I know Avatar: The Last Airbender is one of the most popular and loved animated shows of all time. They even tried to make a movie about it back in 2010 the is universally panned. The animated series has a 9.4 rating here and the movie only a 4.0 so people have been hungry for a good live adaptation of the animated series for a long time. It's finally here. It's almost impossible to please everyone who liked the original animated series because everyone has their own expectations on how it should be and they hate when it differs even a little from the original. They don't seem to understand how they don't have the luxury of having unlimited episodes and get go as in depth as the original, it has to be adapted into only 8 episodes per season. I had no problem at all, I liked this series so much that I binged all 8 episodes in only 2 days. I just couldn't stop watching and already looking forward to next season.
1,283 Reviews
Very good work, but it is darkened by the legacy and weight of the series name
ramzalhdad11 April 2024
I can see that a lot of people attacking this series of Avatar The Last Airbender. There are even people who criticized the series even before its release due to the disastrous series that was released in 2010. On my part as a fan of the Avatar The Legend of Aang series, I can say that I very much enjoyed this show, starting with the story that They kept it with a few minor changes, in addition to the wonderful acting of the characters. I loved the character of Aang and how he balanced being a child who wanted to play but carrying responsibility for the world at the same time. I also liked the character of Zuko, his story, his motivations, and his constant struggle to find the Avatar to restore his inheritance to rule. I also liked the change that occurred at Saka's character from what it was in the original series, from a funny character to a domineering character with a painful past and a feeling of letting his father down. The series gave each character its due and gave them enough depth that made us relate to them, in addition to the smooth progression in the story without there being an exaggerated prolongation of events with development with very distinctive and noticeable for the characters, and I also respected the preservation of the atmosphere of mystery and wisdom characteristic of the original series with perfect photography and very excellent CGI. Perhaps there are a few things that I did not like, such as Aang's weak acting in sad moments and the previous Avatars not giving any development to Aang's character. In fact, I think this series is one of the most underrated series in this year because it carries the name and legacy of a great series that created most of young people's childhoods and an audience that looks forward to an iconic work like it, and I expect the second part to be better than the first.
Lost Arc of Aang
pollereulogy22 February 2024
I understand that adapting a cartoon series scene by scene into a live adaptation is impractical. However, removing the lead character's pivotal arc, which was integral to the essence of the original story, weakens the storytelling. The Aang portrayed lacks the innocence and depth of the 12-year-old protagonist we grew to love; instead, he's presented as a young adult novel archetype warrior.
Moreover, the characters seem to lack the comedic traits that defined them, resulting in scenes that feel devoid of emotion and overly somber.
The direction feels stagnant, with characters rigidly placed and delivering exposition rather than engaging dynamically with the world around them.
Numerous unnecessary changes detract from the impactful moments, surprising reveals, and character development that made the original series so compelling.
While I appreciate the efforts put into the visuals and action sequences, they shouldn't be the sole focus of a production with such a substantial budget.
Moreover, the characters seem to lack the comedic traits that defined them, resulting in scenes that feel devoid of emotion and overly somber.
The direction feels stagnant, with characters rigidly placed and delivering exposition rather than engaging dynamically with the world around them.
Numerous unnecessary changes detract from the impactful moments, surprising reveals, and character development that made the original series so compelling.
While I appreciate the efforts put into the visuals and action sequences, they shouldn't be the sole focus of a production with such a substantial budget.
I enjoyed it
jochemunlimited6 April 2024
I saw many episodes of the first season of the cartoon, but not all. Back when there were no streaming services so I needed to watch it on television when I passed by chaning the channels. Through the years I got parts of the first story but never the last episode of season 1. So I am aware of the story.
I also saw the movie or movies, I am not sure how many there are. Het last one was not bad, it looks like this series. So I see the battle in the north again. But I must say, it was no problem. This series is very watchable. Sometimes you have amazing shots. But overall you can see the background faded and the foreground sharp and too much light, so you see it is fake. I think the really big amazing shots cost a lot of money and even that the other scens looking fake, it is still of a high quality. I think it is also combined with real shots.
I mostly like the characters, but many times I think: there is something off. Like the parents or the crazy king. Also the acting can be a bit off, like it is too static. Just like the fake backgrounds. It looks to clinical.
But overall I believe the characters. The most important characters are believable for me. It also sometimes has the same sillynes as the original. The pace is also good, but I think sometimes it is going too fast. I think they take some shortcuts, but overall you get the main story. I enjoyed watching this. I am starting watching the original again, but then from season 2.
So I think there should be a season 2. I do not know if I like it after I just saw the original. But I saw many horrible adapation of books, games and animation. This is a very good take. It can be a bit better, bit more clever maybe. But this is solid.
I also saw the movie or movies, I am not sure how many there are. Het last one was not bad, it looks like this series. So I see the battle in the north again. But I must say, it was no problem. This series is very watchable. Sometimes you have amazing shots. But overall you can see the background faded and the foreground sharp and too much light, so you see it is fake. I think the really big amazing shots cost a lot of money and even that the other scens looking fake, it is still of a high quality. I think it is also combined with real shots.
I mostly like the characters, but many times I think: there is something off. Like the parents or the crazy king. Also the acting can be a bit off, like it is too static. Just like the fake backgrounds. It looks to clinical.
But overall I believe the characters. The most important characters are believable for me. It also sometimes has the same sillynes as the original. The pace is also good, but I think sometimes it is going too fast. I think they take some shortcuts, but overall you get the main story. I enjoyed watching this. I am starting watching the original again, but then from season 2.
So I think there should be a season 2. I do not know if I like it after I just saw the original. But I saw many horrible adapation of books, games and animation. This is a very good take. It can be a bit better, bit more clever maybe. But this is solid.
Never saw the animated series so I had no expectations
Supermanfan-131 April 2024
Avatar: The Last Airbender is based off the animated series of the same name. It takes place in a world that is divided into 4 different nations, each nation is made up of an element (Fire, Water, Air and Earth). The Avatar is the only one who can master all 4 elements and the one who brings balance between all the nations until one day the Fire Nation decides to invade. The Avatar is the only one who can stop them but he suddenly disappears. A hundred years later a new Avatar named, Aang, emerges. With some help from friends he must master the elements to bring peace and balance back to the world. I have to admit that I've never seen the animated series or movie so I went into this with no expectations or prior knowledge of the series. I've read good things and the trailer looked good so I gave it a shot. I'm glad I did because I really enjoyed it. I thought it was going to be more aimed to younger audiences but it's enjoyable for everyone.
No, it's not that good and don't even compare it to the Netflix One Piece
MissSimonetta27 February 2024
I'm too exhausted with these pointless live action remakes of animated classics to get angry anymore. This Netflix redo of AVATAR: THE LAST AIRBENDER is at best competent, with handsome production design and costuming. Storywise, it strips out the humor of the original, leaving us with grim imitations of the characters we so loved. The sadsack reimagining of the feisty Katara is particularly horrid.
The acting is spotty. Some of the performers are pretty good, but so many of the line readings come off like community theater. Where's the passion?
While not the fiasco the previous live action feature was, this new AVATAR is just pointless. Yeah it's not bad, but why settle for not bad when the original show was great? I'd rather just rewatch the old one for the hundredth time.
The acting is spotty. Some of the performers are pretty good, but so many of the line readings come off like community theater. Where's the passion?
While not the fiasco the previous live action feature was, this new AVATAR is just pointless. Yeah it's not bad, but why settle for not bad when the original show was great? I'd rather just rewatch the old one for the hundredth time.
This Series Is All Bark And No Bite
ajwallacereviews3 April 2024
Warning: Spoilers
The live-action Avatar: The Last Airbender is all bark and no bite. Now what could I possibly mean by that? Well keep reading and I will break it down. Avatar: The Last Airbender was one of my most anticipated series set to drop in 2024. So in turn I had big expectations coming into this show. I knew it was going to be fire before I even saw the trailer and all we had were the first set of still images. Once I saw the trailer I was blown away. In comparison to the original cartoon, it passes the eye test. But that still doesn't explain why this series has no bite.
Well, to do that we have to understand what the bark is first. If you haven't guessed by now the bark is how good this show looks on screen. This series is striking. From the colors to the CGI and visual effects to the way they use light in different scenarios. If I'm being honest though the visuals were never really in question. Just because of the amount of technology available nowadays. So I was super confident that they would get it right this time. That's right I said "this time" because their first attempt at a live-action Avatar back in 2010 was a disaster.
This leads me to explain what the actual bite is. The "bite" is the thing everyone loves most about any series or movie and that's the story. Yeah, seeing all the different bending styles is cool. But what makes the series legendary is the story. Avatar: The Last Airbender is one of the most visually appealing series to drop this year hands down. Even though some of the storylines don't hit like they did in the original series it's still very good. Nostalgia aside the biggest element separating good and bad live-action adaptations is story.
Now, I have found a new appreciation for live-action adaptations. In part due to what Netflix is doing with legacy series like Avatar or One Piece. For one expectations are so high nowadays because of what Marvel has been able to do with the mcu in the past. But it's different jumping from 2D animation to live-action because the gap is so wide. You go from a limitless canvas where your only limitation is your imagination. To then create those same moments in the "real world," with "real people". You know where a thing called gravity exists. Fortunately, technology for the most part isn't the biggest limiting factor anymore.
The biggest limiter in live-action series now is time. Most of these live-action adaptations are condensed to around 8 -10 episodes. They have to be super precise in the episodes they choose to cover because if not. You run the risk of creating major plot holes in the story. Combining complementary arcs in one episode is very difficult in itself. Unfortunately, this formula has its ups and downs so the pacing suffers a tad bit in the process. Nothing major but it's something to improve on for future seasons.
Now by no means does this mean I think this series is trash. I enjoyed watching every episode and something I plan on watching it again. Now I see potential in Team Avatar even though they haven't hit their groove yet. It speaks to underlying chemistry issues that can be fixed eventually. It was just not the bite I was looking for which is why I gave it an 8/10 G-Files Score. I can tell you this though I'm super excited for the next season. One thing they did do a good job of was establishing all the players and motivations. Granted some portrayals were better than others. But with more time they can all take their roles to the next level.
The only thing I wish for is to include more of the journey. Even a short montage would suffice. I want it to feel like time is passing and not fast travel everywhere. Appa didn't get any love this season and he is just as big a part of Team Avatar as anybody even Aang. Plus nobody on the squad has a bigger bite than Appa himself so show him a little more respect.
Well, to do that we have to understand what the bark is first. If you haven't guessed by now the bark is how good this show looks on screen. This series is striking. From the colors to the CGI and visual effects to the way they use light in different scenarios. If I'm being honest though the visuals were never really in question. Just because of the amount of technology available nowadays. So I was super confident that they would get it right this time. That's right I said "this time" because their first attempt at a live-action Avatar back in 2010 was a disaster.
This leads me to explain what the actual bite is. The "bite" is the thing everyone loves most about any series or movie and that's the story. Yeah, seeing all the different bending styles is cool. But what makes the series legendary is the story. Avatar: The Last Airbender is one of the most visually appealing series to drop this year hands down. Even though some of the storylines don't hit like they did in the original series it's still very good. Nostalgia aside the biggest element separating good and bad live-action adaptations is story.
Now, I have found a new appreciation for live-action adaptations. In part due to what Netflix is doing with legacy series like Avatar or One Piece. For one expectations are so high nowadays because of what Marvel has been able to do with the mcu in the past. But it's different jumping from 2D animation to live-action because the gap is so wide. You go from a limitless canvas where your only limitation is your imagination. To then create those same moments in the "real world," with "real people". You know where a thing called gravity exists. Fortunately, technology for the most part isn't the biggest limiting factor anymore.
The biggest limiter in live-action series now is time. Most of these live-action adaptations are condensed to around 8 -10 episodes. They have to be super precise in the episodes they choose to cover because if not. You run the risk of creating major plot holes in the story. Combining complementary arcs in one episode is very difficult in itself. Unfortunately, this formula has its ups and downs so the pacing suffers a tad bit in the process. Nothing major but it's something to improve on for future seasons.
Now by no means does this mean I think this series is trash. I enjoyed watching every episode and something I plan on watching it again. Now I see potential in Team Avatar even though they haven't hit their groove yet. It speaks to underlying chemistry issues that can be fixed eventually. It was just not the bite I was looking for which is why I gave it an 8/10 G-Files Score. I can tell you this though I'm super excited for the next season. One thing they did do a good job of was establishing all the players and motivations. Granted some portrayals were better than others. But with more time they can all take their roles to the next level.
The only thing I wish for is to include more of the journey. Even a short montage would suffice. I want it to feel like time is passing and not fast travel everywhere. Appa didn't get any love this season and he is just as big a part of Team Avatar as anybody even Aang. Plus nobody on the squad has a bigger bite than Appa himself so show him a little more respect.
I turned it off and watched the original cartoon instead.
poseyfan27 February 2024
At long last, Netflix's Avatar: The Last Airbender has arrived. And I must say, I didn't necessarily care for it too much. This calls for the classic line: If it ain't broke, don't try to fix it.
I wasn't swayed one way or the other. I didn't hate it, but I didn't love it. It kind of just exists. I couldn't help but compare everything in the show to the original cartoon. (One of the best TV shows ever in my book.) Everything was done in its shadow.
At one point I was watching with my brothers and we were like "this is kind of mid. We should just watch the cartoon." And that's what we did. I think that tells you all you need to know.
I heard someone say that this was on par with Disney's recent live action remakes. Mostly soulless remakes. And I would have to agree.
The best part of this show is the casting I would say. The acting is just ok though.
Overall, I didn't care too much for it.
I wasn't swayed one way or the other. I didn't hate it, but I didn't love it. It kind of just exists. I couldn't help but compare everything in the show to the original cartoon. (One of the best TV shows ever in my book.) Everything was done in its shadow.
At one point I was watching with my brothers and we were like "this is kind of mid. We should just watch the cartoon." And that's what we did. I think that tells you all you need to know.
I heard someone say that this was on par with Disney's recent live action remakes. Mostly soulless remakes. And I would have to agree.
The best part of this show is the casting I would say. The acting is just ok though.
Overall, I didn't care too much for it.
I want more
bvndwhp8 April 2024
I recently saw the avatar animated series and compare it to the live action one. Although it had some changes I really liked them and want to have more episodes of the new storie arc. I appreciate the series because it remind me of this incredible series. 9.5/10. I recall the first time I saw the avatar when I was 12 years old approximately, it was something magical and mystical, I wanted to become a bender of any element like Zuko, Aang, Katara or Toph and I didn't saw the series ever again until the this series dropped out, I watched the 3 seasons and wanted to defend the live action series because it has its own magic. I love the character of uncle iroh but in the first season it looked kind of angry later in the second and third he was more opened and lovely, in the live action serie it gave him his lovely personality since the begging so I appreciate that. Love that zuko had as its shop members the ones he rescued from
His father. That's all give it a try, you will not regret.
Amazing CGI and Effects, Bad acting and Script
bestdesigns23 February 2024
I really loved the animated Series of Avatar, watched it so many times.
Good things : Although this season is much better than last flop movie but they missed so many things. CGI is much better, effects and fights are really good. Bending effects couldnt be better .
Bad things : The fun of characters was nowhere to be seen. Sokka was suppose to be a funny guy but they made him look so angry all the time. Same goes for bhoomi and Iroh.
Story has been changed much enough that for person who never watched it wouldnt understand all of it.
Dialogues and script is so cringe at some places. Specially dialogues of kitara and sokka. Unnecessarily trying to fit the dialogues of animated series without setting up the whole script .
So its 6/10 for me.
Good things : Although this season is much better than last flop movie but they missed so many things. CGI is much better, effects and fights are really good. Bending effects couldnt be better .
Bad things : The fun of characters was nowhere to be seen. Sokka was suppose to be a funny guy but they made him look so angry all the time. Same goes for bhoomi and Iroh.
Story has been changed much enough that for person who never watched it wouldnt understand all of it.
Dialogues and script is so cringe at some places. Specially dialogues of kitara and sokka. Unnecessarily trying to fit the dialogues of animated series without setting up the whole script .
So its 6/10 for me.
Surprisingly good
dollyhello29 March 2024
I wasn't intending to watch this, but after a while, there wasn't anything else except the trashy Love is Blind nonsense and I decided to give this a go. The first few minutes were really B grade but it got much better and I ended up watching all episodes over two days. I loved the little kid who played Aang, and the two who played Katara and Sokka. Prince Zuko was also good. It was great to see so many Native Americans in the story. I will eagerly await season 2, which didn't expect when I started watching it. If you want a straight forward fantasy filled story with great special effects, with no mind bending underlying themes, this one can be recommended.
Where is the humour?
halukkocadere22 February 2024
As a longtime fan of "Avatar: The Last Airbender," I approached Netflix's adaptation with cautious optimism. Unfortunately, what I found was a series that fell short of capturing the magic and depth of the original.
One of the most glaring issues was the lackluster dialogue. Lines that were iconic in the original series were either altered beyond recognition or delivered with a lack of emotion. For example, the pivotal moment when Aang emerges from the iceberg and speaks to Katara lacked the sincerity and charm that made the scene memorable. Instead of the heartfelt exchange between two characters meeting for the first time, it felt forced and flat.
Aang: "I need to ask you something. Please, come closer." Katara: "What is it?" Aang: "Will you go penguin sledding with me?"
Moreover, the adaptation failed to capture the essence of the characters. Aang, Katara, and Sokka lacked the depth and development that made them so beloved in the original series. Instead of complex and nuanced personalities, they felt one-dimensional and uninspired.
Overall, Netflix's adaptation of "Avatar: The Last Airbender" missed the mark. While the visual effects were impressive and the production value was high, it ultimately failed to capture the heart and soul of the original series. Fans of the original will likely be disappointed by this lackluster adaptation.
Rating: 6/10.
One of the most glaring issues was the lackluster dialogue. Lines that were iconic in the original series were either altered beyond recognition or delivered with a lack of emotion. For example, the pivotal moment when Aang emerges from the iceberg and speaks to Katara lacked the sincerity and charm that made the scene memorable. Instead of the heartfelt exchange between two characters meeting for the first time, it felt forced and flat.
Aang: "I need to ask you something. Please, come closer." Katara: "What is it?" Aang: "Will you go penguin sledding with me?"
Moreover, the adaptation failed to capture the essence of the characters. Aang, Katara, and Sokka lacked the depth and development that made them so beloved in the original series. Instead of complex and nuanced personalities, they felt one-dimensional and uninspired.
Overall, Netflix's adaptation of "Avatar: The Last Airbender" missed the mark. While the visual effects were impressive and the production value was high, it ultimately failed to capture the heart and soul of the original series. Fans of the original will likely be disappointed by this lackluster adaptation.
Rating: 6/10.
I can see why the original writers left
tevernaugh-764462 March 2024
Warning: Spoilers
How does Aang make it through the entire season and never even attempted to learn how to wate-rbend??....I thought the series started off really well. The costumes were designed quite poorly, they looked cosplay-ish and even then they're deep in battle they never even seem to get dirty. The animals were designed extremely well and made the series a bit more bearable. The acting wasn't terrible but the over-acting worsened as the series went on and by the end seemed soap opera-ish. In the first few episodes they made minor changes to the storyline, which is expected but half way through they take it entirely too far and started forcing different stories together and started making abilities that are supposed to be unique and special available to every character. They also made Aang seem lazy. He didn't even try to learn waterbending because he thinks one of the past avatars would take over and do it for him. 1/3 of the series is over and Aang is just as untrained as he was 100 years ago. I hope they do better next time around.
Weak dialogue and rushed pacing compromise an otherwise well-done adaptation
seige-hound24 February 2024
Warning: Spoilers
The Netflix adaptation of Avatar is decent. It takes the core plot points, remixes them a little, and turns it into a slightly more mature-toned version. It's still family friendly, but more closely resembling a modern PG-13 superhero story than the PG original.
My core complaints are the dialogue writing and the overall rush to get through the plot at the expense of deeper character development. There is a lot of fanservice, references to the Kyoshi books, a lot of action, and some small changes that I would argue are a little better than the original. However, those are at the expense of a deeper connection with the characters. The most well-developed characters are Aang and Zuko, but even they get a few of their core characteristics shaved off. Aang is a lot less goofy. He still acts like a kid and makes a few good jokes, but he isn't going on little sidequest adventures anymore. There's no elephant koi at Kyoshi Island and only a little cart surfing in Omashu. It's like they trimmed the fat and lost the flavour.
Another issue is the dialogue. Especially in the first episode, the dialogue is very clumsy and exposition-heavy. A lot of telling, and not enough showing. It does improve a bit from episodes 2-8, but a rough start gives a very poor impression, unfortunately.
In terms of the good, there is a decent amount. The choice to combine several plot elements from different episodes into one does work. For example, the third and fourth episodes in Omashu combine plot elements from "The King of Omashu", "Jet", "The Northern Air Temple" and surprisingly "The Cave of Two Lovers". You'd think I'm crazy, but it surprisingly works a lot better than it should.
Then there's the fight scenes. While not as impactful as the animated show, the mix of top-tier CG effects with real choreography far surpasses most fantasy television, let alone the awful 2010 movie. There's no six earthbenders lifting a single pebble in this one, I can assure you of that. Waterbending feels a little weak in this show, but that's about it honestly.
Overall, I'm impressed by the effort. It's not a perfect show, and it definitely isn't remotely better than the original, but I do think it's worth a watch, and I'm looking forward to seeing the rest when it comes out.
My core complaints are the dialogue writing and the overall rush to get through the plot at the expense of deeper character development. There is a lot of fanservice, references to the Kyoshi books, a lot of action, and some small changes that I would argue are a little better than the original. However, those are at the expense of a deeper connection with the characters. The most well-developed characters are Aang and Zuko, but even they get a few of their core characteristics shaved off. Aang is a lot less goofy. He still acts like a kid and makes a few good jokes, but he isn't going on little sidequest adventures anymore. There's no elephant koi at Kyoshi Island and only a little cart surfing in Omashu. It's like they trimmed the fat and lost the flavour.
Another issue is the dialogue. Especially in the first episode, the dialogue is very clumsy and exposition-heavy. A lot of telling, and not enough showing. It does improve a bit from episodes 2-8, but a rough start gives a very poor impression, unfortunately.
In terms of the good, there is a decent amount. The choice to combine several plot elements from different episodes into one does work. For example, the third and fourth episodes in Omashu combine plot elements from "The King of Omashu", "Jet", "The Northern Air Temple" and surprisingly "The Cave of Two Lovers". You'd think I'm crazy, but it surprisingly works a lot better than it should.
Then there's the fight scenes. While not as impactful as the animated show, the mix of top-tier CG effects with real choreography far surpasses most fantasy television, let alone the awful 2010 movie. There's no six earthbenders lifting a single pebble in this one, I can assure you of that. Waterbending feels a little weak in this show, but that's about it honestly.
Overall, I'm impressed by the effort. It's not a perfect show, and it definitely isn't remotely better than the original, but I do think it's worth a watch, and I'm looking forward to seeing the rest when it comes out.
Way better than the last movie, however some criticisms..
ericag_ph21 March 2024
First (1), the best arc that set the bar high in acting, casting, look and feel, storytelling, direction for Avatar is the Kyoshi Island arc (episode 2). They definitely got that right, 9.5/10. BRAVO! Whoever was involved there, give them a raise!! The worst and most disappointing arc was the Omashu arc (episode 3). They tried to do too much in one episode, it seemed rushed, as a result, it was just a mess, 4/10. I almost gave up watching the rest of the show because of episode 3. It was like the director, scriptwriters, editors took the day off. Should have just concentrated on a favorite arc and run upwards with it (my preferred would have been a way better King Bumi arc, drop the Jet, Teo and badger mole arcs). Or give them entire episodes each. I repeat, episode 3 was a mess, very disappointing. Second (2), everywhere else (that is not the Kyoshi island arc), the acting still needs a lot of improvement (which means the director needs to step up as well and bring it out of the actors). I rate the acting as follows: Aang (6), Katara (6) lacks emotion, Sokka (6) needs to be funnier/goofyer, Azula, Sozin, Ozai (5), Iroh (6). I think these actors did a way better job in portraying their characters: June (8), Zhao (8.5), Zuko (8.5), Avatar Kyoshi (9), Suki (9), Yukari (9). Third (3), the characters as they were presented have too many flaws. Azula is too weak rather than scary/powerful or frightening/intimidating. Maybe she could have played the part Toph better, but needs to act tougher. The old movie had a better Azula. The actress who played June (bounty hunter) would have made a way better Azula. Sozin was too friendly looking, doesn't look like anyone who wants to conqueror anything. Ozai though they got the look right didn't appear scary and overpowering/intimidating/bent on conquest. Mai and Tylee - almost invisible. Would have preferred more airtime and character development of them rather than Jet and Teo arc mess of episode 3. Fourth (4), the Northern Water Tribe arc, I thought it was just OK, the storytelling of animated version was just way better. The actors for Yue and Pakku, I think they did a good job, 7 each. Overall, I give the live action season a 7/10. Will watch season 2.
Excellent VFx but story and writing is lacking.
antonbeukes-7270223 February 2024
Overall i enjoyed the show. The visual FX is a spectacle to watch and is rather nicely executed. The backdrops and sets were all very well done. The characters themselves give tribute the original story and characters but that is there my problems with the show begins.
My biggest disappointment is that If you've watched the movie you could basically can skip this. The general story begins and ends the same.
The writing at times felt forced, bland and "kinda pausing for reaction" bad. The actors themselves i liked, but nothing memorable either.
The princess character and here entourage annoyed me to no end and the whole writing around her felt extremely forced. And while writing this part or this review I even lower my score from 7 to 6/10 so bad it was for me.
My biggest disappointment is that If you've watched the movie you could basically can skip this. The general story begins and ends the same.
The writing at times felt forced, bland and "kinda pausing for reaction" bad. The actors themselves i liked, but nothing memorable either.
The princess character and here entourage annoyed me to no end and the whole writing around her felt extremely forced. And while writing this part or this review I even lower my score from 7 to 6/10 so bad it was for me.
Good, Could Be Great With Tweaks
mjblue-9977214 April 2024
The original Avatar the last Airbender series is one of my favorites of all time. I remember watching it live week to week as a high schooler and thinking how weird it was I was so into a "kids show" on Nickelodeon. As I get older I've watched it a few more times and the more I watch it, the more I love it. It holds up in every aspect-the visuals, writing, character arcs and relationships amongst each other, humor, etc.
So when this show was announced I was skeptical because the movie stunk, and because the original series makes it a lot to live up to. I've now watched the whole first season and I have to say it exceeded my low expectations. As others have said, the visuals are incredible and some of the casting is actually very much on point. I thought Yue, Iroh, Zhao and Zuko in particular were all pretty great (However, other casting decisions were not good at all, but that wasn't my main problem that I'll get to later). I appreciated that they didn't veer too far off the path of the first one in terms of plot (although they did rearrange some things that I thought were unnecessary and skipped some story sections I liked). Keep sticking to the source material in the future seasons!
The thing I think they missed on big time though, and hope to see changed in the coming seasons, is the brightness, levity, and humor of the original series. The first one walked the line really well of portraying at times very mature themes, but packaged them in a way that was very digestible and often times funny. The remake ditched that strategy almost completely, and the tone is over the top serious and at times even dark. I really couldn't specifically believe how they portrayed Aang and Sokka as mostly serious characters, it felt wrong. They're both kids, they don't need to force them to act like adults, it's weird. To add to that, Katara is portrayed timid this time, when in the original she was feisty and the voice of reason to two goofballs.
If you watch the original for just one episode after watching the live action version you see how radical the tone shift is, and I hope they don't keep going in this direction, it could be so much better with a brighter and funnier tone, one that doesn't take itself so seriously but still can tackle mature themes. That was one of the pieces that made the first one amazing.
So when this show was announced I was skeptical because the movie stunk, and because the original series makes it a lot to live up to. I've now watched the whole first season and I have to say it exceeded my low expectations. As others have said, the visuals are incredible and some of the casting is actually very much on point. I thought Yue, Iroh, Zhao and Zuko in particular were all pretty great (However, other casting decisions were not good at all, but that wasn't my main problem that I'll get to later). I appreciated that they didn't veer too far off the path of the first one in terms of plot (although they did rearrange some things that I thought were unnecessary and skipped some story sections I liked). Keep sticking to the source material in the future seasons!
The thing I think they missed on big time though, and hope to see changed in the coming seasons, is the brightness, levity, and humor of the original series. The first one walked the line really well of portraying at times very mature themes, but packaged them in a way that was very digestible and often times funny. The remake ditched that strategy almost completely, and the tone is over the top serious and at times even dark. I really couldn't specifically believe how they portrayed Aang and Sokka as mostly serious characters, it felt wrong. They're both kids, they don't need to force them to act like adults, it's weird. To add to that, Katara is portrayed timid this time, when in the original she was feisty and the voice of reason to two goofballs.
If you watch the original for just one episode after watching the live action version you see how radical the tone shift is, and I hope they don't keep going in this direction, it could be so much better with a brighter and funnier tone, one that doesn't take itself so seriously but still can tackle mature themes. That was one of the pieces that made the first one amazing.
Beautiful visuals
Dragonscouter6 April 2024
As a child the last air bender was one of my favorite mobvies, especially the first one that came up. I have not been invested much in the animation version of it but watching this new series has been an absolute enjoyment
the visuals are pretty nice, some scenes I was getting hyped on my seat because it was cool to watch your childhood favorite character in action. The actor has done an amazing job, the way he portrays the avatar as well as his charisma and character fits it perfectly and is very amusing to watch
The story is not something they could play with much but the story is pretty basic, I am here more for the visuals and the actions of the series.
Would definitely recommend.
the visuals are pretty nice, some scenes I was getting hyped on my seat because it was cool to watch your childhood favorite character in action. The actor has done an amazing job, the way he portrays the avatar as well as his charisma and character fits it perfectly and is very amusing to watch
The story is not something they could play with much but the story is pretty basic, I am here more for the visuals and the actions of the series.
Would definitely recommend.
Pretty Darn Good
rich735425 March 2024
Never having seen the animated version, I had no expectations going into this. I didn't even know what the storyline was until I read it on Netflix. On viewing the first episode, I was totally hooked and binge watched the rest of the series. Here are my thoughts.
The good: Great visuals, great CGI, compelling story, and characters you can actually like (unlike so many shows these days). Add to that some very good action sequences and fast paced storytelling, and you pretty much have a recipe for success.
The bad: As with so many other shows, the writers do not seem to know how to write a great season finale... it wasn't terrible, but it was unsatisfying. Additionally, the acting and dialog suffered at times, particularly with the Aang and the firebender princess (can't remember her name).
Conclusion: I thought this was a very good effort and well worth watching. I'm looking forward to season two.
The good: Great visuals, great CGI, compelling story, and characters you can actually like (unlike so many shows these days). Add to that some very good action sequences and fast paced storytelling, and you pretty much have a recipe for success.
The bad: As with so many other shows, the writers do not seem to know how to write a great season finale... it wasn't terrible, but it was unsatisfying. Additionally, the acting and dialog suffered at times, particularly with the Aang and the firebender princess (can't remember her name).
Conclusion: I thought this was a very good effort and well worth watching. I'm looking forward to season two.
Gorgeous effects, failure of characters
ramosaral22 February 2024
First things first, they did a top notch job with visual effects. Bending techniques, the way the elements connect with the bodies of the characters, the places all look wonderful. They bring the world alive. However, that is not what ATLA is about. In order for the characters to have their development we need to see their interaction, we need to see their characters, that is why we love the characters in the cartoon. Here the characters are all over the place. There is no goofiness, they are all too serious which bothers.
Also, showing things subtly, inserting the message between the lines is the strength of the cartoon. Here they deliver ling winded, empty, and bland speeches that do not move us.
Also, showing things subtly, inserting the message between the lines is the strength of the cartoon. Here they deliver ling winded, empty, and bland speeches that do not move us.
Great scenary, weird scripting/directing
leonx-6260222 February 2024
Amazing scenary and editing, it really gives off the vibe of the places in the original series. Also the didn't spare in the usage of bending which is great.
But i was thrown a bit off by the threatical like acting, and the script. Maybe I need to get used to it. But it feels a bit forced how they act, like is very improbable to behave like that in reality. I guess they try to have similar reactions as the original characters in the show, but since they are cartoons its more acceptable. For a live action adaptation i would expect a bit more real/normal behaviour. But then again, i only watched one episode so far, so I'll try to get use to it.
But i was thrown a bit off by the threatical like acting, and the script. Maybe I need to get used to it. But it feels a bit forced how they act, like is very improbable to behave like that in reality. I guess they try to have similar reactions as the original characters in the show, but since they are cartoons its more acceptable. For a live action adaptation i would expect a bit more real/normal behaviour. But then again, i only watched one episode so far, so I'll try to get use to it.
Better than expected but parts of the wood they build is inconsistent
LetThemEatHay2 April 2024
Warning: Spoilers
I love the special effects, this series is visually stunning. Castings was mostly spot on especially Aang, Iroh and Zhao. The actors were perfect for these role. Actors that were miscast are Princess Yue who looks out of place and they put a bad wig on her, Sokka was also a miss for me.
I just wish they could be more consistent in the world they build. Aang can "fly" by bending the air yet when he needed to escape he was physically climbing a wall. He also have the strongest power but waa kidnapped and restrain with just a rope. Why? This is so inconsistent with how he is supposed to be.
Katara should have had the opportunity to work on improving water bending and hand to hand combat. They make her seem like a prodigy who just happens to figure it out. She had a cool fight scene with Zuko but we never seen her train with a kungfu master.
The back story for Prince. Zuko was done really well, I really feel for the character. Iroh being hit on by a girl young enough to be his daughter is bizzare especially when it added nothing to the plot.
The finale also had this build up and they just had "godzilla" fight the battle for them, it's so anticlimactic. Despite these flaws I still really e not the series, it's a goos fun adventure to watch during movie nights!
I just wish they could be more consistent in the world they build. Aang can "fly" by bending the air yet when he needed to escape he was physically climbing a wall. He also have the strongest power but waa kidnapped and restrain with just a rope. Why? This is so inconsistent with how he is supposed to be.
Katara should have had the opportunity to work on improving water bending and hand to hand combat. They make her seem like a prodigy who just happens to figure it out. She had a cool fight scene with Zuko but we never seen her train with a kungfu master.
The back story for Prince. Zuko was done really well, I really feel for the character. Iroh being hit on by a girl young enough to be his daughter is bizzare especially when it added nothing to the plot.
The finale also had this build up and they just had "godzilla" fight the battle for them, it's so anticlimactic. Despite these flaws I still really e not the series, it's a goos fun adventure to watch during movie nights!
This is not Aang's story. This is Zuko's.
qjfcgbcc24 February 2024
I am very loyal to the original animated series, and I understand why the creators of the original series decided to part ways on this adaptation. I was so angry when I started this, so many plot points and characters were mushed together to fit into less episodes that it left out huge development details, huge connections that become critical later in the storyline, and above all else, Aang's story felt nothing like him. But then I switched perspectives, and made Zuko the main character in my head... and the whole thing changed. I was no longer mad about what was wrong with Aang's story because it was not the necessary to the main characters plot. I was still very annoyed... but I wasn't fuming and yelling at the TV (which I did, more than once). Is the original better? Hands down! But anyone who has seen the original should have already been prepared, knowing nothing will be better than what we all already loved. But because of how well the original handled character development, we all love Zuko just as much as we love Aang. So try watching it as if this is his story, it may make it easier for you to enjoy. Do I think this series can and should do better in the future at staying truer to the original plot? Absolutely. I am hoping they had to combine plot points in this season to get the show off the ground and get a bigger budget from Netflix on season two, and with a larger budget will stay truer to the story. I think it is worth watching, if only to see certain aspects come to life in live action. Just know there are parts you will be mad about. And give it a chance with Zuko in mind as the star.
Perfectly Imperfect
ysnptrj24 February 2024
This is more a refreshing adaptation of a source material that's been delivered in recent times. Yes. Some of the acting is clunky and a bit goofy; however, watching the character dynamics with each other is, quite honestly, as close to the source that could be expected. Firebenders manifest fire. Waterbenders look like waterbenders. This can be watched, and you can still reminisce the animated adventure without feeling an injustice has been committed like a past adaptation that won't be mentioned here.......ever again........personally, I don't hover over films, shows, or media in general looking for inconsistencies. But as a causal viewer. This is perfectly imperfect. It captures the world of Avatar. I'm relieved of the dread of expecting some artist's COMPLETE reimagining of a beloved source and elated to find something that is a retelling of it in a different medium. True to the source; true to the story. I appreciate this beyond words, and am excited to see it through.
I really love the original, this has something missing
diogoaxavier23 February 2024
Warning: Spoilers
I give it a low 7.
Avatar the Last Airbender is my absolutely favorite show ever. Was really sad when the movie came out and what they did with the IP. This is better than the movie, but it doesn't make it that good but it's not that bad either.
It's like every one is saying the visuals are great and the bending looks good, even though it's wonky sometimes.
Pretty cool to watch all the past Avatars, and their point of view, even though it seems like its all Aang did throughout the show.
I get that it's a lot to pack in 8 episodes, but story line for Jet and the Mechanist felt weird and confused, i would rewrite episodes 3 and 4 everything is tangled and kind of bad. Also... The tunnel of two lovers without aang... Cmooon if you're going to do it now... Do it with Aang!
The actors for Aang and Katara seemed pretty bland to me. They only had like 2/3 emotions but Sokka really stole the show for me. One thing to high note is the Good chemistry between iroh and Zuko. And the fire lord is pretty cool as well!
One thing that really lacked was the whole waterbending training arc which was basically non existing. For the water book having Aang not waterbending at all is pretty stupid. And Katara being called a master with no training whatsoever it seemed a very Mary Sue moment.
It's early but I think the casting for Azula, ty Lee and Mai doesn't look that good, I hope they prove me wrong.
Avatar the Last Airbender is my absolutely favorite show ever. Was really sad when the movie came out and what they did with the IP. This is better than the movie, but it doesn't make it that good but it's not that bad either.
It's like every one is saying the visuals are great and the bending looks good, even though it's wonky sometimes.
Pretty cool to watch all the past Avatars, and their point of view, even though it seems like its all Aang did throughout the show.
I get that it's a lot to pack in 8 episodes, but story line for Jet and the Mechanist felt weird and confused, i would rewrite episodes 3 and 4 everything is tangled and kind of bad. Also... The tunnel of two lovers without aang... Cmooon if you're going to do it now... Do it with Aang!
The actors for Aang and Katara seemed pretty bland to me. They only had like 2/3 emotions but Sokka really stole the show for me. One thing to high note is the Good chemistry between iroh and Zuko. And the fire lord is pretty cool as well!
One thing that really lacked was the whole waterbending training arc which was basically non existing. For the water book having Aang not waterbending at all is pretty stupid. And Katara being called a master with no training whatsoever it seemed a very Mary Sue moment.
It's early but I think the casting for Azula, ty Lee and Mai doesn't look that good, I hope they prove me wrong.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
