Yeast (2008) User Reviews

You always hurt the ones you love

[larry-411 · 6/10 · 15 March 2008]

I attended the World Premiere of "Yeast," Mary Bronstein's entry in this year's narrative features competition at the 2008 SXSW Film Festival. Many fans of the unscripted style were in attendance. It is that audience to which "Yeast" will hold the greatest appeal.

This mostly-improvised film follows a few days in the lives of three women struggling to keep friendship alive in the face of a huge challenge -- they know each other too well. Bronstein's character lashes out with aggression, Amy Judd withdraws in silence, and Greta Gerwig's character just wants to have a good time. They get on each other's nerves in a way only best friends can and, as we witness, it's just as easy to love someone who is close to you as it is to hate them.

"Yeast" was shot on Mini DV with a very homemade feel, using mostly intense and extreme closeups. As Bronstein explained in the Q&A after the screening, the use of two cameras enhances the unscripted nature of the film as it does not require reverse shots and multiple takes. It's more a semi-scripted docudrama/reality show than anything. Dialogue was originally written and rehearsed but, when it came time to shoot, the lines were tossed and actors encouraged to simply work out the general scenes. This allowed a more natural reacting style to take over.

"Yeast" exposes the fact that the people you are most comfortable with are the ones who can be the most annoying, and the easiest to annoy. It's a universal dilemma and is painful to watch at times but fascinating nonetheless.

Great movie

[jeffharms2000 · 10/10 · 18 June 2008]

Hilarious. During the first half hour all I could think of was how i was going to email all of the girls i know to tell them to see this. The camping arguments, the elusive mood swings, reminded me of all of them... But then Yeast is more universal than that, and by the halfway point i was reminded of my own mood swings, and my own unsolvable irrational hostilities. In retrospect it reminds me of Dostoyevski's Notes From the Underground. The misery, the conflict, relentless and almost self-satisfying. They subtly grin sometimes while they dig at each other.

I loved this movie. I am a big fan of Cassavettes, and this feels like a natural evolution of that thread of film-making. Although in Yeast the characters are more archetypal than "real". Don't get me wrong the performances of Mary Bronstein, Greta Gerwig and Amy Judd, of the whole cast are full of brilliantly wild subtle moments. During the film I thought a lot about "A Woman Under the Influence." But in this film, no one is outside the influence. Everyone is insane. I love the last shot of the girl alone, totally in need of the people she has treated so poorly, the people who all hate each other. To be lead by the hand up to a moment as emotionally complicated and ambiguous as that ending, well its just about the greatest thing in the world.

In the sense of being an 'indie' film, i should say i got a great thrill out of thinking about how it was made. Sneaking into the 'reserved' section of a burger king, walking through the turnstyles at Great America... I really felt like i was there. And this is the great advantage of this kind of film and why it succeeds where Hollywood fails. Movies shouldn't be afraid to keep the camera close to their actors. I really enjoy this sort of intimacy. What Yeast adds to this notion is the idea of cramming the most reactionary absurd conflict possible into that small and genuine space. I think ultimately the film starts to articulate something larger than just some great performances. there is something far more thoughtful and deliberate going on here.

I really dislike this word "mumblecore". I am very pleased to see that at least one group of filmmakers is kicking and screaming their way towards articulating a more impassioned vision.

Floundering female friendships...

[phoenixx100 · 10/10 · 25 October 2009]

I really enjoyed Yeast, and was surprised at how much more emotive the 'unscripted' directorial style is. Although I'm not a cinema student or major buff of any kind really, I found myself fascinated by this more natural way of crafting a film. The characters truly came alive for me, and I found myself feeling real sympathies for them and their frustrations with one another.

The profound constipation of communication was truly palpable at times, and this very fact, kind of eclipsed the need for there to be a more definite tale to tell. For me, the inability of the characters to be wholly at peace with one another, is what this story is all about. As another reviewer explained, this really is a 'universal dilemma,' and a very disturbing and sad one at that.

Mary Bronstein's character Rachel, although depicted as something of an emotional tyrant, evoked feelings of sincere sympathy within me; I'm a guy, but I have often observed similar difficulties in close female friendships. It was very entertaining and involving to watch, and I suspect that this excellent film will leave many viewers with a strange lingering feeling of voyeuristic guilt.

Rises with a good issue and good points

[StevePulaski · 8/10 · 23 August 2012]

Mary Bronstein's Yeast is an intriguing step in the already extensive timeline of the now decade-old cinematic movement of mumblecore. The film explores the idea of female friendships and how they can deteriorate over time for reasons that are inherent and sometimes inevitable. Ever know someone you knew for a long time and they knew how to be your closest friend as well as having almost immediate access to under your skin and an instant pipeline to what makes you tick?

In just seventy-seven minutes, Bronstein explores the behavior of females in tight situations and says a mouthful. She plays Rachel a good-natured but needy, vindictive woman living in a low-rent apartment with her roommate Alice (Amy Judd). She is friends with Alice, but lately, has been triggering Rachel's maximum tolerance for shady and silent behavior.

She abruptly refuses to go on a simple getaway with Rachel and her close friend, Gen (Greta Gerwig), which leads Rachel to just leave her in the dust as they go out and hopefully have a great time. Gen begins to engage in some outrageous acts of disobedience and disregard for others' feelings by either taunting a group of campers nearby or just not taking into consideration her friends feelings. She acts in a lawless, inconsequential manner that drives to Rachel to almost ending the friendship.

She returns home to Alice, whose lackadaisical personality is hitting critical mass. She does not do dishes (or any chores for that matter), has a disgustingly incompetent and listless agenda, is surly and insufferable, and just completely offputting. The remainder of the film is devoted to Rachel's one-on-one talks with Alice.

Yeast describes itself as, "a maddeningly oblivious, tyrannical, and emotionally stunted young woman tries her best to negotiate two toxic friendships." The film faults all the characters in a subtle yet direct way, never making any out to be truly innocent, but only to ones perspective. One can view Rachel as justified to complain about her friends' attitudes, and another could fault her for being self-indulgent and equipped with a "everyone needs to be like me - open and properly mannered" personality. This is the effect of an impressive script, which was reportedly mostly improvised giving it a pleasantly naturalistic feel.

It is expected that those who embrace mumblecore films with an open mind and a sense of life will emerge greatly fulfilled, while those expecting a traditional take on a unique subject will casually dismiss it. I believe those are the two ways you can view the cinematic movement and there's rarely an "in between stance" with a mumblecore film. You either connect with it and are satisfied or are left cold and unmoved. Yeast does a fantastic job showing us a scarcely discussed aspect of feminine friendships that I'd much rather see than women parading in skimpy, tight outfits oppressively boasting their "neo-feminine" side. Charlie's Angels anyone?

Starring: Mary Bronstein, Greta Gerwig, and Amy Judd. Directed by: Mary Bronstein.