"Once Upon a Time" A Tale of Two Sisters (TV Episode 2014) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
I'm Ready for Storybrooke to Get Frozen Over!
NineTenElevenTwelve29 September 2014
After the simply fantastic Season 3 finale, I had high hopes for Season 4; and I'm pleased to say that this premiere episode did not disappoint!

The characters from "Frozen" have indeed come to "Once Upon a Time" and they were cast perfectly! It's scary just how well Georgina Haig, Elizabeth Lail, and Scott Michael Foster faithfully portray the characters of Elsa, Anna, and Kristoff respectively.

But, fear not, the characters from "Frozen" may have indeed been brought into the "Once Upon a Time" mythos but they don't overshadow the other story lines and characters. Emma continues to struggle with the consequences of her actions in the Season 3 finale, Regina has a very interesting story arc set up for her, Rumple and Belle get some very heartwarming scenes, and the rest of the characters all get their own moments to shine (whether they be small or large).

Overall, this episode was fantastic and a great start for Season 4! I can't wait to see what happens next!
11 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Assumingly for a ratings boost, the main cast of Frozen has come to Once Upon a Time.
Amari-Sali29 September 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Let it be known I am seemingly in the minority who didn't find Frozen to be that good of a movie. Be it because I grew up knowing the classic Disney movies, or else the movie just doesn't hold a candle to the anime I watch, either way I did not at all understand the hype. However, it is hard to deny it has become the type of phenomenon that Disney used to routinely produce so, naturally, they are going to try to exploit the Frozen franchise for every dollar they can get. Which, sadly, includes putting it on this show.

Topic 1: Merlin's Hat? – Rumple & Belle

In the episode we watch as our former villains deal with an internal conflict which makes them want to seek revenge, and yet there remains a desire to not go back to who they used to be. For Rumple, a part of him wants so dearly to get revenge for Neal/ Baelfire's death, but then that would make his sacrifice in vain so he puts his feelings aside. Leading to his focus mostly being on Belle and their honeymoon in a house that has appeared in Storybrooke. One in which they sort of reenact the ballroom scene from Beauty & The Beast. However, rather than leave those two in marital bliss, we are reminded that Rumple still has his dagger, and with the discovery of what looks like Merlin's hat, it seems he may be thinking about dabbling into magic and, like Regina, he may look into changing the past for a better present.

Topic 2: The Search for Anna – Elsa (Georgina Haig)

From what it seems, the characters of Frozen are coming to Storybrooke and the time period we meet them is right after where the movie ends. Anna is planning for her wedding and in the process of Elsa finding their mother's dress, and waiting for Anna to put it on, she finds their mother's diary. A diary in which it seems their parents left out of fear of what Elsa was. However, due to Elsa seemingly not knowing how to fully read whatever written language they use in Frozen, we likely are given half the story in which Elsa thinks they left solely because they fear her, and not because they were looking for someone who could cure her, or help her control her powers, like Rumplestiltskin for example.

For with their parents heading off to The Enchanted Forest, known in their world as Mystic Haven, this pretty much comes off as the most likely reason for their travels. But with neither Elsa, Anna, nor the trolls knowing if that is fact, Anna decides to impetuously go on her own and find out the day before her wedding. Unfortunately though, a storm comes and we are left unsure if Anna was on her way back, or on her way to The Enchanted Forest, but with Elsa discovering in Mr. Gold's shop Anna's snow pendant, after causing some chaos with her snow monster, it seems Anna made it to The Enchanted Forest, but didn't make it back to Elsa.

Topic 3: Rewriting History – Regina

Leaving us with Regina. When the last season ended, Maid Marian returned, thanks to Emma, and it put a dagger in Regina's happiness. Something throughout the episode everyone fears will turn her evil again. Thing is, she doesn't necessarily want to become the town's most hated person again. If anything, she just wants the happiness which again and again has been stolen from her. So, in order to correct the cycle, she gets Sydney out of prison and asks for his help.

Now, the original idea was to have her former evil persona, back in The Enchanted Forest, kill Maid Marian so that technically the modern Regina wouldn't have a hand in it. However, as Elsa's snow monster nearly kills Maid Marian, despite no one seeing Regina there but Maid Marian, she decides to save her. An odd decision for, once again, only Maid Marian would have known for the snow monster knocked out Emma, Hook, Robin Hood, and David.

So, with Regina deciding killing the woman perhaps isn't an option she can do, or live with, she decides to focus on the heart of the issue: The book which binds every character's fate. In said book, villains, like Regina, are never allowed happiness. Well, Rumple maybe, but not Regina. So, rather than keep killing people, finding temporary happiness, and then having it taken away from her, she wants to find the writer and have that person change the story. An odd idea if just because, in theory, wouldn't that mean she has to meet their version of god? Still, with her sick and tired of losing her happy ending, it seems she can't just deal with mere mortals anymore, but go up the chain of command.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Time for some icy heart melting
TheLittleSongbird3 May 2018
When 'Once Upon a Time' first started it was highly addictive and made the most of a truly great and creative premise. Really loved the idea of turning familiar fairy tales on their heads and putting own interpretations on them and the show early on clearly had clearly had a ball. Watched it without fail every time it came on and it was often a highlight of the week. Which was why it was sad when it ran out of ideas and lost its magic in the later seasons.

After a very solid Season 3, generally one of the best 'Once Upon a Time' seasons and the best one of the three seasons up to this point where the weakest episodes were still decent, Season 4 had a lot to live up to. With the season opener "A Tale of Two Sisters", first impressions proved to be extremely promising, showing at this very early stage that with the right execution it could be just as solid.

"A Tale of Two Sisters" is a great start to Season 4. It is the episode to introduce the story between Elsa and Anna, the two main characters in Disney's 'Frozen' (personally love the film and consider it one of Disney's best recent films, while not being completely obsessed with it, despite it being one of the most hated films on the internet these days even though it's also extremely popular). Although some of the acting could do with some polish, particularly from the Kristoff, it's already proving to be a relatable story and the two characters are remarkably true to personality. Despite how this sounds and people's concerns, this felt much more than 'Once Upon a Time' capitalising on 'Frozen's' success. Something that the episode has sometimes been criticised for.

Despite really liking the story and the promising new direction (something that remarkably is although focused on sizeably doesn't take over too much), personally actually found the stories for Regina and Rumplestiltskin more interesting, the two characters getting some significant development and major strides forward. Particularly Regina in one of her most nuanced storylines to date, the character is similarly written in a nuanced manner, being written with humanity and realism to balance out her evil in a way that makes one understand once more how she came to be that way.

Really loved too Rumplestiltskin's, another one of the show's most consistently interesting characters, story, with his chemistry with Belle being both heartfelt and heart-warming. These two stories show early indication of shaking off one's fears of the season being too 'Frozen' oriented.

Can't fault any of the acting, there is a lot of meat for everyone to sink their teeth into which all do with aplomb. Lana Parrilla is the highlight, very powerful performance, and Robert Carlyle is not far behind.

Furthermore, "A Tale of Two Sisters" is a very handsomely mounted episode visually, the settings and costumes are both colourful and atmospheric, not too dark or garish and never cookie-cutter. It is photographed beautifully too. The music is haunting, ethereal and cleverly used with a memorable main theme.

Writing has the right balance of humour, pathos, mystery and intrigue.

Overall, great Season 4 opener. 9/10 Bethany Cox
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Do you wanna build a snowman?
sini-2001 April 2023
I was really hyped where season threee of Once Upon a Time left us, and this season four first episode did not disappoint.! I really love how they got Frozen to this season and the premise is good . The flashback of Arendelle is nice touch of what happens next after the events of the movie. Elsa's actress is really doing good job too, and love the details they have put to the show yet making it different. Kristoff is a bit different looking than I expected.

But I love Emma's side eyes at the sight of the snow monster lol. Her reaction of another crisis happening is like 'oh, not another monster again' 😂😂
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Absolutely Lackluster, and an utter disappointment from the Frozen "cast"
lemangum802 October 2014
Warning: Spoilers
I just cannot get over the poor acting of the new characters, the weak story line, and just the general sporadic-ness of this episode. The casting, in my opinion, was done without much thought to keeping the characters true to their personalities in the movie. I kept waiting for it to get better. I kept waiting for the actors to show emotion. The only parts that were actually good were the scenes not involving any characters from Frozen (the original show cast was amazing, as usual, which is why I am giving this episode a 4 instead of a 1).

I wanted to give an honest opinion so people could read a review WITHOUT spoilers, so they don't waste their time if they choose not to invest 45 minutes on....well....not much of anything.

A HUGE disappointment. I cannot imagine I'm the only one who thinks so.
8 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed