I Remember You (2017) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
36 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
don't renovate an isolated Icelandic cabin in the off-season
gpflinn22 August 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Iceland in winter looks bleak, stunning, and mysterious. enjoyed this one. great atmosphere.

Got a bit annoyed with the ending for how smart the psychologist is and with all these ghostly pointed visions he has -- how on earth does he just ignore the wet seashells, footsteps downstairs, and open cellar door at the end? absolutely shocking. and to not even mention it to home girl detective who has linked pretty much everything??? he could have cleaned up 2 cold cases for her in 10 seconds. Cannot blame him tho...if I found my young child ended up stuck in a used septic tank on a remote island I would be just as bitter
12 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Real Decent Thriller
LordCommandar3 March 2018
This was a real decent thriller. I watched two subtitle films today Julia's Eyes (was ok) and this one, which came together at the end really well. A good solid ghost story, that has right build to give the audience a reason to watch to the end. If you like subtitles films, and the language of Iceland, then I highly recommend this ghost story. You will not be disappointed .
18 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Starts so well but...
vg406 March 2018
You may watch it once with low hopes. Starts really well but loses steam along the way. The plot is unique and yet not convincing enough. It is definitely worth a watch.
19 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Excellent supernatural thriller
fsorganizing26 May 2018
The plot/story is based on Yrsa Sigurðardóttir's mystery novel, and so it has aspects of a good mystery and a ghost story. The screenwriters and the actors did a great job, and I didn't mind having to read the subtitles. Although, I did have to pay close attention throughout the whole film in order to understand the plot, which contains layers of complexity. In the end, it paid off because there are some very eerie, creepy scenes.

If you require a lot of blood and gore, then this may not be your kind of film. But if you enjoy good ghost stories with past history tied to the plot, then I definitely recommend it. "Chilly" might be a good word to describe the atmosphere of the film, not only because of the supernatural material but also because the Icelandic countryside looks quite chilly and remote.

Again, kudos go to all of the people who helped to make this film. I look forward to seeing future work from the director, Óskar Thór Axelsson.
10 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Engaging supernatural thriller
paulclaassen9 September 2018
Warning: Spoilers
The cast delivers very realistic acting, making this supernatural film very believable. This was creepy and mysterious, and remained interesting throughout, with a very good blend of reality and the supernatural. The film is essentially about a father who's son went missing. The father believes the son to be dead, but that doesn't stop him from hoping otherwise so he can find closure. The son's spirit, on the other hand, also can't rest until he is found.

Spoiler: Only once the film reaches the interesting twist do you realize the film played in different timelines. This is actually a very sad film. Very well done!
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
ghosts from the past
cdcrb15 November 2017
Warning: Spoilers
icelandic films arriving in the u.s. are usually pretty good. this is no exception. a ghost story and a mystery wrapped into one. a coroner tries to find out about the crosses cut into the body of a woman who has hanged herself. he is personally dealing with the disappearance of his son. a national story at the time. separately a trio of people are left on a remote island, where they are intending to turn an abandoned building into a b and b. there does not appear to be any connection between the two stories. there are clues to the puzzle, but you won't know about them until it's too late. stick with it. you won't be disappointed.
13 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Promising But ultimately disappointing
ebeckstr-12 June 2019
This movie has a lot going for it. It has some truly creepy moments, very solid acting on everyone's part, moments of good scoring (despite some cliched choral passages), and a promising story line.

Unfortunately, for reasons I cannot understand, about two-thirds of the way through the script introduces a cliched, hackneyed domestic melodrama plot line which, while it does thematically connect with other aspects of the story, could have been dispensed with in favor of something less predictable and inane. I'm avoiding going into detail because I don't want to drop spoilers in case you decide to watch this movie. I myself have little patience for scripts that are inconsistent and which suffer under choices which the writer should have known were bad ones. The conclusion, while apropos of the story that precedes it, is also something we have seen time and time again in similar movies. It's frustrating to see what could have been and memorable movie become ultimately rather forgettable.

If you're hard up for a ghost story flick and you've seen everything else out there, I Remember You is probably worth a look, but it's not one that's going to be on my own re-watch list; which, for the sake of context, does include the likes of Ringu, The Ring, The Grudge (Japanese), Dark Water (Japanese), The Fog (original), The Haunting (original), The Innocents, Pulse and Retribution (both Kioshi Kurosawa), and the number of others that I watch repeatedly because they avoid most of the mistakes made by I Remember You.
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
No, thanks
Phil_Chester19 August 2019
It has beautiful scenery in locations seldom seen on film, but the story is too loose to develop any real tension. There's one effective jump scare, but that's it. And the confusing parallel timeline structure doesn't add anything to the drama. Best avoided.
14 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Forgettable
frukuk25 March 2019
I enjoyed the relaxed pace of the first half, but felt the second half just didn't deliver anything of any significance. All in all, a rather weak ghost story, populated with characters I couldn't care about.
5 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
SPOILER ALERT/ UNTIED
rafaelabme8 May 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Nordic noir is by far my favourite genre, so it happens to be the one i watch the most. And although i have like this movie, i only gave it 6 stars because for me the ending left me hanging (baduntSs). Good acting, good suspense, amazing location, and i really liked the time difference thing. However, How did Benni get into that green thing? was he kidnapped by someone? was he kidnapped by one of the love trio at the gas station? If kidnapping was not the case, was that the hardest game of hide and seek ever played? so what, Benni hid inside the boat when the trio was going to the island and then he hid himself inside that green thing just playing hide and seek? Because if so, the story gets weaker.
14 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
my notes
FeastMode25 July 2019
Warning: Spoilers
There aren't specific reasons i hated this movie. there wasn't a bunch of dumb stuff i could make fun of. i just couldn't get into it, AT ALL. i struggled to get through it. the only reason i finished it is because i wanted to see how the mystery unfolded. i found it almost completely useless (1 viewing)

SPOILERS

the one thing that got me to give this a 2 star rating instead of 1 star is the twist at the end. the two stories being told are not happening at the same time. the story with the dude and two girls took place when the doctor's son first went missing. it did give me goosebumps when they revealed it. it still didn't make the rest of the movie much better. in fact, the story with the 3 in the cabin becomes basically pointless. the doctor's storyline is about finding out what happened to his son. the 3 in the cabin are basically just a random story that has no impact on the story other than to be the reveal for the doctor's story. the 3 in the cabin didn't even give us any really ending. that story on it's own is useless. husband, wife, wife's best friend go to a cabin to get it ready to become a BnB. scary stuff starts happening because the dead kid is in the septic tank (they are unaware). wife finds out husband and best friend sexed and are having a baby. scary stuff kills husband and friend. wife stays with the haunted kid, maybe also dead... that story on it's own is terrible. the cheating drama and baby issues had no use in this movie at all
7 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A solid scare with no cheap shots or plot holes
horrorismyhome10 December 2017
The synopsis here on IMDb is not quite accurate. There are actually 2 stories happening here, and how they connect is revealed slowly, with perfect timing and a suspenseful buildup.

The first story concerns the town doctor, who is helping the police with an investigation of a woman who has died. His character spend the entire film teetering between trying to figure out this town's dark past and how it connects to some recent and frightening events, and trying to live with the torment of the loss of his son, who went missing some years earlier.

The other story is about a married couple (and her best friend) who are in town to convert an old, disused building into a bed & breakfast. There are some personal issues between the three, but the most interesting character by far is the wife. She's also experienced some trauma in her past, and it is she who suffers the strange events that happen in this story. None of what happens to her is ever seen by her husband or her friend, so we don't really know if it's real or imagined.

The town's current crimes, the renovation of the b&b, how the two narratives cross paths is revealed slowly, with suspense and satisfying scares, and is done exceedingly well.

The actors' performances were well done; not a stinker among them. And the landscape is perfect for such a tale. Desolate, cold, isolated...not just in miles, but in connection with the outside world (for example, difficulty in getting a cell phone signal). There are no cheap shots, no stunt scares. A beautiful soundtrack and gorgeous cinematography are icing on the cake of this thriller.
71 out of 87 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Supernaturah Horror Icelandic Style
redrobin62-321-20731118 August 2018
I liked this film. It was dark, moody, atmospheric and with a few effective jump scares. Unlike many films of this genre, this one was practically bloodless. The movie was well photographed, too, capturing the bleak and unforgiving landscape that is the northern frontier.

My issue, and why I didn't rate it higher? You've seen everything in this film before. I couldn't help but notice there was cliche after cliche in this offering. Hell, this movie could've shot in rural New York, Washington, London and there wouldn't be any stylistic difference. I fear that I'll forget about this flick two days from now, and that's a bad thing. They tried, though. There is that.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Confusion
takato052410 October 2021
Warning: Spoilers
I would've given a higher rating if I understood the end. The ending with the couple and friend is what I'm referring to. Did she die? She looked kinda dead in the final shot with the doctor's son, who was obviously dead. It also didn't help that I didn't realize the two stories weren't happening at the same time. Thank goodness this was on Hulu in original language with subtitles. Those dubs Netflix has are terrible and would've ruined the story.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Not bad but a bit slow
deloudelouvain16 April 2018
I wouldn't say I Remember You is a bad movie, not at all actually, but it's probably not a movie I will watch a second time though, and that's why I just gave it a 6 out of 10. From a 7 are the movies I would watch again. The story is not bad, with enough mystery to keep you interested, but it is just a bit too slow and there are a couple things that could have used more explanation. The cast was good. I didn't know any of them and that's not a surprise since Icelandic movies are not the most common and popular, but that doesn't mean there are no good actors there. The setting is everything you expect when you think about Iceland, not much else to see than bare lands, mountains and lakes, and a cold winter atmosphere. It's all well shot. The movie is worth a watch, but to me it could have used a bit more action and horror.
9 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Mom and Son find each other
bohemian_033021 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
The quiet isolation of Iceland is enough to keep you looking over your shoulder for something being there. It is a great movie to watch on a day you have no plans and just want to sit back and watch two story's unfold.

This may be a spoiler. Although the ending is sad....at least a mother who gave birth to a still born son (found one in "B") and a son who lost his mother during child birth (found one in "K").

So why did Freyr close the cellar door and leave them behind.??? He found his son so he will now go on to a higher place,why look back at the house and not allow K and B to have a happy ending too going to a higher place...instead of being left behind?
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Better than Sigur Ross and Icelandic black metal.
fedor825 April 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Just like there are weeaboos, there should be a name for fans of Iceland. There is a certain small but loyal group of western hipsters who overrate everything that comes from Iceland.

My first Icelandic movie is a bit of a dud. Silver lining: they still make much better movies than Sigur Ros and their black metal buddies make music. For whatever it's worth. And there are some nice vistas.

Very drawn out ghost mystery with a plot resolution that's somewhat confusing and unsatisfying. So basically the doctor's kid disappears while playing hide-and-seek with an autistic child, and at that same time mysterious deaths start all over Iceland with all the victims having multiple crosses engraved on their bodies. Yet the authorities only start noticing a pattern after the 6th victim... Really, movie? Icelandic police is that incompetent? Yes, well, a low murder-rate in a highly civilized society will do that to a police force, make the cops dull-witted, unprepared and inefficient. Or even more dull-witted and inefficient, I mean.

Dumber still, the lost kid had a serious medical condition, yet he was allowed to play hide and bloody seek with an autistic kid without anyone watching over them. Really, Iceland? Is that common practice to let young children with medical issues run around the town unsupervised? No wonder their population never rises above 300,000.

