"How I Met Your Mother" Natural History (TV Episode 2010) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
One of my favorite episodes ever
simbrab24 July 2016
This one is easily the best episode of season 6 so far and one of my favorite episodes of the whole series. This is one of the rare cases where all main characters are equally represented in three equally strong story lines that all provide good laughs as well as more serious, emotional moments.

Let's start with Ted. He unexpectedly runs into his arch-enemy Zoey as the gang is invited to a high class event at the Natural History Museum, courtesy of GNB. As it turns out, she is married to an old rich man who calls himself The Captain. Ted is visibly excited upon learning about this new side of her and can't stop mocking her and her elitist friends, which results in great hilarity. This is the funniest and wittiest Ted we have seen in a long time. I love him in this role. Sadly, he soon falls for Zoey's fake tears and gets tricked into talking trash about GNB and his own project, which is disappointing to watch and the only low point in an otherwise brilliant episode. He makes up for it in his following exchange with The Captain, a well written dialogue delivered by two great characters.

Marshall and Lily take on a more serious issue. While working at GNB, Marshall has lost part of his idealistic attitude and has put off his plans of working in environmental law. Lily is worried about this change in his attitude, partly because he spends so many hours at his job and partly because she fears that this change might affect some of his other views as well. A realistic portrayal of a relatable problem. And yet the writers manage to get some hilarious moments out of that storyline, mostly via an imaginary conversation between Lily and "College Marshall". As it turns out, Marshall has not changed when it comes to their relationship, and Lily has to accept that he is "Corporate Marshall" at this point in his life. But that might not be the end of the story after all...

But the best part of the episode is once again the Barney and Robin storyline. It starts out as a funny but harmless little filler piece. They dare each other to touch and play with exhibits, and as Neil Patrick Harris is involved, of course there are some good laughs. And I have to say, although I didn't like their stint as a couple in season 5 (though that wasn't the only thing I didn't like about season 5), that Barney and Robin have great chemistry here. Eventually they get caught by a security officer, who then rambles on about all the pranks and shenanigans he has seen since working at the museum, including dinosaurs from the cretaceous period hanging out with dinosaurs from the jurassic period. This is one of my favorite jokes of the episode, as it is both a nod at the "cats and dogs living together" line from Ghostbusters and a hilarious reference of a common mistake in dinosaur-themed movies and even museums. And then, out of nowhere, a revelation that entirely changes the tone and leads into a serious and emotional finale. A final masterstroke that takes an already thoroughly funny and well-balanced episode to another level.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Natural History (#6.8)
ComedyFan201026 July 2015
Warning: Spoilers
This episode goes on with Zoey vs Ted conflict and makes it now a bit more complicated. Looks like her character will stay for a while. In this story I was mainly happy to see Kyle MacLachlan as a guest star in the role of Captain, Zoey's husband.

I liked the story of Lily and Marshall more. The two always manage to make me feel good. Even though for the most of the episode there was sadness. I get the idea that people change, but somehow it was sad that Marshall changed in this area, I want to see him save the world too. Although this may still happen as we saw that Corporate Marshall is now extinct.

And the story about Barney finding his dad was also good. Especially since it happened in such a funny way that shows him and Robin as such rule breaking brats.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A Revelation Is Made
slightlymad2226 January 2015
More of the same as Zoe continues her campaign to save The Arcadian, and stop the new GNB building from being made, and ruin Ted's dream in the process.

Plot In A Paragraph: The Gang attend a black tie function at the Museum Of Natural History, Ted runs in to Zoe, who continues to cause him problems, Meanwhile Marshall and Lily are struggling with who they are, and Barney and Robin play a game of seeing who can touch the most things that say "Do Not Touch" which leads to a surprise revelation.

I enjoyed the Barney storyline, and the ensuing revelation but less so everything else. I really dislike the Zoe character, and hope they do not pursue this as a romantic interest for Ted, although all the signs point to it.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Whale
bevo-1367815 June 2020
I like the bit where they touched all the stuff at the museum
6 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Unfunny, uninteresting and just plain boring
SLionsCricketreviews19 December 2015
The plot synopsis for this episode says that Barney makes a stunning discovery as to the identity of his father. Of course, this is in no way a plot point of the episode. Rather, it is just a cliffhanger that occurs after a series of lame and boring interactions between Robin and Barney.

We do get a sense of Lily and Marshall's relationship at a potentially risky zone, as Marshall is further corrupted by the power of GNB. This plot reminds me of Season 5 of Joss Whedon's "Angel", where our group of heroes move into Wolfram & Hart. This is perhaps a point of influence, but everything to do with the occupations and complications of all characters is really beginning to feel flat.

At just the standard 22 minutes, this episode was a chore to sit through. Downright unfunny, depressing (although some of it was intentional) and awkwardly slow, "How I Met Your Mother" really no longer is about 'The Mother' - who knows when it will be
3 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed