"Caprica" Pilot (TV Episode 2009) Poster

(TV Series)

(2009)

User Reviews

Review this title
10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Very Impressive!
ryan-123717 April 2009
This is the most intelligent and impressive sci-fi series pilot I have ever seen. The dialog is excellent and the acting superb. The show brings to the realm of sci-fi the quality and excellence that the Sopranos, Deadwood and The Tudors brought to HBO and Showtime.

I was a fan of the first couple seasons of Battlestar Gallatica however I felt that the show lost its way and proceeded onward for financial gain versus a commitment to excellence. Caprica begins much more intelligently and better-crafted than its predecessor, Battlestar Gallatica, did and with even better talent.

Eric Stolz and Esai Morales were excellent casting choices! They both bring a dignity and vitality to their characters.

I hope the show is picked up and we are privileged with several seasons of intelligent, dramatic and suspenseful sci-fi from this great ensemble.
28 out of 35 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
what a start !
MattDevivre23 April 2009
In a dark and mysterious way the "Caprica" pilot gives you a first impression of the futuristic world of this upcoming new sci-fi show and obviously once again there's far more than meets the eyes. Though fans of "Battlestar Galactica" of course will know many of the facts given but I'd say it still is fascinating to see this scenario of the past and there seems to be more to it than just telling fictive history.

Until the events of BSG will take place a few years are left. Therefore a lot is different to the known BSG setting and consequently a lot will change. It could become very interesting to watch this transition ! Though I consider "Battlestar Galactica", a good show I've never gotten into it. Still I've always thought it provided a fine pre-story. Therefore it sounds like a clever move finally doing "Caprica" ! Well and after all this pilot made a great first impression. One thing I especially enjoyed: "Caprica" seems more focused on narration and less on action than BSG. It provides terrific storytelling skills and it makes excellent use of the 90min TV-format. Slow but steady build-up, never wasting too much time and after all not too hasty on the exposition of characters.

In a short: "Caprica" has great potential for at least one fantastic season. Probably the best pilot I've seen in a long long time. Keeps you watching and the plot isn't all too obvious right from the start. I hope the creators are able to keep this high narrative level !
27 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
High-end production, smart science-fiction, great casting and characters, numerous interesting topics, fascinating and well-written story
igoatabase23 October 2009
Almost two years ago I watched the Battlestar Galactica mini-series and 33, the season 1 first episode of the reimagined version. I was so impressed by it that I got my hand on its DVD to watch the full season. However for some reason, probably an evil copy protection system or dumb region encoding, I never managed to play it using my media center. To sum things up, I have never seen the first season so I don't know much about BG. But considering the high impact the mini-series and pilot had on me I had no doubt Caprica would be a great show. However now that I have seen its pilot I can say it just broke the dream barrier of my highest expectations.

First the production quality is really good. There're still a few mistakes, like some bad lighting at times, but overall it's top notch. The interior designers worked really hard and the comfy-techy Graystone house should blow away most viewers. The digital visual effects are so well mixed to the real settings that it dramatically smooths the immersion process. All the high-end gadgets and technologies are also quite interesting because they're in fact just improved versions of the cellphones or ebook readers we daily use for example.

All these elements contribute to anchor Caprica in our reality. It's not just fiction, it's a vision of what our world could be in fifty years or less. It's the whole point of science-fiction but the events never felt so palpable. Moreover the casting is impressive and even if I had never seen the performers before I'm already convinced by their talent and found Eric Stoltz was perfect as Daniel Graystone. He should be the Gaius Baltar of Caprica as he invented a virtual reality device and is working on a robot. eXistenZ and Terminator were the first referenced that came to my mind but more recently I also think Virtuality should be considered.

The story itself is just fascinating and all the contemporary topics covered make the show even more interesting : Religion, terrorism, mind (Dollhouse ?), death… In fact the beginning was slow because the writers took the time of properly introducing the characters but once some major and dramatic event occurred, the arc unfolded and then the minutes became like seconds. Moreover it was really unexpected and it felt like if I was actually watching the news. Moreover the action takes place 58 years before BG so we know what's coming but as with the Terminator franchise it makes the story even more intriguing. It's the how that matters the most here and not the "What will happen ?".

However I can't help pointing out a few mistakes and a certain lack of attention to details. For example even if the fictional world is believable I think it's still a bit too contemporary and at times I even thought the action was occurring years ago when the visuals should depict a relatively far future. However it didn't repel me and somehow it even seduced me because it made the collision between the traditional and technological worlds even more impressive. An other disappointment was the solution Daniel found to his research issue. How he managed to get things done was interesting because it was like solving a puzzle but his decision was a cliché because the idea has already been used dozens of times. I'm sure the writers could have come up with something more original if they had the time. The drone-like robot at the house seemed misplaced because its actions didn't really require mobility. Is it some sort of twisted reference to Wall•E ? But again I'm probably just picky because that mechanical pet made the scenes more entertaining in the end. Last but not least I also didn't quite like how the virtual club was depicted as it looked like a messy mash-up of dark underground fantasies. I think the writers should have focused on a single room with one type of event happening. Moreover the scenes were rushed and it was nothing like Eyes Wide Shut for example.

But beside these few cons I already consider Caprica as a true sci-fi masterpiece. It was both scary, smart and fascinating. Morever according to Wikipedia the show "will have a story arc-heavy format" like BG so the writers will have the time to deeply cover the events and make them as accurate as possible.
11 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Great pilot that leaves where BSG takes off
zerobeat23 January 2010
Warning: Spoilers
When I saw some reviews of this that said things like "I loved BSG in the 70's and hated the remake and thus hated Caprica" or "it was so confusing" I just knew it would have a huge leg- up in terms of appealing to me. Yes sir, I did like it.

If you don't like watching something where you have to pay attention to every second, and can't sort of casually watch it and maybe talk a bit through it, or go to the bathroom without pausing the video, then this will definitely not appeal to you. There are virtually no "cool scenes". Let's hope this is what the eventual series will be like. And let's hope that any "cool scenes" are there by accident of serving the story, and not some soulless minion of orthodoxy in a suit ordering the show-runners that "you need a cool scene here to appeal to people who don't care about intelligence, complexity and/or story arcs".

Of course, I'm not saying that if you don't like the show that it's precisely because you don't care about intelligence, complexity and/or story arcs. The thoughtful mind is boundless, and so are its tastes.

My big beef so far is that it appears that the avatar of Adama's daughter (Tamara) is given the same emotional depth and memory and realism as the avatar of Graystone's daughter (Zoe). Yet it was established that Zoe had programmed her own artificially intelligent avatar while she was still alive, thus making it plausible that it would be so utterly realistic (a difference that makes no difference is no difference at all). But Tamara's was generated after she was dead, relying only on public records of her existence, so at best it should only have been superficially her without self-awareness.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Genesis of the Cylons
Tweekums3 May 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Fifty eight years before the events shown in the opening of 'Battlestar Galactica' the people of Caprica and the other colonies have no idea what is to come. That doesn't mean that all is well though; an underground monotheistic group wants to change society; this group includes Zoe Graystone, the daughter of prominent cyberneticist Daniel Graysyone. She and some of her friends plan to leave Caprica but as they leave one of their number detonates a suicide belt on a train killing them along with many other people. This isn't the end of Zoe though; she has created a copy of herself on an illicit web site; this is no mere avatar but a complete copy complete with all her memories and emotions, perhaps her very soul. Daniel learns of her existence, thanks to catching one of Zoe's friends accessing her computer, and after initial scepticism comes up with a plan to bring her back using the cybernetic technology he has been working on. To do this he will have to get the help of Joseph Adama, a lawyer with some dubious contacts whose wife and daughter were with Zoe at the time of the explosion.

Having enjoyed 'Battlestar Galactica' I came into this a little unsure of what to expect; on the one hand the pedigree is good on the other I knew it didn't survive for long. It turned out, at least on the strength of this pilot, I needn't have worried. While this is set in the same universe it is very much its own show with a very different style. It opens well with a scene set in an online nightclub that shows a decadence I didn't expect before introducing Zoe and her friends who are no longer impressed with such behaviour and appear to want something more from life. Having set Zoe up as the protagonist it was a real shock when she was killed and it emerges that her father will be the main protagonist along with Joseph Adama. Adama provides some surprises too; we know his son is the protagonist in 'Battlestar Galactica' so it wasn't expected that Joseph was involved in such shady dealings. The story does a good job of showing how the warrior Cylons came in to existence as well as hinting at how the human looking ones might be eventually be made. As well as telling a good story this does a good job of showing Caprican society complete with racial prejudices between the colonies and a distinctive religious system. The cast does an impressive job; Eric Stoltz and Esai Morales stand out as Daniel Graystone and Joseph Adama but there are also notable performances from Alessandra Torresani as Zoe and Polly Walker as a teacher at Zoe's school who may be involved with the monotheists. Overall I'd say that this was a great pilot episode that kept be gripped from start to finish; I hope to be able to watch the rest of the series at some point.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Thumbs up!
harbcard23 May 2009
If the show lives up to the pilot, I think you have the makings of real destination TV. I was not a fan of BSG's reboot only because it really became such a hopeless vision. I read all the reviews on how it was a post 9/11 Sci-fi world but it really didn't offer a solution only a dream of a solution. This prequel shows how dreams are perverted. In a very entertaining way, with a great cast. I'm there for the series. Eric Stolz was great. The CGI work was better than average for TV. I need to know more about the fedora wearing Taurons. Also why was there a Ramada on Caprica, as evidenced in the reflection in the coffee shop's door.
8 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Caprica
inghels-timothy27 September 2010
Of course you wonder what the resemblances are with Battlestar Galactica the TV series. I've only seen a couple of episodes so for the story I can't give any confirmation on how this prequel is correct. Only the special effects are almost the same, tacky in a way that they don't seem to fit completely in the real picture, I've noticed this two in the series. They could be better.