Why did the kid's demise bring the ghost of the missing kid from 60 years earlier on a revenge spree? What had it been waiting for all that time? Another kid had to snuff it so that the ghost would finally take revenge? Fine logic.

The mystery moves at a snail's pace, and it isn't even gripping - as mysteries kinda should be. The film is a half-hour too long. It's only mildly interesting. Then comes the dumb semi-confusing "resolution" and that's it, folks! Now you can efff off to your dumb Sigur Ros CDs!

And what's with the bloody mobile phone having no signal? This isn't 2002. Gimme a break with that tired old plot-device. You can go to the center of the Amazon rain-forest these days and get a signal. The Moon? I wouldn't bet against it...
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
I will try to remember this one.
Divine_Dev4 May 2018
This could have been better but still it's a good story (not convincing enough though) with a few jump scares.
1 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Slow-burning ghost story
Leofwine_draca30 December 2021
Warning: Spoilers
A slow-burning ghost story from Iceland. Effective bleak visuals and an icy touch are the order of the day here, along with a glacial pace and half of a storyline which likens this to a murder/missing child mystery. Quite a lot of disparate plot ingredients including a dual narrative that only makes sense at the very end. I wasn't a huge fan of the twist, finding it a cheat of sorts, although it's one I'm familiar with having seen it since the old giallo days. Generally the acting is better than the character writing but there's plenty to tune in for if you like the genre.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A little chilly
begob6 September 2021
A psychiatrist follows a trail of sudden deaths while recovering from the trauma of the disappearance of his young son.

Police procedural meets the unquiet grave of a child. This is pretty much Ringu territory - at least the American remake - but without the lavish set piece scenes and searing menace. There is a disjunction in time revealed late on, which makes you rethink the story, but not by much as there's not a lot to explain. And if you've twigged the early appearance of an unusual object, the second reveal is no surprise.

The production values are fine, nothing to complain about. Flashbacks to vintage times in digital black and white are not convincing, but the volcanic eruption was spectacular.

Overall: More ghostly than horrifying, and nothing original.

Ps. The credits make a good job of thanking the entire population of Iceland by name.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The Mystery of the Crosses
EdgarST21 December 2019
As we have become accustomed to the American horror movie formula (since its main rivals, the British, Italian, Mexican and Japanese film industries have almost abandoned the genre), it becomes obvious, when we are confronted by a different horror movie, that today most of this genre productions look like long advertising spots, with commercial aesthetics and style, that promote, I don't know, ketchup, green sauces, make-ups, visual effects software, whatever but true horror.

While watching this Icelandic film, I remembered what happened to a similar movie, «I Am the Beautiful Thing That Lives in the House", a Canadian production that was misunderstood, maligned and unjustly underrated. Both works address a favorite conflict in horror motion pictures, stories and myths: that of the spirits that seek peace, after violent deaths or when their bodies have not been found. In «Pretty Thing», a nurse is haunted by the specter of a beautiful young woman who was killed by her groom. In «I Remember You», we find two children who were mistreated and mocked by their peers and suddenly were missing. These stories frequently reflect on the sense of responsibility or guilt felt by those who remain alive when someone close dies, in whose deaths they were somehow involved. Their responsibility or guilt take the form of ghosts that generally only they can see and "free" them from the attachment to this plane of existence.

Based on a novel by Yrsa Sigurdardottir (Reykjavik, 1963), an Icelandic author specializing in two genres perhaps antagonistic (crime novels and children's books ...), «I Remember You» involves complex characters and biographies full of ungrateful incidents, from the psychiatrist who has never been able to locate the body of his missing son, to the man and two women trying to open a hostel on an abandoned island, without knowing that they are in the house with a horrific past. One of the missing children is somehow connected to the strange mutilations and deaths of elders who seem to be part of a sect and, above all, with the psychiatrist's son.

