CSI: Miami (TV Series) Presumed Guilty (2009) User Reviews

Absolutely Zero Credibility On This One

[ccthemovieman-1 · 23 July 2011]

I've always laughed, and not complained, at the unrealistic "scientists" on CSI: almost all young and beautiful/handsome. However, in this episode the characters were just so not credible, it's ludicrous.

No judge looks like the guy in this story. The same goes for the golf pro, the country club people, the attorneys, etc., etc. - nobody in real life looks like or sounds like the people portrayed in this story.

The guest star, Sean "P. Diddy" Combs, might be the worst actor I've ever seen on this program.

As for the story - the golf instructor being falsely accused of murder and the CSI team trying to prove that after he's been convicted - it's okay for awhile. However, the ending is brutally inane and an insult to people's intelligence. Oh, well, most people agree this seventh season was not the best in this usually-solid program....but it's still worth watching.

Worst guest star of all time!

[jazzycate · 6/10 · 10 February 2009]

I normally enjoy this show, although it is basically "CSI for Dummies." Doesn't have quite the intellectual/science focus of the other two CSIs, more flash, MTV style filming, and showcase for improbable technology than serious crime solving. But still it is a guilty pleasure. This particular episode, however, was brought down considerably by the performance of guest star Sean Puffy Puff Daddy P. Diddy Combs, or whatever he is calling himself today. "Don't give up your day job, you are definitely not an actor, even though you obviously take yourself very seriously," I just had to laugh. Pathetic guest star garners this episode 6 stars. Without him, the story line and regular stars would have been closer to an 8.