It's set in an already high tech, futuristic world, cool, fancy stuff is used frequently, also the settings are very nice. For the intro this means a certain spoof is going on, around which the movie evolves further, don't get fooled by this. It's certainly a touching story and all the elements of the series are there, just not in space.

There's a bigger thing going on between rising forces and in this growing contradiction, we only see certain pawns who seem to set it off. It's a very good creational story, I must say, also well supported and acted by Daniel and Allesandra. It touches the boundaries of the mind. Also a good scoop of action is given but in a different amount I expected, it still has to turn bad in the Galactic way, you get a very interesting concept of what's about to happen! Very cool!

Additionally I would like to start a FAQ here, asking why this seems to be the pilot, the first episode of the TV series 'Caprica'? I watched this 'movie' of 93 minutes, thinking it's a prequel to the TV series (2004-2009), instead IMDb states it consists of the first three episodes of the series 'Caprica, telling the exact same story'. Is this movie just a mashed together version of the three episodes? Or is this movie just them?
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
An interesting beginning at a much lower pace
wmfranken21 July 2010
Having just finished watching all of Battlestar Galactica, I was curious what Ron D. Moore's next endeavour would be like. In short, this pilot wasn't like BSG, and didn't really even have the same feel. Most differences are in the camera, which isn't the shaking documentary style, but a rather more classical affair. The music's pretty laid back, although there's still good use of interesting and uncommon instruments. Both in tone, setting and general presentational feel, it reminded me a little of a random very long dragged-out episode of the show "the outer limits". I don't consider that a bad reference, but it's certainly no BSG. The air is mysterious, ominous and inquisitive, which hasn't been done in a while in scifi shows as I recall, but seeing how many "the outer limit" episodes were made, it's not that unique either. It's rather strangely interesting, but somehow less compelling than intended.

On the whole, the story of this pilot was good as a meticulous introduction, but stretched somewhat too thin for my liking. Maybe it's because I just finished the Daybreak episodes of BSG, which were so full of high speed info, both in your face and between the lines, that my head seemed to explode for a whole day after watching them. But even so, Caprica's pilot takes quite a long while to kick-start and really lets all information sink in slowly. Very gracious, but if you've seen existenz and the matrix, or even fight club, you will (too) easily follow. Nothing wrong with that, but after the hectic blood pumping style incorporated in Moore's previous work, I just suddenly feel bored for being able to keep up so easily. Feeling bored would not be a good thing I believe. I realise the show might want to delve deeper into an audience beyond the scifi crowd, or the dedicated BSG fans, but it's a fine line for those fans to be bored with science gimmicks they've seen a hundred times over, and overheating the brains of anybody upgrading from "Friends" or even "Frasier". As it is, so far so "ok", but nothing revolutionary is to be found in the plot, so it's up to characterisation to save the day. Fortunately, the two leads are good, especially Graytone, with Adama taking a bit of a back seat here. It'll be interesting to see how the two develop. I do hope the Twilight/Buffy feel surrounding the teens will be reduced somewhat. It's not very original and it probably falls flat for most adults.

The ending of the episode shows were the story can take us, which is tantalising, even though I'm not sure if it's ultimately worth the effort depending on the future pacing. So, the cylons, or cybernetic life-form nodes, yes yes, some seriously creative retrospect acronym creation went on here, is this what we all came for, or just a bait? Well, time will tell. How did the cylon centurions start their existence, how might they have achieved the monotheistic beliefs and rebellious nature that would ultimately bring about the first human- cylon war? If you want answers to these questions, stick around for possible revelations. I probably will, lured in as I am, but here's to hoping the presentation will become a little more exciting.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An excellent and extremely engrossing pilot
GusF18 September 2013
Warning: Spoilers
One thing that always fascinated me about "Battlestar Galactica" was the existence of a separate species of humans who developed their own advanced civilisation which was, in many ways, very similar to our early 21st Century one and in others very different. While the premise of that series precluded it from exploring this society in any depth beyond the occasional use of flashbacks (which I wish had been used more frequently), such exploration is this series' bread and butter.

