When Abbie Mills and Ichabod Crane save Katrina Crane from Horseman of Death and his binding ritual, Ichabod cuts the Horseman's axe in half with the Sword of Methuselah and manages to corner the Horseman. Still after Abbie frees Katrina from the bindings and they join Ichabod who is holding the sword on the Horseman, his axe can be seen on the ground in one piece even if it was cut in half earlier.