The Case for Christmas (2011 TV Movie) User Reviews

Miracle on Court Street

[boblipton · 5/10 · 22 November 2011]

This updated version of MIRACLE ON THIRTY-FOURTH STREET has Santa facing a class-action suit for disappointing children at Christmas. He hires lawyer Dean Cain, a widower in emotional lockdown over the death of his wife.

I was expecting something very treacly, but it's a pretty good flick. George Buza makes a perfect Santa, Rachel Blanchard is excellent as the girl who loves Dean Cain.Cain is good. I do find the elves annoying rather than funny, but I am sure they will appeal to the majority of the audience of this Hallmark movie.

The whimsy this movie demands is tough to maintain. George Seaton managed MIRACLE ON 34TH Street by working from his own script in which he always took every plot point seriously -- he was one of the rare writer-directors of the era. THE CASE FOR SANTA CLAUS occasionally tries to get silly and occasionally serious. When this movie is at its best, it is because it takes real, small issues seriously. Wait for those moments and you'll not be disappointed.

Good family Christmas movie

[joab-70946 · 7/10 · 29 January 2018]

In this Christmas movie, businessman, Braxton Bennett, tries to have it legally pronounced that Santa doesn't exist, therefore doing away with Christmas spirit. When Santa is served, he goes to fight the suit and meets Lily. She's a young girl who believes in Santa and Christmas. She completely believes he really is Santa when he tells her what he brought her for Christmas last year. When she hears of Santa's problem, she coaxes her father, Michael Sherman (a lawyer) into helping him. Micheal thinks the man is insane and is worried that being associated with the case will cost him credibility as a lawyer. Why is Bennett suing Santa Claus? He obviously doesn't have Christmas spirit.

This is a nice holiday movie with a good cast. There is even a bit of romance in it with widowed Michael and his friend Lauren. I enjoyed this movie and children will too. Thanks to Santa, his elves and the workshop.

Not good

[dougdelise-1 · 4/10 · 13 November 2014]

I have seen many of holiday movies over the years, this is one that can be easily missed. It has a very weak story, and is a Miracle on 34th Street rip off. The poor writing is compounded by bad acting by those in lead rolls. Weak dialog, inconsistent character interaction, poor character development makes me believe this project was ill conceived from the start. I found myself tempted to turn this movie off and delete it as I recorded it on DVR. Then decided to suffer through it like have a root canal without enough Novocain. Why you ask? To see if I was correct in the predictability of the storyline ending. I'm sure that somewhere there is some that may enjoy this movie that does have two bright spots...the young daughter, and the neglected love interest. Too bad Santa comes across as an absentminded mumbling old man. While his Lawyer is totally clueless, aggravated by a poor performance by Dean Cain. Do yourselves a holiday favor and stay away from this movie, I gave it a four because after all....It is Christmas.

Kids from two to 92 will enjoy this very good Christmas season film

[SimonJack · 8/10 · 15 February 2022]

"The Case for Christmas" is one of the few movies of the Christmas holidays romance genre that was obviously made for families to watch at home - especially parents with small children. That doesn't mean that older children and adults themselves wont enjoy it. I think most will because it combines fantasy with some light comedy and romance. Most people enjoy fantasy that is good, wholesome or adventurous. So, this really is a Christmas family film.

While it's not likely that any modern movie will able to match the few mid-20th century Christmas films that have become family classics, good films with good plots, screenplays and performances are always welcome and add to the enjoyment of movies over the holiday season. And while the plot for this film is fairly simple, it has two things especially going for it that lift it above the pack of annual holiday films. The first is the fantasy aspect, with the humor as Santa and his managing elf, Charlie frequently exchange places - between the North Pole and New York City - at the twitch of a nose.

The second big plus for this film is the acting by the lead characters. The portrayals by Dean Cain as Michael, Rachel Blanchard as Lauren, and Helen Colliander as Lily are so natural, not exaggerated or hammy or overplayed or under played. It's as though they weren't aware of the camera being there and shooting the scenes. The opening of the film at the North Pole had me thinking that this might be a very hokey film. But the first few minutes in the home of Michael and Lily, and I was set to enjoy this film and see how it would turn out. One knew right away that it would be Michael who would be defending Santa in the courtroom

And, with the court case involving Kris Kringle, the film begs comparison with the 1947 classic, "Miracle on 34th Street." And, some other reviewers dutifully note. But for the matter of a court case with the scenes in court, the bulk of this film is quite different. This film uses lots of fantasy with "magic" of Santa and Charlie appearing and disappearing with a twinkle on the screen. There was none of that in the 1947 film, but it had a much more complex story.

This film does have some overacting, especially with Barry Flatman as Braxton Bennett and Krista Bridges as Dina Smiger, his attorney. But, one gives their roles an edge because they seem obviously to further their images as the villains in the story. I was glad that Bridges toned it down after the first scene, so that she didn't come off looking like a dope. It was okay for Bennett to have that honor, but then the end had a little surprise there that's actually quite good

Others have noted the performance of George Buza as Kris Kringle. I think he played it just right - not too overboard, yet somewhat boisterous but not discombobulated. His is one of the very best Santas I can recall ever seeing in the movies - right after Edmund Gwenn in the 1947 classic.

So many of the Christmas romance films are made for older teens through adults as grandparents. Tots, toddlers, and the younger kids fall asleep on those or quickly lose interest But this is a nice Christmas film that should hold everyone's interest over the holidays - even one to watch along with the standards, over succeeding years.