"The Expanse" CQB (TV Episode 2015) Poster

(TV Series)

(2015)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Great pacing leading to an excellent cliffhanger
tad-3223 December 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Forty three minutes of excellent science fiction. This episode is one long battle between the Martian space navy flagship Donnager and an armada of six unknown ships (with a few scenes where we cut away to the asteroid belt and Earth, but I'm going to focus on the battle here).

The battle begins with Martian arrogance that they have everything under control. As the episode and the battle progresses, that arrogance erodes as it increasingly becomes obvious that the Donnager is outmatched. She manages to destroy 4 of the 6 enemy ships, but by that point she's crippled. The remaining 2 ships start a boarding action against the now-toothless flagship. During the boarding action, we find out that these are Humans aboard these strange ships, but not much more than that.

After ensuring that the remaining survivors of the Canterbury are safely away in the Donnager's armed shuttle Hitachi, the crippled flagship self-destructs. It's unclear if the explosion takes out the remaining enemy ships.

During all this, Martian officer Lopez reveals that they were dispatched to investigate a loss of communications with their base on Saturn's moon Phoebe. The Donnager found the base destroyed, everyone was dead, apparently an accident until they found that the computers on the base had been purposely smashed. The Donnager was on its way back to Mars when it picked up the distress call from the Canterbury survivors.

There's also some potentially dark foreshadowing with respect to the mention of asteroid impacts and the extinction of the dinosaurs. There's also the suggestion that a faction of belters might be responsible for the strange enemy ships.

We are faced with many questions: How will Mars respond to losing its flagship? Might they blame Earth? Earth has deployed the Orinoco to the area. Will they find the Donnager's shuttle? Will they be ambushed like their Martian counterpart? Why was Martian base on Saturn's moon Phoebe destroyed?
37 out of 38 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Good character development
haydnlawrence-1864924 January 2016
Warning: Spoilers
This was a very good episode. While there are many aspects to the different unfolding story lines, I'll focus on the space battle. The biggest part of this was the character development of the Martians. It gave us a new/updated insight into their culture and who they are.

SPOILERS NOW

I actually felt bad for the Martians when the ship exploded. The Martians had been somewhat set up as the enemy in the previous three episodes, so it says a lot when they can make you like the so-called "enemy" after just one episode. I especially loved the Captain, her arrogance/strength, and her final words.

Overall, this episode is what truly made me realized I will absolutely give this series and entire season of watching before I make a judgement.

The only thing I can criticize is the fact that not a single Martian officer/soldier survived while practically all the main characters did...
22 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Excellent eruption of galactic bloodbath
quincytheodore2 January 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Usually, war scene involves a lot of fireworks carnage without too much focus on the structural flow. The Expanse has both qualities in tandem, it gives a majestic view on warfare and still manages to keep an approachable narrative even though it's teeming with sci-fi jingoisms. This is an intricate story presentation as well as an impactful visual spectacle.

The battle of Donnager happens for almost half the episode, and it's not just random blasts of laser and cannon. By using manageable pacing, it gives a solid perspective on the main characters' predicaments. There lies significant amount of special effects as well, offering much higher level of action scene than other sci-fi have done. Describing this episode as worthy of cinema screen would not be an understatement.

It pans back and forth between various scales of the war. The most notable gimmick is the inclusion of gravity differential which hastens or slows down the action, and serves as on-screen slow motion effect. This trial also gives more character development to the Martians who indeed are more humane than any impression their chauvinistic visages might produce from earlier episode.

A few other subplots happen in between the fire and explosion which slightly push the mystery angle further. However, the center stage is the immense skirmish and it's an impressive production value audience can simply sit back and marvel at.
21 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A good and action packed episode
8512223 May 2017
Greetings from Lithuania.

4th episode of "The Expanse" was the most action packed episode yet. It was also superbly paced - all story lines were interesting and were involvingly done. Special effects were really good and action scenes were high quality.

After seeing first 4 episode i can say that i really like about this show it is deep story - this is a pure sci-fi and i love it - and there are no aliens (finally).

Overall, i will definitely watch next episodes as i enjoyed first 4, with the 4th one being probably most intense yet. Good sci-fi series so far, not a masterpiece, but pure sci-fi.
19 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Very Exciting
Hitchcoc12 January 2020
I'm becoming more acclimated to this series and have a grasp on the bad guys, the good guys, and those thought to be bad guys are. This episode takes place primarily on board the Martian ship. Once again, like the unsinkable Titanic, and overblown egotism transpires. The last remnants of the Cant's crew are doing what they can to survive, in a sort of brig. This episode has a great balance of pure action and cerebral characterization. Something else has been added to the mix which makes going forward quite exciting. I haven't been engaged in something like this for some time.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Just a piece of useless trivia
nemesis-8828 February 2022
When Miller gets the "extractor" at the morgue, the white box with green lock he opens is the Festool Systainer, a tool box made by German Manufacturer Festool. Those boxes are used all throughout the show - particularly, in the "green epidemic" on Ilus, and in a few other scenes.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
"Big guns"
narcis-4883816 April 2021
Railguns are not much of a weapons, if don't believe me, just ask Capt. Theresa Yao of the MCRN Donnager...
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed