The Death of Poor Joe (1901) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
The Dickens You Say!
boblipton9 March 2012
Here we have the earliest surviving film version of a Dickens work, an incident from BLEAK HOUSE.... perhaps. Bits of OLIVER TWIST on screen date from 1897, but they are lost; the 1901 version of A CHISTMAS CAROL does what it can in a couple of minutes, which is not much, unless you know the work.

This one is only a couple of minutes, and its events are pretty much summed up in the title. It's done in one shot, clearly on a stage. It's about as uncinematic as you can get, even for the era. Nonetheless, we'll call it interesting from a historic viewpoint. Dickens stuff translates very well to the screen because his style of story-telling became the model. His work was strongly influenced by the magic lantern, the cinema's precursor and a source of many of its techniques. Nonetheless, unless you are a deep-dyed film history fan, this is not for you.
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
It appears to just be a scrap of film
planktonrules28 March 2020
Most early silent films have disappeared and will never be seen again due to the volatility of the nitrate film stock and indifference, at the time, about what to do with the movies after they've been shown. In addition, most films around 1901 were very, very short (1-2 minutes) and had little in the way of effects and story. So, you really have to adjust your expectations accordingly and realize that the films STILL have significant cultural and historical value.

"The Death of Poor Joe" is a film that MIGHT be from a longer film or set of films about the Dickens story "Bleak House". It consists of a street sweeper in the winter succumbing to the elements....and not much more. The background, like other films of the day, is obviously painted and there's a bit of fake snow tossed in to the story. Not much more to it....and very difficult to rate.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed