Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
The Gay Lady (1949)
Lovely performances plus historical facts of the Gaiety Girls.
28 November 1999
This film tells the story of 'Trottie True', a middle class girl who becomes a child star of the Bedford Music Hall, graduates to the heights of being a successful Gaiety Girl, marries a Lord and eventually leaves the stage. It is not a particularly original or thrilling storyline, and it could be a very dull film if it were not for the sumptuous costumes and scenery that are so beautifully selected to display the Technicolor process.

The on-stage scenes (which are few and far between) show some colourful costumes as do the various ballroom and restaurant scenes. This newly restored print enables us to have a good idea of what the film would have originally been like to see the cinema, and it must have been a wonderful way to forget the aftermath of the war.

Apart from the lavishness and brightness of the film, the female performances are a delight, especially that of Jean Kent as 'Trottie True'. Miss Kent gives a truthful performance of a rising star who falls in love with a Balloonist, becomes a successful stage performer, and marries a Lord. The story all sounds rather far-fetched, but Jean Kent's performance makes it work. So often, characters that are aiming for stardom become untruthful, but Miss Kent was totally believable. She aimed to get to the top of her profession, and did so without becoming the usual 'bitch', a trap that these type of roles can easily fall into. She is also totally believable towards the end of the film when she marries the Lord and becomes a Duchess. A particularly moving moment happens when she performs her Music Hall songs at the Servants Ball. We all think that her rather austere mother-in-law will be mortified, but instead turns to her husband, and says: "She can stay" - perhaps a little sentimental, but rather moving. Apart from giving an excellent performance, Jean Kent also looks so beautiful in her extravagant dresses and with her gorgeous red hair used to full effect in the Technicolor filming.

The other female roles are equally well cast, particularly the ever-wonderful Hattie Jacques as a fellow Gaiety Girl. She gives a wonderfully rich comic performance that never steps over the mark. It is good to see her in an earlier stage in her career. Hattie Jacques is matched brilliantly with the late Bill Owen as 'Trottie's' Music Hall friend. He gives a performance without any of the ususal stereotypical characteristics of a 'Cockney Music Hall Performer', and although it is obvious that he is in love with 'Trottie', he never becomes too sentimental as if playing 'Buttons' in "Cinderella".

Unfortunately, the male leads let down the film. James Donald as 'Lord Digby' is extremely dull. 'Trottie' has far too much vitality to fall in love with him! Her first love, 'Maurice' (the Balloonist) (Hugh Sinclair) was an unbelievable character and his rather awkward smile filled the screen too many times. I rather felt that 'Trottie' may have had more fun if she had gone off with some of the film extras - and why not when they comprise of such names as Roger Moore, Patrick Cargill and Ian Carmichael! In fact the list of small part players is rather amazing, with a wonderful ripple of recognition when Gretchen Franklyn appeared as 'Martha' the maid in 'Trottie's' childhood home! A special mention needs to go to a young teenage Dilys Laye who plays the young 'Trottie'. She gave a delightful performance and gave a clear indication of the successful career that she was about to embark upon.

The most important element of this film is depiction of the differences between the Music Hall and Gaiety Theatre. There is a wonderful scene between 'Trottie' and Lana Morris as 'Bouncie Barrington' in which 'Bouncie' comments on all the jewellery she has been given from her Stage-Door Johnnies. She says that she is a Gaiety Girl because she is pretty - which is all that is expected from her when she performs on the stage. 'Trottie', of course, has other ideas, and knows that she is a good performer and that the audiences love her for her talent. This film gives a good indication what these days must have been like - it is just such a shame that a full Musical Number is not seen on stage at the Gaiety. One number between Bill Owen, Hattie Jacques and Jean Kent is seen (in part) from the wings of a theatre. It should have been filmed in its entirety, but was cut short few to financial constraints at the time of filming. The other songs were sweet, including a Music Hall number written by Carroll Gibbons which commenced with Dilys Laye as the young 'Trottie' and moved forward in time with Jean Kent finishing it as the older 'Trottie'. Another song "White Wings" (which is supposed to have been one of the Queen Mother's favourite songs) seemed rather dull and although was supposed to be sung by Jean Kent, looked suspiciously dubbed! The print viewed was a newly restored version of a gorgeous film that gave us some lovely performances plus historical facts of the Gaiety Girls.
14 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Treat For 1950's Musical Nostalgia Buffs
13 February 1999
This musical film remake of THE GOOD COMPANIONS (Dir:J Lee Thompson, for Associated British in 1957) features several tuneful songs by Paddy Roberts(m/l), C. Alberto Rossi(m/l) and Geoffrey Parsons(l). Miss Trant (played by Celia Johnson),and her encounter with the struggling concert party, the 'Dinky Doos', and the world of the touring theatre as depicted by J.B. Priestley was well known to English audiences since the thirties. As the setting of the story is updated from 1929 (when touring shows were highly popular) to the 1950's, when they were in decline, the musical style is also updated, and the songs are all catchy in the style of variety c1956. Indeed, the film is priceless as a 1950's British film musical which owes nothing to operetta or rock and roll - in its recording and celebration of fifties variety it is unique. It also remains faithful to the essential spirit of Priestley's novel in its celebration of show business and the theatrical life, and in particular, the metaphor of the touring theatre as an escape for the middle aged male from a society that is domesticated, drab and puritanical, epitomised in those dour apron wearing wives (played by Thora Hird and Beatrice Varley in the film) who appear at the stage door and attempt to drag their 'erring' husbands away from the chorus girls, and back to 'reality'. There is also the sense of community amongst the performers, and of communal travel by steam hauled trains through the length of Great Britain.

Eighteen year old Janette Scott, a potent symbol of a lost age of 1950's innocent screen romance, does not receive top billing, but clearly emerges as the star of THE GOOD COMPANIONS. She displays great spirit and loads of charm, especially in the 'Today will be a Lovely Day' number, and her enthusiasm is quite infectious in the skilfully staged finale. I would also single out for praise Eric Portman, who is perfect in the role of Jess Oakroyd, and brings richness and depth to the role. There is a wonderful moment at the end of TGC, when after Susie Dean's triumph, he nods leans forward and glances towards Miss Trant, who is sitting in the same row of the theatre stalls, and almost telepathically communicates with her to share Susie's moment of triumph. THE GOOD COMPANIONS is strong in character acting in a very English tradition (even a theatre manager has an individuality about him, even though he appears only briefly with one line of dialogue), and just look at the cast list of supporting actors!: Joyce Grenfell, Anthony Newley, John LeMesurier, Rachel Roberts, Thora Hird, Alec McCowen, Hugh Griffith, Shirley Anne Field, Bobby Howes, Melvyn Hayes, the list goes on and on - what a cast! It is also to the credit of the direction and writing, that with so many characters they are so clearly defined and that the narrative remains focused.

It is these qualities, together with the film's excellent production values (in its restoration, the film is one of the most visually elegant British films of its decade-the lighting of interiors is exceptional,rooms and decor are beautifully depicted-Jess Oakroyd's living room, public houses, theatre interiors, and a private dining room at the back of a seedy café which takes on a warmth all of its own because of the theatricals seated round the table). These qualities, together with the good natured charm of the young leads, make THE GOOD COMPANIONS excellent entertainment. A rarely seen, high spirited British showbiz musical,'The Good Companions' of 1957 is a 'must see' for 1950's nostalgia buffs.
18 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed