Now that Dio and Layla are a thing, Frankie feels like everyone at school is looking at her with pity, so she uses Pretty's new found popularity to prove she's moved on.
Working on an assignment with Erlic at the mansion, Frankie meets Theodore for the first time. Remy, Scary, Pretty and Nyx investigate a mysterious photo they found.
Remy and Carson get lost in the tunnels. Frankie and friends have to rescue them. Things get complicated when Frankie is late to meet Erlic for their date, and Nyx must stall him.
Frankie enlists Maw-Maw and Mrs. Ripp to help make the family gumbo recipe. Meanwhile, Remy and Carson investigate the mysterious "Hat Guy" they've seen in school and around town.
Frankie's parents throw her a "Welcome Back Party." Frankie uses the party as an opportunity to show people she's the same old Frankie and finally patch things up with Layla.
Under pressure to get the talisman back on Erlic, Frankie invites Erlic and Theodore over for game night. Pretty and Scary testify at the Underworld Council about Grim's mishap.
With Pretty and Scary stuck in the Underworld, Grim sends her assistant to replace them. Frankie and Remy have to finish Grim's task at the escape room so they can get them back.