- Garth Fitzgerald IV: [to Dean & Sam] You two came busting in here like a house on fire. Guns waving, the jaw lines and the hair... it's very intimidating.
- Bess Meyers: Mom? What is going on?
- Joy Meyers: [Slaps her hard] First off, I'm not your mother.
- Garth Fitzgerald IV: You leave her alone! You hear me? You want to hurt somebody, you hurt me!
- Joy Meyers: [laughing] Oh, that is so sweet. But I am going to hurt her. And him.
- [She points to Sam. Turns back To Garth]
- Joy Meyers: But especially you, for bringing these hunters here.
- Dean Winchester: Why would Garth run from us?
- Sam Winchester: Why haven't we heard from him for the last six months? Did you test him?
- Dean Winchester: He was unconscious. No, I --
- [Looks around parking lot]
- Dean Winchester: Did he steal a car?
- Sam Winchester: [Finding a pile of clothes on the ground] Did he steal a car... naked?
- Jim Meyers: We're more spiritual than we are religious. We believe, much like the American Indians did, that nature and man are one.
- Dean Winchester: Yeah, really worked out well for them.
- Russ: The sooner you realize that all is good here, the sooner you can go.
- Dean Winchester: Don't you two have a chew toy or something to go play with?
- Sheriff Pat: The good reverend Jim and his family are all a little new-agey and hippie-dippy like, but they're clean as a whistle and pillars of our community. Why is the FBI even interested in them?
- Sam Winchester: I just go where they send me, sheriff. Truth be told, I'm more interested in, uh... Murders and "X-files"-y stuff.
- Sam Winchester: [Notices the Mark on Dean's arm] What happened to your arm?
- Dean Winchester: Oh. It's a... gift from Cain.
- Sam Winchester: Like... the wrestler?
- Dean Winchester: I wish. That would be awesome.
- Dean Winchester: So, why are a bunch of werewolves wearing silver bullets around their necks?
- Garth Fitzgerald IV: [Coughs] Sorry, Dean, but we don't use the "W" word around here. We prefer the term "lycanthrope."
- Sam Winchester: [Referring to Garth] I'm looking for a John Doe that was admitted here a few days ago. He's a, uh... skinny, Ichabod Crane-looking kind of guy.
- Garth Fitzgerald IV: So, what'd I tell you? It's all good, right?
- Dean Winchester: [Hushed aside] Everyone here's a wolf?
- Garth Fitzgerald IV: Yeah.
- Dean Winchester: Yeah, not all good.
- Garth Fitzgerald IV: Boys, this is Bess... my beloved. And, Bess, that's Dean. Now, he could start a fight in an empty house, but deep down inside, he's just a big ol' Teddy bear.
- [Dean looks annoyed and Sam chuckles]
- Garth Fitzgerald IV: And Sam here -- Sam can be a bit insecure at times,
- [Sam glares]
- Garth Fitzgerald IV: But for good reason. Bless his heart.
- Dean Winchester: Anything on Gadreel?
- Sam Winchester: Actually, uh, yeah. Turns out he, uh, he left some Grace in me before he bolted.
- Dean Winchester: You know how wrong that sounds, right?
- Sam Winchester: What is that? Adrenaline?
- Dean Winchester: Yes, sir.
- Sam Winchester: You trying to jump-start him or kill him?
- Dean Winchester: I want some answers. He walked out on Kevin. He walked out on us. So if you got a better idea...
- [Sam walks up to an unconscious Garth and slaps him hard across the face. He shoots awake]
- Garth Fitzgerald IV: Aah! Aah! Aah!
- [Spots them]
- Garth Fitzgerald IV: Dean? Sam?
- [Looks around]
- Garth Fitzgerald IV: What is this? A hospital? Wait. Am I in Heaven?
- Dean Winchester: All right, take it easy, Garth. You're in Wisconsin.
- Dean Winchester: Somebody changed the playbook, man, you know? It's like what's right is wrong and what's wrong is... more wrong, and... I just know that when... When we rode together...
- Sam Winchester: We split the crappiness.
- Dean Winchester: The girl?
- Garth Fitzgerald IV: Wh--what girl? What the---
- [DEAN pointedly grabs a bra from the table and holds it up]
- Dean Winchester: Ragnarok is not just a Bible story to these nutjobs, it's an action plan. Human extinction, total and complete werewolf domination.
- Sam Winchester: And... what? This is the ground-zero for their movement?
- Dean Winchester: Freakin' Wisconsin, man.
- Garth Fitzgerald IV: Don't do this. Not to Bess. She's your daughter
- Joy Meyers: How many times do I have to say this? "Stepdaughter"!