I would have loved this episode even if TAPS hadn't found anything. I've been going to Star Island for years and I've had a paranormal experience as have many young people who have worked and vacationed there. So when I heard that TAPS was going to investigate I was psyched. Many old Star Island friends were treating this like the super bowl, party's and all.
The investigation was very fun to watch, especially when the team commented on a creepy painting of a baby and a ghost commented back. However the episode would have been much better if TAPS had gone to the paranormal hot spots. The team skipped one of the most haunted rooms on the island where the ghost of little boy is said to have been seen. They also could have gotten some pretty good evidence if the set some cameras up near a old monument haunted by Black Beards wife. But the lack of activity may be because so few people were on the island, during the summer season when people are on the island 24/7 is when most of the activity happens.
All in all TAPS' investigation of Star Island is more enjoyable for those who have visited the island but offers some interesting evidence.