The evolution of the drama is always interesting, the performances and the cinematography of Jakob Ingimundarson are all good, and there is no lack of tension and a couple of scares, but here we do not find the primary, ancestral and classic horror so dear to the British Hammer films, to the Italian horror master Mario Bava or to the Mexican studios Churubusco Azteca, but a more adult and contemporary approach to horror. «I Remember You» has enough merits to enjoy an evening of good genre cinema in its of 21st century version. See it.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Where we at?
kosmasp23 February 2018
A very moody film, that cuts back and forth between two storylines. And that makes it really interesting. Also the location of the one storyline is really setting the mood. While there are phantastical elements to it, I would argue that this is more of a thriller, rather than straight horror. But it does have quite a few "jump scares" and you might feel frighten from time to time.

If that sounds intriguing, believe me it is. It is also very well made. The acting is great, the script will keep you guessing what will come next and there are enough twists to keep you on the edge of your seat ... maybe even after the movie is over. The guessing part of it all is what makes it work the first time around. I haven't seen it a second time, but I'm sure there are things to discover and enjoy then too
28 out of 37 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Slow but Steady Chilling Mystery
FarhanRas29 March 2018
Although people may approach it seeking a horror film, and despite having some paranormal elements to it, the movie is mostly a missing persons mystery. The film weaves two "main" storylines as well as two missing persons cases deftly into a film that culminates into a single picture in the end.

The characters are not really fleshed out more than they have to, which is a good thing, and the actors do a pretty good job bringing the characters to life, especially the psychiatrist.

There weren't much jump scares or purely horror scenes, and what little "scary" scenes did show up added to the atmosphere and mystery, and made sense to the plot and eventual background "mythology" of the movie. As such, this movie should be fine for people who aren't really into horror movies, if they can handle a pinch of supernatural as a part of the mythology instead it being intended purely for horror purposes.

The movie was pretty focused on the main story, and there weren't much side stories or unnecessary relationships, violence, intimate scenes, or anything that really distracted from the story for the sake of sensational viewing. The pacing was slow but steady. To be honest, it was so slow and steady that was almost beginning to suspect that the film would have disappointing ending, due to the relatively nonfluctuating levels of emotion or suspense. However, despite the the ending indeed being technically anticlimactic, I think it was indeed satisfying, resolving the main mysteries while still leaving room for thought and reflection.

I would definitely recommend this movie for anyone who likes mystery, and don't mind a teaspoon of spook in that.
16 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A very moving film
ellen-3004820 January 2018
You know a film is good when you forget you are reading subtitles. I remember you is quite scary, very intriguing and very moving. Well acted and produced it left me wondering how everything tied in together right to the very end.
26 out of 42 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
I Remember You
Tweekums24 March 2019
This Icelandic chiller is effectively two stories in one. In the one a psychiatrist, Freyr, is brought in when a woman is found hanged in a church. It looks like an obvious case of suicide but she has numerous crosses carved in her back suggesting abuse. As the case is investigated links are found to other deaths and the disappearance of a bullied child fifty years previously... she was also taking an interest in his son who vanished three years previously. In the other story a couple, Katrin and Garðar, and a friend. Lif, head to a remote abandoned village, where they hope to convert one of the houses into a guest house; they soon start to feel that they aren't alone.

This is a solid chiller doesn't really fit into one genre. There are elements of a mystery as we are invited to wonder who caused the dead woman's scars and what happened to the two children. There is also the question of whether the people in the remote house are seeing things that are really there are just imagining it due to the somewhat creepy nature of the location... there is something intrinsically atmospheric about 'ghost towns'. The bleak majesty of the local Icelandic countryside only adds to the atmosphere. The two stories aren't categorically linked till the finale; although it is the nature of such films that people will assume a link... even so I didn't guess the major twist until it was revealed. There is little in the way of real horror, and few jump-scares, but it is still effective thanks to the way things are depicted and a minimal but skilled use of music. The cast is solid, making the characters feel like ordinary people. Overall I'd recommend this for those looking for something a little different... a good mystery with spooky elements.

These comments are based on watching the film in Icelandic with English subtitles.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed