. As the family pleases or displeases the Saint Lady Death the health of the girl takes turns for the better or for the worse accordingly (the poor doctor treating her I am sure got fed up with so many miraculous changes), until finally a battle of sorts between good and evil takes place. To say the ending is corny and kitsch is an understatement, this is the god of the 10 commandments done without filmaking craftsmanship.

The second history shows the problems of a guy that losses his job and his luck goes from bad to worse until he starts worshipping the Saint Lady Death, similarly his luck changes in accordance to how well he follows the wishes of Lady Death.

The third history, almost incidental, shows how a woman betrays her best friend with the help of the Lady Death.

I had two big problems with this movie. First the propagandistic tone of the movie. There are several points in the main history in which the characters rant on and on about "Jesus Christ the true saviour", but this is not done with the intention of advancing the plot of the movie but to moralise and preach to the movie goers, the only way I can qualify this is as propaganda and I , as a non Christian, felt quite uncomfortable initially, but they go so much about this that it becomes a self parody.

The second problem I have is the bad acting. I am sorry to say but the acting is as wooden as it can get, perhaps the actors involved have worked mostly on TV ( telenovelas perhaps?) where quantity counts more than quality, this shows and badly. Perhaps the best actor in all the movie was the little girl, maybe because she does not have all the hangs on of working for TV soap operas.

A forgettable movie, if anything an example of how not to do a proselytising film.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Good Lord, why did you let this thing happen?
RichardKleiner23 October 2007
Warning: Spoilers
First let me state that I'm Christian, and I saw this film expecting it to be very good, since the theme itself is quite risky to deal about. The cult to "La Santa Muerte" is quickly gaining followers all around Mexico City. However, this cult is completely anti-biblical, since Death was actually Jesus' enemy (which He defeated, by the way).

Using a style strikingly similar to Iñarritu's "Amores Perros", the film tells three separate stories that usually cross roads but don't ever interact. However, the director pays attention to only one, about a girl with a terminal disease and her parents struggling to cure her. A second subplot, regarding an unfortunate man, is seen at the same time, but finishes quite quickly. Then, a third one appears out of nowhere with no coherent explanation. This one is about a man cheating on his wife, and the other woman does anything to be with the man. All this stories are linked by the cult on "La Santa Muerte". So, using this movie as a vehicle for a biblical message, director Paco Del Toro tries to spread the word to Mexican ignorants that dealing with "La Santa Muerte" is dangerous and not what it seems.

The problem: The film sucks.

I don't know where did Paco Del Toro get the idea that having a couple fighting, scratching and hitting going completely hysterical is an example of great acting. He tried this on "Cicatrices", and both times it looks fake and over the top. Overall, the acting is bad. But maybe the worst thing of all was the script. Nothing happens. Seriously, nothing remotely interesting happens. And the dialogs were so unrealistic, you even think the movie was dubbed in Argentina. "Esto es un atropello!" (this is an outrage in Spanish) is an expression not even old Mexican people say in their daily life. And, give me a break with the evangelical message. It couldn't sound more rehearsed. Not even the least experienced preachers would quote the bible so falsely.

Apparently, Del Toro thought of making this into a horror movie, but there isn't no horror at all. The only scene where you think something scary's gonna happen is the classic "it was nothing after all", and it was completely useless for the whole plot. The score is repetitive and exasperating, because, like in the film, nothing really happens.

The problem about Christian movies is that they're used only as a vehicle for an evangelical message, and there's really no concern for other details, far more important than it, movie-wise. Worst among this are Christian Mexican films. However, I did enjoy Del Toro's film "Punto y Aparte", since it had a controversial message and dealt with it in a very bold and forward move, yet, it worked pretty well. In "Cicatrices", the message and the impact was weaker, and the movie wasn't good. In "La Santa Muerte", the idea was incredibly bold, and was backed up by many Christian organizations, this resulting in all the hype and publicity it received prior to its release. So you might expect it to have an eye opening message and share the revealing truth to the world about this enslaving cult. But, when seeing the final product, you just end up with a bad taste, especially the cheesy end sequence (I mean, I believe in God, and that He can resurrect anyone from the dead, but the scene where the light shines from above the little girl and she revives is just lame, LAME!).

The movie will only be appealing to those who haven't seen one in their entire life. I plea to all Christian producers to stop making crappy films directed only to ignorant audiences, for cultured critics will ravage them, one after the next. Christian film-making can be better, you just need to see real talent and take lots of risks.

As a Christian, I can't recommend "La Santa Muerte" to anybody, because it will only scare them away from Christ, and they will find refuge in the same cult the film tried to speak against. It actually fails in its message, because it can only be understood by people who already know that the cult is demonic. This makes it a film with a very narrow fandom.

I liked the way to cross the stories. That's what kept me from giving the movie a 1. But, as much as I'd hate to admit it, the movie sucks.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Don't watch this!
skull0825 December 2007
By the title, you expect this movie to be a terror/suspense movie.. don't be fooled, it is not! the approach of the storyline is from the Christian standpoint, so basically the message of the movie is that praying to La Santa Muerte is the same as worshiping the devil and you should believe in Jesus Christ... I don't have a problem with that, however, the acting, storyline and dialogue it's just horrible!! no one in Mexico talks like the characters in the movie do, it's just not credible, everybody talks like it was some horrible soap opera and it's just plain annoying, it's ridiculous... The director used three or four stories in the movie and tried to use the Pulp Fiction approach in which all the story lines are connected somehow... something that has been done already in more successful/well directed movies in the past... Anyways, don't waste your time on this piece of crap movie, it's not worth it!
11 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Santas Muertes, Batman!
LatinoMan16 June 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Wow, I'm utterly amazed at how bad this movie is, it wins the title to worst movie of the decade hands down, either in Spanish or English...

Please, don't bother yourself with anything related to this sad excuse of a film (you should not even read these comments!), you surely will be sorry, like anyone else, for that. To say this movie is bad is an understatement, this is an abomination, an entire failure without the least redemption...

The worst part? When some characters preach gratuitously and try to shove us an evangelical message through our throats...

Lame!

By the way, this kind of films badmouth other noble, unbiased efforts at an independent, realist approach to Latinamerican cinema.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed