Very fun concept for a show. I'm a sucker for reality shows that focus on artistic crafts. What sunk this for me is having RuPaul as a judge. Even if you disagree with Robin and Craig sometimes, they clearly understand the art form and have informed, intelligent things to say about the execution. RuPaul just has favorites and least favorites based on concept or arbitrary preference. This was clearly a huge determinant of winners throughout season 3, especially the final. Drove me crazy.
And don't get me started on the silly guest judges. Here to judge your body painting is... Linda Carter, who played Wonder Woman? Shawn Johnson, Olympic gymnast? Some pop star? The only thing they ever say is "Ooh, look how cool!" Guys, I can do that! Show me people who know what they're talking about.
Thoughts on seasons:
1: Best chemistry between contestants. Friendship between Gear and Natalie was really fun.
2: Wrong season winner, obviously.
3: I guess this has turned into the RuPaul show. Also so much laughter at RuPaul saying, "How dare you disgrace the dignity of this competition!" Lol it's reality TV, take it down a notch.