"Law & Order: Special Victims Unit" Comic Perversion (TV Episode 2014) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
The Dice Man
bkoganbing20 July 2016
Jonathan Silverman who in his younger days played nice guys got a chance to stretch his acting chops with a performance on SVU as an Andrew Dice Clay type comic. Silverman's shtick includes jokes about rape and reminds me so of back in the day when ABC weatherman Tex Antoine who got fired after making a joke about how women if they're going to get raped should just relax and enjoy it. His career ended quick.

Not Silverman's though who makes a career of playing the college circuit to a bunch of drunk horny frat guys who think this is hot stuff. It's not so funny when a college student gets attacked by a couple of recent audience members after she accuses Silverman of fostering a climate of fear for women.

It's that old issue of speech versus action. Silverman gets his share of action though sometimes the partners are less than willing. In the end one of the rape activists takes some direct action of her own.

Jonathan Silverman is really good in this one.
12 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Are rape jokes normal?
yazguloner6 August 2021
Jonathan Silverman (Josh Galloway) gives a wonderful and memorable performance as the comedian.

When I watched the episode, I prayed that the rape jokes just would be scripted. But I was sure it was true. It is clear from the comments and information.

Frankly, I am from a different country, religion and culture. I said with some nationalism: These are cheap American rape jokes. Of course they did. In fact, it is a subject that should not be within any borders in any culture. But the reality is unfortunately very different: The man accused of killing a young girl in my country was released. Today, the news that his girlfriend was found dead in that man's house was in the headlines. Also; Two separate series of a novel about women's rights were filmed at different times. It was about a gang-raped woman marrying her rapist.

However, the media started a tabloid poll instead of talking about women's rights in these two dramas: "Which actress in these two movies gets raped better!" Unfortunately, my country is not innocent in this regard.

These came to mind when I was listening to comedian Josh Galloway (Jonathan Silverman) jokes. In the show that Svu watches, Olivia's hard gaze, her look at the comedian is the right one. Because comedy makes rape seem like a normal occurrence. It normalizes rape.

However, let's take a closer look at this story in Svu, which reflects inconsistent and contradictory situations so well. While Olivia goes crazy at the jokes, behind her are men and women who applaud wildly. The most dangerous problem here is that the crowd applauds him rather than making those ugly jokes. Let's say you banned the comedian, what about those crowds? Will there not be many ugliness like him in them?

In short, it is not enough to kill flies. It is necessary to dry the swamp. Svu now tries to get to the root of the problems. He tries to ask new questions in this regard.

The writing of the story could have been better. It was predictable. It shouldn't have been like a public warning about the harms of the subject.

I wholeheartedly support Olivia's worldview and Mariska's efforts in this regard. I would also like to say that sometimes I find Mariska's attitude to impose on what it should be.

But I find her right. Because existential issues (human and women's rights, democracy, justice) are not politics. Propaganda is not. Fundamental entitlement. The opposite is the same as supporting rape jokes.

It is also the result of a corrupt mentality that people make jokes about rape and find existential discourses political. But we have a shortcoming in this regard that we cannot tell people.

However, arresting, banning or silencing is not a solution either. These are temporary solutions. Permanent solutions are required.

We can solve this mentality with awareness and education.

I have a solution. It could also be herpes.

In my opinion, a condition should be presented to those who will make jokes about women and rape and publish articles. Someone else should perform or broadcast the same joke about someone they care about, such as their mother or sister. If he approves, let him be. A mixture of soft sharia and tough democracy is a condition.

Because there is a lack of code and a disorder in the minds. This is what we call contradiction. Unfortunately, this situation in the world is official and common in civilian, individual and society. Like those who believe the earth is flat.

I will explain with an example for better understanding. In the story, Olivia tells the girl who wants to be baid herself to the comedian, give up her idea. (Should have) Let's also assume Stabler is still not gone and they are still partners. Stabler took the girl's offer positively, encouraging her to do it. However, if his own daughter wanted to be bait, he'd be all hell. And he vehemently refused. The contradiction is here. Any woman can act like this. Anyone else... We are different for the outside, we are different for the inside (our home). Sometimes we don't even realize the difference at all. Because we accept it as normal. We normalized it.

Olivia is still under the influence of ptsd. However, if I had a boyfriend who liked that comedian's rape jokes, I'd cold his too.
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Cartoonishly awful, predictable and just a train wreck.....
tetrahex14 May 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Just a terrible episode. *this review contains spoilers*

From the start you can see every last thing that is going to happen, its one of the most predictable episodes around. The second you hear "rape jokes" and there's a comedian, you think, oh no, they can't allow that, he's going to be a rapist, and guess what, he is. I held a tiny bit of hope they were going to do something unpredictable, maybe do something insightful, something daring, but the more I watched the more I saw the writing on the wall, this is basically a feminists fantasy of what a rape joke comic is. He's not funny, the rape jokes are not just bad, they are awful. Rape jokes can be funny, ask yourself, how many times have you heard a late night TV host or comic make a crack about Michael Jackson? Most of those jokes were effectively about both rape, child rape, sodomy, and pedophilia if you really think about it, yet people laugh, and do the people laughing and the comics telling the joke condone pedophilia? Are they all secret pedophiles? Of course not. But for a humorless feminist, they really don't think that far. So basically this was nothing more than an episode of total cliché, what would a cartoonish feminist write for such an episode, and the resulting episode was just...cartoonish. Put up your straw man to break it down, good job.

The comic was of course Not funny. A sexual pervert A rapist. Yes good job making a straw man argument against rape jokes there....it wasn't so much entertainment or drama, it was just bad propaganda.

George Carlin had a fantastic bit on rape jokes https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gQA6UStpOyQ
16 out of 50 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
In today's hard hitting episode
xhidden9916 December 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Every man who ever thought of sex is charged with gang rape by Barba. Olivia Benson shoots and kills a man who rolls his eyes at her. She is made mayor of earth.
6 out of 45 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Rape is no joke
TheLittleSongbird3 August 2022
This episode did nothing for me on first watch, with it being one of the few 'Law and Order: Special Victims Unit' episodes to leave a bad taste in my mouth from the over the top disataste that comes from the character writing and dialogue for Galloway. 'Special Victims Unit' have done a lot of brilliant episodes, especially Seasons 1-10, and Season 15 had high points too, so this is not coming from someone who habitually hates on every episode.

Just somebody who has become increasingly frustrated at the increasing inconsistency in the show's quality. There are not a lot of episodes of the show to do nothing for me on first watch and manages to not only do anything for me on rewatches but fared worse. This is one of them, a strong contender for the worst episode of Season 15 and not since Season 7's "Alien" (except this was possibly worse) has anything related to 'Special Victims Unit' left a big taste in the mouth.

By all means, it's not irredeemable. There are two good performances. The best one, and the best thing about the episode despite despising the character, being Jonathan Silverman, chillingly relishing his truly reprehensible character. Raul Esparza brings a lot of energy and spark to Barba, who lightens up every part of his screen time. Was frustrated by his character writing in a couple of episodes this season ("Psycho/Therapist") but not here.

One of the best scenes is the scene between him and Olivia, loved his telling it like it is. The production values are well done, subtly stylish and intimate without being claustrophobic. The music isn't too melodramatic.

However, the writing and story are a mess. Everything about the story is obvious from the get go and the episode could easily have been over in half the time. It is also very slight which affected the pacing later on which suffered from over stretching. Next to none of the characters are sympathetic or worth investing in, even the victims. Only Barba comes off unscathed. Didn't like the over zealousness and self righteousness of the svu and with the basic mistakes she makes part of me was conflicted as to whether Olivia deserved her promotion after all.

Writing is trite pretty much throughout and cringe-worthy at worst, shining only with Barba. Particularly absolutely detested the rape jokes, not only are they not remotely amusing they are also incredibly distasteful in a gratuitous way even for jokes meant to not be for the faint hearted. A major turn off from the get go was the beginning, which really made me cringe and angered. Galloway was written in an over obvious cartoonish way, very few prime suspects or perpetrators before or since were written in a way where their guilt is never once going to be in doubt. Not to mention the abrupt ending.

In summary, did next to nothing for me on either of my watches. Just to say that all the episodes over-time were re-watched, even the ones that on first watch came over as bad to see whether what opinions stood up or changed. 4/10.
14 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Worst Episode
whitneylb-730305 April 2023
It was cringe at best. The episode was embarrassing. The performance by Jonathon Silverman was over the top and uncomfortable. The jury laughing and applauding was unrealistic and the judge, pure awkward performance. 🤦‍♀️ it was pure cringe.

SVU has been an amazing show. I have watched it from the start to now just recently and sadly I am losing interest. This episode, however, was the worst by far. The fact that I googled VERBATIM "season 15, episode 15, worst episode of SVU" And there are multiple comments on how awful it was, says it all. Sorry, I disagree that Jonathon Silverman's performance was good. The villainous actors have often stolen thos show, not this time. Epic fail.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed