I give it a 7 because of the money and quality that is put it into it. I have not read the books but I feel the pain of the folks who have because I'm experiencing the same thing with The Wheel of Time. I have always felt that if you want to change the IP to a point where it doesn't match the content of the original book, just create a new series with a different name and negotiate the IP price because of the difference. I may have created some future millionaires there because of that simple formula...
Don't destroy the original. On it's own, I would give it a higher rating, but I really don't like shows that make you have to work for it to understand what's going on. After reading a little about the book series and now know that it's spans generations, I understand the dilemma. Ambitious undertaking, but if you can't make it work (and it's not working according to the feedback from discerning readers of the book) just unfold the dimensions and make it more simple. I got that from an episode of the show :). Thank you for reading.
Don't destroy the original. On it's own, I would give it a higher rating, but I really don't like shows that make you have to work for it to understand what's going on. After reading a little about the book series and now know that it's spans generations, I understand the dilemma. Ambitious undertaking, but if you can't make it work (and it's not working according to the feedback from discerning readers of the book) just unfold the dimensions and make it more simple. I got that from an episode of the show :). Thank you for reading.
Tell Your Friends