Wow, I can't believe so many people are rating this highly. This ending was truly ridiculous.
The first hour or so of this episode made me believe it was a perfect, fitting finale for the show. The action sequences were brilliantly done, the music choices were great, there were so many great character moments, I could go on. Armin and Zeke's conversation is one of the most moving scenes of the entire show. Everything feels so well executed, but that changes when...
Eren dies. Now hold on, I know you're thinking I'm one of those crazy AOT fans who's been rooting for Eren - but rest assured I am not. I thought his dying was the best choice for the story. It's the way they went about it that bothered me. Here's where I begin to have problems with the story.
In a vision from the past, Eren and Armin have a conversation where everything is sorta revealed, and it's this scene that tanks the whole episode for me. In short, Eren is redeemed.
HUH?
Yeah, you heard me right, the genocidal POS who has single-handedly murdered 80% of the population, small children included! And he's just... forgiven?! The explanation they give for this is mind-numbingly stupid. Basically he's supposed to be noble because he wanted all his friends to "be together with him in hell." That's just such a ridiculous plot point. This show previously didnt adhere to any religion and to shoehorn in the hell thing is just crazy and out of nowhere. Eren also has an incel breakdown about Mikasa not forgetting him and staying single just to pine after him for "at least ten years." Gross. And after everything, the brutal killing of hundreds of millions of innocents... Armin forgives him.
This is just disgusting, the way the story ends with everyone having a respect for Eren. Not only that - Reiner and Annie are integrated back into the main group and essentially forgiven. What's the message of this show? You can murder as many people as you want as long as you do it for your friends?
The rest of the story is still insane. Mikasa sits at Eren's grave and a bird flies up to her and pulls at the scarf. What is this supposed to mean? That Eren was reincarnated as a bird? When has this ever been a mechanic or rule of the story? Just ridiculous.
The ending with the flash forwards into the future is just depressing and trying wayyyy too hard to be "deep." In reality, showing Paradis get built up, only to be destroyed again, is just depressing and makes all the sacrifices feel unneeded.
This episode takes an amazing, well-done show and screws it all up, getting very close to making the right creature choices before pulling the rug out from under the viewers. I'm very disappointed.
7/10, and that's me being generous.
The first hour or so of this episode made me believe it was a perfect, fitting finale for the show. The action sequences were brilliantly done, the music choices were great, there were so many great character moments, I could go on. Armin and Zeke's conversation is one of the most moving scenes of the entire show. Everything feels so well executed, but that changes when...
Eren dies. Now hold on, I know you're thinking I'm one of those crazy AOT fans who's been rooting for Eren - but rest assured I am not. I thought his dying was the best choice for the story. It's the way they went about it that bothered me. Here's where I begin to have problems with the story.
In a vision from the past, Eren and Armin have a conversation where everything is sorta revealed, and it's this scene that tanks the whole episode for me. In short, Eren is redeemed.
HUH?
Yeah, you heard me right, the genocidal POS who has single-handedly murdered 80% of the population, small children included! And he's just... forgiven?! The explanation they give for this is mind-numbingly stupid. Basically he's supposed to be noble because he wanted all his friends to "be together with him in hell." That's just such a ridiculous plot point. This show previously didnt adhere to any religion and to shoehorn in the hell thing is just crazy and out of nowhere. Eren also has an incel breakdown about Mikasa not forgetting him and staying single just to pine after him for "at least ten years." Gross. And after everything, the brutal killing of hundreds of millions of innocents... Armin forgives him.
This is just disgusting, the way the story ends with everyone having a respect for Eren. Not only that - Reiner and Annie are integrated back into the main group and essentially forgiven. What's the message of this show? You can murder as many people as you want as long as you do it for your friends?
The rest of the story is still insane. Mikasa sits at Eren's grave and a bird flies up to her and pulls at the scarf. What is this supposed to mean? That Eren was reincarnated as a bird? When has this ever been a mechanic or rule of the story? Just ridiculous.
The ending with the flash forwards into the future is just depressing and trying wayyyy too hard to be "deep." In reality, showing Paradis get built up, only to be destroyed again, is just depressing and makes all the sacrifices feel unneeded.
This episode takes an amazing, well-done show and screws it all up, getting very close to making the right creature choices before pulling the rug out from under the viewers. I'm very disappointed.
7/10, and that's me being generous.
Tell Your Friends