Through the Graystones, we are presented with a privileged and rather decadent section of society which is intoxicated by its own success. Through the Adamas, we are presented with the ordinary lives of reasonably successful but not rich people in the richest of the Twelve Colonies in the case of Joseph and his family and the criminal underworld of the Twelve Colonies in the case of Joseph's brother Sam as well as the Ha'la'tha. Since our society has multiple dimensions to it, both good and bad, it makes sense that the same would be true of both Caprica and the Twelve Colonies as a whole. Often in science fiction, alien societies can be rather one note but this certainly isn't true of this one, which is human and yet rather alien to the audience. Caprica City feels entirely real. It reminds me of New York City as it strikes me as a city that never sleeps but it could really be a stand-in for any major city in the mid to late 20th Century or early 21st Century.

Given its advanced technology such as household robots (the use of which seems to be confined to the rather rich) and holobands (seemingly more readily available to the public if the V Club is anything to go by), the series' universe seems rather futuristic, perhaps 40 to 50 years ahead of us. However, it also feels somewhat retrofuturistic given that the most of the men's clothes look like they are straight out of the 1950s, not to mention the fact that household robots and robots in general are frequently seen in such stories. Another manner in which the series' atmosphere seems reminiscent of the 1950s is the very open racism exhibited towards Tauron, whose people are frequently referred to using the racist epithet "dirt eaters." While in our society racism has certainly not gone away, such frequent displays of racism in public are quite unusual in 2013 as many bigots confine their comments to the Internet where they think that they are anonymous. That is another manner in which the series seems retrofuturistic as, in this regard and possibly others, its societal development seems out of step with its technological development. In some respects, it feels like a period drama crossed with a science fiction one.

In other respects, however, it is a very early 21st Century series. The Soldiers of the One tie into the modern fear of terrorists and, like the most effective spies and terrorists, blend into their environment like a chameleon if Sister Clarice Willow, the principal of the Athena Academy, is anything to go by. In fact, they are quite similar to the Cylons in that respect. Given that the Cylons' belief in a single, all powerful god came from the Centurions rather than the Final Five, I'm very curious to see the connection between the Cylons and the STO. Furthermore, Ben Stark's suicide bombing of the Lev train illustrates how dangerous and pervasive terrorist organisations and religious cults can be as the Soldiers of the One were able to indoctrinate a previously good and decent 16-year-old boy into not only sacrificing his own life for their ideals and beliefs but murdering his girlfriend and dozens of innocent strangers as a demonstration of the frightening strength of their resolve and their power over the minds of the vulnerable. As with its parent series, "Caprica" is certainly not afraid to tackle the more unpleasant aspects of modern society and even humanity. Such total and unwavering devotion to anything – be it politics or religion – fascinates me from an intellectual point of view but absolutely terrifies me from an emotional one. I have to admit that the latter always wins out over the former.

As well as exploring the best and worst that humanity has to the offer, the series also considers the question of what it means to be human, one of the oldest ideas in philosophical thought, let alone science fiction. The Zoe Graystone who was raised by her parents and lived in the outside world may have been killed in the Lev train explosion but another Zoe, a virtual avatar named Zoe A, survives in cyberspace. However, she is more than just a mere echo of a dead girl. While she was created by collecting all available information relating to Zoe's personality, likes, dislikes, etc. rather than copying her personality directly, the two Zoes are practically indistinguishable. Zoe A knows that she is not a person in the conventional sense but nevertheless feels and, after considerable reluctance on both of their parts, is accepted as being one by her best friend Lacy Rand and her father Daniel Graystone. On the other hand, Joseph Adama is more reluctant to acknowledge the virtual version of his late daughter Tamara as being human, let alone his child. He describes creating life and cheating death as being an "abomination," though seemingly not due to religious convictions as he had previously told his brother Sam that he did not believe in the gods. He tells his young son Willie, who has been severely depressed since the deaths of his mother and sister, that they are dead and are not coming back. However, I have a feeling that he may come around eventually, just as Graystone did.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
A Complete Mess
claudio_carvalho4 July 2009
Warning: Spoilers
My wife and I have just spent one hour and half of our lives watching the DVD with the pilot of this series released this week in Brazil. As fans of 'Battlestar Galactica" from the late 70's that did not like the remake, we had good expectations with this show, but unfortunately the story is a complete mess. It begins with a "great" explanation: "Caprica, 58 Years Before the Fall"; and then we see a club with half-naked women and three teenagers plotting something. And the confusion goes on, with an explosion in a train caused by one of the youngsters. There is no development of characters or situation that should be expected in any pilot of a TV series, only weird but never intriguing situations thrown on the screen, blended with special effects and beautiful locations. And nothing else! My vote is one (awful).

Title (Brazil): "Caprica"
16 out of 52 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed