Reviews

187 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
The Amos 'n Andy Show (1951–1953)
5/10
NYC 400 - #399 - "The Amos 'n Andy Show"
2 May 2024
Minstrel Shows were a popular form of entertainment for audiences before film and television existed. There were rapid fire jokes, clever patter, a lot of puns and wordplay. It was lowbrow humor for its own sake. But the target of all of the offense were Black Americans.

Minstrel Shows gained popularity in the 1830s, about the time that abolitionists began seriously pushing to end slavery in the nation. The shows were clearly a way of allowing many to continue to believe that Black people were lesser and also a method of comforting those worried about a world where "their property" could do whatever they wanted.

It's also important to know that the actors in a Minstrel Show were nearly always white performers made up in blackface to look like the characters they mocked, and the makeup was designed to be garish - exaggerating the features of the eyes and especially the mouth to enormous proportions.

Minstrel Shows had three main characters that narrated or performed for the audience. Jim Crow was a badly dressed, mentally challenged buffoon. And yes, that's where the term "Jim Crow Laws" originated. Zip Coon was a well-to-do, aspirational character who considered himself to be on the same level as white people. And Mr. Tambo was a musician, who always carried a tambourine to accent a joke or to keep rhythm when the inevitable dance numbers began.

When the concept of "Amos 'n' Andy" was created, it's very clear that it was using the basics of the Minstrel Show format, right down to the performers. Two white vocal performers did the voices of the characters on the show.

When television started and the idea of transferring this very popular radio show into a TV series happened, it was determined that they really couldn't do it in a "blackface" style. They needed to cast actual Black actors to play the parts.

In 1951, "Amos 'n' Andy" started airing on CBS and became the first television program with an all Black cast. That was something. Alvin Childress was Amos, Spencer Williams was Andy and Tim Moore was their main nemesis, Kingfish.

It's important to put this series in context with history to show what was happening. In a way, the timing of its debut matched the timing of interest in Minstrel Shows when the anti-slave movement was occurring, as the Civil Rights movement was seriously starting to gain ground as this show began.

The setting of the program was Harlem, USA. And these characters got into all sorts of predicaments based on their personality traits. Many of the scripts for the series were taken directly from the radio show and adapted for the small screen. It was stereotyping to the max as the continual messaging of how lazy and useless these characters were created most of the laughs for viewers.

It didn't help that CBS chose to premiere this program at the same time an NAACP National Convention was happening. The network got some serious blowback from Black Americans for that choice.

However, there were positives that happened because of the program, as some eventual performers were inspired to go into show business because of seeing this show. Richard Pryor, Redd Foxx and several other comedians became motivated to get involved in storytelling because of seeing this program.

Of course, if there were a more positive, less bigoted program that aired instead, I'm sure that also could have motivated them as well, but let's not walk down a path that doesn't exist.

New York plays a part because everyone knew Harlem, what it represented and why it was important. It was one of the biggest centers of Black people in the nation and there was no other location that could have created the same sort of recognition and impact as that.

Eventually, CBS bent to the pressure placed on them by the NAACP and canceled the show. But, in some ways, it set the stage for the standard format of the US sitcom that has been a staple on television for over seventy years and for that, it does deserve to make the list.

I don't think anyone needs to see "The Amos 'n Andy Shoe" now, except as a student of sociology, political science, psychology, ethics, and to learn how "entertainment" can be abusive and can have an impact on our society. In that sense, the program will always serve a purpose as a part of the history of the United States.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Annie McGuire (1988–1989)
7/10
NYC 400 - #314 - "Annie McGuire"
1 May 2024
What if "The Brady Bunch" had a few less kids, father Mike was a staunch Conservative, and mom Carol was a complete liberal, while Carol worked in New York Government?

It might look a little bit like this...

After "Mary Tyler Moore" ended, the star of that program had a difficult time finding a new groove. She had something of a charmed TV Life to that point, being part of the cast of "The Dick Van Dyke Show" and her own Minneapolis series, with both shows becoming beloved favorites while they originally aired, and later, still quite popular in syndicated reruns.

Getting that new successful series for Mary wasn't for lack of trying. Comedy, Variety, there were several attempts to give Mary a reboot and in this try, we had a kind of dramedy thing going on.

I have to think part of the influence of this series was another surprise hit on NBC, which began the summer before this series started: "The Days and Nights of Molly Dodd," which is also on this list of The 400 Most Notable TV Series Set in New York CIty. The elements that link "Molly" to "Annie" are the fact that it was a single camera shoot, with no audience or laugh track, and the material wasn't your standard sitcom jokes. This was attempting to be life, but just a little bit edgier, and maybe (hopefully) funnier.

Mary is, of course, the titular character, working as Deputy Coordinator of Community Relations in lower Manhattan, with one kid from her previous marriage. She commutes from her home in Bayonne, New Jersey, "Working Girl" style, on the ferry. She's a liberal who, as the series begins, is a newlywed with Nick McGuire, played by Dennis Arndt, Dad to two, and who is a construction contractor and gets his politics from his dad, a very conservative restaurant owner.

Even in her most recent series at this point, "Mary," which had her as a writer for a Chicago based publication with a whole series of quirky co-workers, Ms. Moore had a live audience, so you got to hear reactions to the jokes. It's a little jarring to see this "real life" attempt without that reaction. I don't think that was the worst of it, but it was nothing like anything Ms. Moore had done, to this point.

Also, the program did use that political angle, with the Conservative Republicans squaring off against the Liberal Democrats in a power struggle that we now know all too well.

New York played a part because city government, the welfare of the citizens, the demands of the office Annie held and her continual commutes from and to Jersey were all a part of the situation, and Nick's construction projects even start to interfere with Annie's work, as his job deals with New York City properties as well.

The mentality of network programmers is what likely killed this show fairly quickly. You have a well known star, doing what she does in a format that's a little bit different. Do you find a suitable time slot so that people can find the program, develop a liking for it and make it a hit? Or do you throw it against one of the hottest shows currently on the air and hope that it destroys the ratings of that program? The thinking was to place this show opposite ABC's "Full House," which was an already well established and popular family comedy.

Also, CBS apparently wanted to create a comedy block with Dick Van Dyke's series, "The Van Dyke Show," a standard style sitcom which featured father and son, Dick and Barry Van Dyke together. That program also was having problems finding an audience, and pairing it with Mary and this dramedy format, back to back only made sense in one way: The execs must have hoped fans of the Petrie family would tune in to see them once again, here.

"Annie McGuire," with its darker toned comedy, the political undercurrents and desire to make statements about humanity, plus the lack of a studio audience or laugh track to sweeten the jokes just didn't get anywhere, despite some concepts worth exploring and some plots that had something to say.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
24 (2001–2010)
8/10
NYC 400 - #315 - "24" (Season 8)
1 May 2024
What is it about guys with the initials "J. B.?" Britain's superspy James Bond is now in his seventh decade of work. Jason Bourne had dodged both good and bad guys through a series of films. And the Godfather of Soul, James Brown is the funkiest of them all!

But then there's this guy. Jack Bauer. He had spent a full seven days handling a whole ton of stuff, as a counter terrorist agent for an organization called CTU, where he dealt with an assassination plot against a US presidential candidate, a nuclear bomb traveling around Los Angeles on a truck and a potentially lethal airborne virus being spread by a group of anti-Americans, among a host of issues. Along the way, he lost friends, co-workers, and nearly died himself multiple times in multiple ways.

On the Eighth Day, Jack Bauer didn't rest. He came to New York City.

Obviously, if this series was set in NYC for the entirety of its run, it would rank a whole lot higher on this list of The 400 Most Notable TV Shows Set in New York City. But the fact that Bauer and company brought their mayhem and destruction From LA to DC to NY does get "Day 8" posted, here.

If you somehow aren't aware the premise of "24," let me briefly explain that each hour of each season of the show is supposedly done in "real time." You are watching an hour from the 24 hour period that season is set within. I say "supposedly" because we are sneaking in commercial breaks during each episode, as the clock continues to tick, so we're missing some action (and, I can only presume, some Bauer Bathroom Breaks).

It's also notable that the original season was delayed specifically because it featured a terrorist attack on an airplane, which Fox execs felt was too close to The Events of September 11, 2001, and pushed the premiere date, back to November of that year. So to have this program shift locations to New York for its eighth season was kind of a big step.

Day 8 was notable for a couple of reasons. First, it was announced that this would be the final season of the series, so there was a lot of immediate speculation about what was going to happen to Kiefer Sutherland's lead character at the end. Would Jack Bauer survive? Sutherland had been quoted as saying that "the star of the show is the clock" and that the format would work, even without Jack Bauer, hinting that maybe there were other seasons to come, without him.

We'll come back to that thought, but let's get into the basics of the plot for Day 8. President Allison Taylor (Cherry Jones) is in town to meet with President Omar Hassan (Anil Kapoor) of the Islamic Republic of Kamistan, amusingly abbreviated IRK, as they were due to sign a peace treaty between the countries. They agreed to meet at the United Nations, as it represented a global effort to bring stability to the Middle East and to make the world more safe.

However there were several plots running concurrently, attempting to prevent that from happening: an assassination plot against President Hassan, to stop the treaty from being signed, Hassan's brother, who wasn't interested in their country giving up their nuclear program and wanted to continue to move radioactive materials into their labs for testing, Hassan having a poorly hidden romantic relationship with an American reporter (Jennifer Westfeldt) right under the nose of his wife and daughter, and the Russians were attempting to pull a maneuver to gain an upper hand on the US, all in the mix.

Let's also point out that Jack Bauer was officially retired and was only in town to do some physical rehabilitation from his previous day, which, of course, nearly killed him. He's a Grandpa to his young granddaughter through his own daughter, Kim (Elisha Cuthbert), and really didn't want to get involved in any official business as he was planning to return to Los Angeles with them, but every minute he got pulled deeper and deeper into the plot.

New York played a part because it's an ideal game board for playing hide and seek, and a lot more realistic than the driving around the sprawling and traffic snarled Greater Los Angeles Area to get from one place to another in a few minutes, as depicted on Days One through Six! Plus the threat of so many people in harm's way in such a small space, and the elements that represented, with the NYPD and other organizations trying to prevent both the actions of the bad actors and the panic of the population, made those scenarios seem very real in a place where an actual terrorist attack was still fresh in the minds of residents.

Bauer's organization had been discontinued previously, but here, the revitalized CTU, was brought back, featuring agent Cole Ortiz (Freddie Prinze, Jr.) in what essentially was the Bauer role for this season, facing off against the CTU honcho, Brian Hastings (Mykelti Williamson) and the return of Bauer's right hand and computer whiz Chloe O'Brian (Mary Lynn Rajskub) who is, like Jack, a little rusty as this day begins. For a couple of hours, it seemed like Prinze Jr. Was going to take on the protagonist part for this series, assuming it was going to continue.

Bauer gets to go off, maybe moreso than in any other season of this series, primarily because he isn't a government official so he doesn't have to answer directly to any higher ups for his actions, and because he has some personal vendettas to settle with people who did him very, very wrong.

By this time in the history of "24," there were clear formulas being used, which had to be part of the reason why they wanted to move the location - it had been set in Washington DC the day before (once again with President Allison Walker in the White House), and got moved to New York, and I'm sure that was all due to help offset the show's recognizable tropes. An amusing drinking game at the time was to take a shot every time Jack says "Damn it!"

No spoilers, but as it turned out, this wasn't the last day of "24." In fact, there were a couple more days to come, but not in NYC, so that's all I'll say. And one more thing: all seasons of "24" are currently available to watch on Hulu, in what could be the ultimate day-long binge.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Flatbush (1979)
5/10
NYC 400 - #316 - "Flatbush"
1 May 2024
This show is kind of like Frankenstein's monster. It takes a bit from here, something from there, blends it together, electrocutes it, and the final result is something horrible! Why would a show with that description rank so highly on this list? Come with me on a journey back to 1979.

Let's begin with the geography. Flatbush is a pretty famous location in Brooklyn. Some would say it's the beating heart of that borough. Flatbush was the neighborhood that housed Ebbets Field, the home of the Brooklyn Dodgers baseball team, until 1958, when they literally went Hollywood and left for Los Angeles.

Brooklyn and the 1950s sorta went hand in hand, as writer Stephen Verona told the tale of his teen years during that decade in a 1974 film called "The Lords of Flatbush," a kind of "where the day takes you" examination of a gang with the titular name, populated by young, unknown actors like Sylvester Stallone, Henry Winkler and before he got fired from the picture, Richard Gere, replaced by Perry King.

That "gang" element helped inform "Flatbush." But, within the same television moment that this program debuted, there was another group of guys in Brooklyn that had already captured the imagination of viewers: The so-called "Sweathogs," the hilariously remedial students featured on the sitcom, "Welcome Back, Kotter."

Our "Flatbush" group was already out of high school, but, like the Sweathogs, they were similarly a squad that stuck together, had fun, lamented the same things and were striving to succeed, each with their own unique personalities. And, this group of guys also had a memorable moniker: The Fungos. Let's meet them, shall we?

Joseph Cali plays Presto Prestopopolos, a neophyte cab driver. There's Adrian Zmed who plays Socks Palermo, a clothing store clerk. Vincent Bufano plays Turtle Romero, who worked in his family's Italian diner. Randy Stumpf plays Joey Dee (with no Starlighters) who makes a living as a plumber. And Sandy Helberg as Figgy Figueroa delivered items for a local supermarket.

It's just five honest guys, making an honest living and looking for some excitement and laughs wherever they could find some. Sure they were tools and goofballs, but they weren't hurting anybody.

The other element that came into play for this series related back to "Kotter," and that's John Travolta, who left that show (but didn't leave the borough), to play Tony Manero in the film "Saturday Night Fever." Silk jackets and feathered hairstyles were featured for the main cast members, as Disco was still ruling the day at this point and these guys were all about it.

New York played a part because it's Flatbush! Yes, we got a Greek guy in there, but the Italians were very well-represented. Maybe that was another part of the problem, and that's where we get to the "notable" part of the equation.

Howard Golden was a long time politician in NYC, who died in January 2024 at the age of 98. In fact he was Brooklyn Borough President for 25 years, including the year "Flatbush" hit the airwaves.

Boro President Golden actually issued an official statement saying that the stereotypes presented by the cast of this show were so offensive, he wanted the program to be pulled from the network! I can't help but think of 399's "Amos 'n' Andy" when I hear this complaint, but anyhow, the point is, a real-life politician chimed in on this sitcom and the elements presented and demanded it be removed as it reflected badly on the neighborhood and the people in it.

Shortly after that public statement, it was! The show got yanked from the CBS schedule after the third episode aired. I'm not certain if the show was canceled specifically because of that proclamation, if the questionable writing and low ratings would have doomed it anyway, of if Golden just saw a political football and ran with it, but it is an historic element. In a way, it's right up there with Vice President Dan Quayle's criticism of "Murphy Brown," which didn't work out nearly as well for Quayle as this did for Golden.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Nurse (1981–1982)
NYC 400 - #317 - "Nurse"
1 May 2024
Actors often want the challenge of "playing against type." That is, playing a role you wouldn't expect, based on the roles, or real-life personality, that they were known for. We get a two-fer with this show.

Michael Learned is an actress most associated with a show called "The Waltons," a gentle drama about a very large family that lived in a sprawling house in a very rural place during The Great Depression. Ms. Learned was the Matriarch of the Walton family.

Here, she's Mary Benjamin, supportive wife to her doctor husband, doting mom to her only child Chip, and a former nurse.

Robert Reed was an actor most associated with a series of contemporary programs, from the 1960s through the 1980s, of differing genres (sitcom, variety, drama) with the word "Brady" in the title. Mr. Reed was the patriarch of the Brady family.

Here, he's Adam Rose, one of the top MDs on staff at Grant Memorial Hospital in New York.

In each of these cases, these two actors' previous roles were warm, charming, considerate and kind, as were the personas of the actors playing those roles, themselves. And that's a 180 to who the two lead characters of "Nurse" were all about.

This show is also notable because it began as a TV movie with a script written by Sue Grafton. If that name sounds an alarm, it's because Ms. Grafton eventually became known as a novelist who wrote detective stories with a female lead character named Kinsey Millhone... the famed "Alphabet Series" of novels. ("A is for Alibi," "B is for Burglar," etc.) This was one of Grafton's final TV movies before her career as a novelist finally took off.

The plot of the pilot was that while on vacation, Mary's husband dropped dead playing tennis with their son (that has to be worthy of some therapy, for Chip), and mom was also right nearby, to attempt some chest compressions and perform mouth to mouth one last time. The son was about to head off to college so, that's an instant empty nest for Mary, in her hollow suburban home.

Mary does the only thing she can do: something. She decides to apply for a job at the old digs and gets the high profile assignment of head nurse in Dr. Rose's ward.

Hubby kept an apartment close to the hospital, so Mary trades her home in the suburbs for a walk up flat with all the haunting memories of her late spouse's life in the city. But at least she doesn't have to take the subway to work.

And then there's Dr. Rose. This guy is a perfectionist, a constant critic, an impatient jerk who has to say something nasty about anything he sees that isn't to his liking. This rubs Mary just the wrong way, who, as you can understand, is a bit out of sorts from some personal issues going on in her life. That turns Mary into a tiger.

Let's clarify a point. Sue Grafton wrote the original pilot, so she is listed with a "Created By" credit for the series, however she never wrote another episode after that TV movie, so the melodramatic elements of scripts involving suicide, drugs and other sensational plots were not her responsibility.

New York plays a part because the demands of the city, the needs of the patients, the level of competence and the importance of everyone's role in the action were on display, with personality conflicts sometimes in the way. Everyone needs to stay professional and do their jobs, even as they find some other person is screwing everything up.

Also the elements of the high cost of living (the rent was too damn high, even in 1981!) and an episode where the nurses go on strike made statements about how health care professionals were getting treated by the system, throughout history.

Seeing Learned and Reed doing these roles would be interesting for fans of their better known work, but I don't know that audiences wanted to embrace these characters the way they did when these two actors appeared on "The Waltons" and "The Brady Bunch," respectively.

If there is any single takeaway about "Nurse" it's that New York City can change you!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
N.Y.P.D. (1967–1969)
7/10
NYC 400 - #318 - "N. Y. P. D."
1 May 2024
There are quite a few depictions of the New York City Police Department and some of the individual members of that organization on this list of The 400 Most Notable TV Shows Set in New York City. Let's face it, cop shows are ideal for television... it's often life or death, it's action, it's adventure, it's good versus bad and it takes place in an area you might have visited on your way around this here town.

"N. Y. P. D." was kind of the heir apparent to another program on this list: 346's "East Side West Side." David Susskind was one of the producers of both series and they each featured the gritty realism, the tensions and the issues that actual New Yorkers were facing at the times of their broadcasts.

Granted, "East Side West Side" aired in 1963 and dealt mostly with social work, so the criminal element was not as frequent, but that program put Black Americans out front where the whole nation could see them as part of our society, and this show, likewise, displayed the full range of the population of 1967 New York, making it another groundbreaking series for TV.

Interestingly, where "East Side West Side" was an hour long program, this was a thirty minute affair, packing twice the action into half the time. Jack Warden played Lieutenant Mike Haines, and his two prime detectives were Jeff Ward, played by Robert Hooks and Johnny Corso, played by Frank Converse.

New York played a part because Susskind and his fellow producers worked with the department depicted, as they did in that previous series, and used actual cases as the starting point for their drama. And because the characters were detectives, they covered crime throughout the city, so you got to see a lot of realistic portrayals of circumstances NYC citizens were facing, all over town.

Because of the show's time constraints, there wasn't a lot of time for pleasantries, off the cuff humor or even a run to the local Chock Full o' Nuts for a powdered donut and a coffee. This was a show about the facts, about the crime and about serving justice and there were fistfights, shootouts, and arrests galore.

To its credit, "N. Y. P. D."'s Lt. Haines didn't treat Detective Ward any differently than Detective Corso, which was another element that was important for audiences of the day to see. Both the Black officer and the White officer were handled exactly the same, with the same respect, same acknowledgement and the same care. Remember, this is 1967.

This program was also one of the first network shows to feature African American writers, including Lonnie Elder, who would eventually receive an Academy Award nomination for his adaptation of the book "Sounder" for the screen, the first ever Black nominee in that category.

Just like "East Side West Side," this program attracted some powerhouse actors to perform, and a brief listing of performers who appeared included Al Pacino, James Earl Jones, Blythe Danner, Donna McKechnie, Harvey Keitel, Ossie Davis, and a laundry list of others, many of whom were unknown during their appearance here, who have gone on to incredible fame and success.

I think the reason why this series isn't seen anymore is also why most police procedurals don't have a very long shelf life. The style of the show was meant for the time that it originally aired. Now, these stories seem overwrought and the action just wouldn't be believed by a viewer, today. At the time, there was a much bigger sense that police vigilantism was something to be appreciated for the sake of protecting the streets, but, in 2024, those are things that might get a cop brought up on charges themselves, in our world of bodycams and officer responsibility.

The series also included one of the most iconic images of any from that era: The rooftop shot of a police car, red siren light twirling, as it raced down Broadway towards Times Square, during the show's opening titles.

Classic.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
NYC 400 - #319 - "How to Marry a Millionaire"
1 May 2024
Warning: Spoilers
"How to Marry a Millionaire" began life as a play by Zoe Atkins called, The Greeks Had a Word for It. Several movies were made based on it, including "Three Broadway Girls." But this sitcom's most direct ancestor was the Cinemascope motion picture of the same name, starring Betty Grable, Lauren Bacall and Marilyn Monroe, released in 1953.

The story of this small screen adaptation of that film is simple. Three twentysomething women: Greta Hanson (played by Lori Nelson in Season One of the series - replaced by Gwen Kirby played by Lisa Gaye in Season Two), "Mike" McCall (played by Merry Anders), and Loco Jones (played by Barbara Eden) are intelligent, friendly, capable and determined, and, who frankly have very expensive taste for the late 1950s, are each seeking their method of succeeding: finding a millionaire to wed.

To accomplish this challenging task, they decided to pool their money and resources and rent a swank penthouse apartment (pictured in exterior shots as being located just off Columbus Circle, on Central Park South) so they can appear affluent themselves, and attract the kind of wealth their budgetary demands required.

Of course, putting up this front is expensive itself, and the three women were constantly having monetary issues of their own, either making the rent on this fabulous apartment, covering the cost of their designer label wardrobe from every department store in town, or being able to afford food for their usually empty pantry, despite the fact that they all made a decent living and would probably have succeeded in their own careers if they weren't so intent on this scheme.

Each episode of the program began with an unseen male announcer, describing, very much like the announcer would narrate for the show "Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous" three decades later, some fantastic location as seen on the screen, like the French Riviera or Miami Beach or a luxury item like an expensive yacht or automobile that only someone with great wealth could afford. The narration is interrupted by a woman's voice who states that there IS another way to afford it. You can marry it, which immediately lead to the show's opening titles.

Barbara Eden became something of the breakout star of the series, her first regular role on a television show, primarily because Loco was myopic and needed to wear glasses to see properly, but never wanted to be seen wearing them by her suitors, so she frequently removed them and then had the issues of bumping into the furniture or in some cases, other men, along the way. Eden's physical comedy and sprightly delivery as the most sweet and innocent of the three ladies of the program made her a favorite. In fact, in the second season of the show, Barbara was elevated from being listed third in the credits to first.

New York played a part because there were no end of potential candidates for the women to attempt, there was no end of their hand-to-mouth existence (of all things! Their "impoverished wealth!") because they were constantly on the edge of eviction as they would manipulate their finances to try to finagle their way around paying one bill this week and paying another, the next.

Though there was a potentially gauche element to the concept, especially for that era, there also was a kind of collective strength these women were displaying. They were doing all of this without any help, other than the support they gave each other, kind of the first mainstream example of "Girl Power" on the small screen!

Clearly this wasn't really a "How to" instructional, but much more a cautionary tale against trying this method! In some ways it was a precursor for the Road Runner cartoons (albeit those were produced by Warner Bros. And this was a 20th Century Fox production). All the time, effort and money Wile E. Coyote poured into catching that Road Runner never seemed to pay off.

But even that wasn't true in this scenario, as original castmember Lori Nelson's character allegedly succeeded in marrying a Gas Station owner and moved out west, which explained the need for a new roommate, as actress Lisa Gaye joined the show.

Maybe the message was: anything CAN happen in New York!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Bull (2000–2001)
8/10
NYC 400 - #320 - "Bull" (2000)
1 May 2024
Sometimes the notable thing about a show isn't the show at all. This is one of the most glaring examples of that. And this is another show with the same title as a different show on this list of The 400 Most Notable TV Shows Set in New York City.

Many people know the term "Bull Market" as it relates to business. It's Wall Street lingo for how well Stocks are doing. Bull Markets are charging ahead, with investors buying up stocks, the Dow Jones Industrial Average rising and lots of money to be made because there's lots of confidence in how everything is progressing.

That is the world of "Bull," where this particular team of investment bankers are working to start their own firm, and intend to do it by breaking away from the institution that gave them the space and the skills to become proficient.

Leading the charge is George Newbern (who appeared on this NYC 400 list as part of the cast of #361's sitcom, "Working Girl"). Here, Newbern plays Robert Roberts III, who intends to shatter his family business, run by Granddad Robert Roberts (Donald Moffat) and Father Robert Roberts II (Ryan O'Neal) so he can finally escape the shadow he's been living under his whole life.

There was definitely some of the flavor of those old-time 1980s Nighttime Soaps like "Dallas" and "Dynasty" with the struggle for power within a family, the ensemble of players trying to gain the upper hand and the betrayal of family blood for the potential for big money.

Robert the Third intended to poach the team of staffers to help him accomplish his goal of independent success. And everyone agrees to go along because they all have their own personal motivations for wanting a new beginning.

But how can this upstart bunch of start ups make the grade? They can't use the clients from their current bank, and they don't have any means to allow them to attract big supporters, just based on their reputations (or complete lack thereof).

Enter Hunter Lasky, played by Stanley Tucci (who we last saw at 379's "3 lbs"), a hyper-driven investment lawyer that maybe can drum up, fabricate or simply smoke-and-mirror this new firm into being the hottest thing on the Street since NASDAQ got formed and turned everything upside-down.

In fact, March 10, 2000 was the high water mark for the so-called dot com marketplace at the time.

New York plays a part because there's no more cutthroat business area on the planet than Wall Street, and there's nobody who knows more about how the market works than those that work the market. It is the seat of all business for the nation and there really is no other place a show like this could have been set.

Also notable is that this program was the first ever original series produced by TNT, then known as Turner Network Television, which had been running the catalog of classic films that Ted Turner acquired the rights to show prior to branching out into other forms of entertainment.

But the most notable thing about the series is that shortly after it began, the Stock Market had its "Dot Com Bubble" burst, and Wall Street took a free fall into a "Bear Market." Suddenly, nearly within days or even hours, companies that looked valuable on paper became as worthless as paper. It was a huge readjustment in the marketplace and it ended the speculative reach of most players on the scene.

As such, "Bull," this 2000 series, came to an abrupt, and very memorable, end... with nothing to do because of the show itself, but everything to do with how reality changed around it.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Thorns (1988– )
8/10
NYC 400 - #321 - "The Thorns"
1 May 2024
At this point in history, 1988, we're at the end of Ronald Reagan's second term. We've been through the Yuppies and the Nouveau Riche, the "Lifestyles of the Rich & Famous" is a guilty pleasure watch, and we have all of the meaning that those things represented. Being wealthy, mattered. And this show brought that point home in an enormous and at times, ugly way.

Let's start with the theme song, which was sung by Broadway Diva Dorothy Loudon, performing the song in a nightclub setting for an audience of attentive patrons in the program's opening credits. The reason why it sounds like a lost track from the classic musical, Cabaret, is because it was written by John Kander and Fred Ebb. Dorothy croons:

We've millions of unemployed/and beggars you can't avoid/It's pitiful, dear/but WE'RE alright.

That perfectly sets the tone for this story about the titular couple, Sloan and Ginger Thorn, played by Tony Roberts and Kelly Bishop. The Thorns are opportunists, social climbers and are intent on inserting themselves into The Social Register in any way they can. Forget about "the little people." The Thorns want to be Big Wheels, and are willing to do whatever it takes. Of course, Sloan is doing the ideal job for all of that: he runs a PR firm.

The Thorns have a staff... a maid, who happens to be French, Toinette (pronounced like "Antoinette," without the "An"), played by long time character actress and Tony Award winner Mary Louise Wilson, Their lively babysitter Cricket, played by Lori Petty, takes care of their three kids (since Mom and Dad can't be bothered): Chad (Adam Biesk), Joey (Lisa Rieffel) and Edmund (Jesse L. Tendler).

Mrs. Thorn's case of affluenza is SO acute, she's trying to get in good with a certain Mrs. Hamilton, the second richest woman in America, hoping to join various organizations, like the "Betsy Ross Society," so she can have the credentials of Old Wealth. She uses Peggy, Mrs. Hamilton's maid, and Toinette's friend, played by Maureen Stapleton, to try to find out some facts about Peggy's reclusive boss, whom she has never met nor seen.

But the surprise is that Peggy is, in fact, Mrs. Hamilton, who has been keeping an eye on these parvenus, even as she helps them out, occasionally. It's just another stumbling block on the road to the top for The Thorns!

New York played a part because this is the place where the most elite of Americans exist, and though they might have summer houses in The Hamptons, or Hilton Head, or they might winter in Boca or Cabo, it's always about New York - Park Avenue, Fifth Avenue, Central Park West, and the pre-war buildings, mansions and sky-high duplexes that are the level of success being sought.

It's also worth mentioning that this show was exec produced by Mike Nichols, and was co-created by Allan Leicht, who was a big contributor to another show we've referenced several times on this list, "Kate & Allie." I don't mean to say that "K&A" is some kind of hub for all NYC shows, but it just happens that people that worked on that program also worked on many of these other shows set in New York... and that makes sense because they have the knowledge and experience to give the flavor of the city to these programs.

Maybe the element of this show that doomed it was the fact that The Thorns put this kind of selfish, opportunistic, "Me First" behavior front and center for the wealthy, and doesn't that make the potential working class viewers understand what's really going on with these supposed genial and caring well-to-do types? I would say a show like this should be on the screen now, except I know it would do as well today as it did during the Eighties, and would probably get pulled as quickly as possible from whatever network was showing it as it did, back then.

We can't be too critical of the rich (and of those that aspire to be).
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Associates (1979–1980)
8/10
NYC 400 - #322 - "The Associates" (1979)
1 May 2024
It was 1979. The Alphabet Network was coming off of a critical and commercially successful season, including a new show by one of the creators of "Mary Tyler Moore," James L. Brooks. That program was called "Taxi," and that show, like this one, is on the list of The 400 Most Notable TV Shows Set in New York City. Brooks was responsible for this ensemble piece, and it had all of the elements of a classic Brooks comedy and another tremendous hit.

We have a show with a title that was eventually duplicated. THIS version of "The Associates" was about a group of three brand new lawyers, hired by a Wall Street area firm to help research and try their cases. Tucker Kerwin was played by Martin Short (who appeared on this list at 359's "Mulaney" ), Leslie Dunn was played by Alley Mills and Sara James was played by Shelley Smith.

Tucker was an idealist, who always took the side of the underdog, and the side of what was morally right. That typically ran in direct counterpoint to the cases the firm, headed by Emerson Marshall, as played by Wilfrid Hyde-White, were handling, as their clients were faceless corporations or super wealthy clients.

Right away, we have some really interesting subtextural storylines happening as the facts of being a lawyer and representing a client because they hired you to do that job can challenge your personal belief system.

Another interesting dynamic is the triangle created with the three associates, as Leslie was somewhat sweet on Tucker, while Tucker (and, essentially all the men depicted in this series) were focused on Sara. That included the clerk for the firm, Johnny Danko, played with 70s Disco Lounge Lizard style by Tim Thomerson.

What's great is that James L. Brooks always fostered incredibly strong and intelligent female characters and the chauvinistic Johnny was continually put in his place by Sara, even as he tried to make a move on her.

All of the associates butted heads with the brand new promoted partner in the firm, Eliot Streeter, played by Joe Regalbuto. He was a by the book sort but was also the biggest brownnose to Emerson Marshall, which also explains how he got the job.

Mr. Hyde-White was his own walking-talking sitcom, with his Brit accent, his hilariously long-winded stories and his distractions, mannerisms and affectations. He probably could have done a soliloquy and been an hilarious triumph!

Martin Short was about to explode and there were some hints about it here, though nothing as broad as we would see when he eventually joined the cast of "SCTV" (which was already running in syndication at the time). And Alley Mills was pleasant, poised and firm when she was right, slightly reminiscent of Mary Richards, in that way.

New York played a part because these cases were related to big names, both companies and individuals that were situated in The City, and they challenged the team with those topics. And the program's theme song, performed by Jazz legend B. B. King, was "Wall Street Blues," a reference to the neighborhood where the law firm was located.

It seemed like ABC didn't really know what to do with this program, and that's all to do with the network execs running things at the time. A show this smart, this funny, that even had some elements of slapstick and farce included, along with that brilliant scripting, maybe was too much for them to handle. They pulled it from the schedule, re-inserted it some weeks later, then finally killed the show at the end of the season, despite the continual high praise from critics.

But remember, about the same time, ABC eventually canceled "Taxi," only to have it be snapped up by NBC and have that series become the start of their comedy success on Thursday nights.

Sometimes it's not the show, it's the suits.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Practice (1976–1977)
7/10
NYC 400 - #323 - "The Practice" (1976)
1 May 2024
I'm sure that if you asked a TV Historian about a series called "The Practice," they would first think of a David E. Kelley dramatic series, set in Boston, about a group of lawyers trying difficult cases, including one that crossed over with another Kelley series, also set in Beantown, "Ally McBeal."

That has nothing to do with this.

Predating Kelley's identically titled law show by twenty years, this program was a sitcom about a New York Doctor named Jules Bedford, played by Danny Thomas, and the people that populated his work and home life.

Jules was the sort of "gruff but loveable" character every show of the era wanted. He was knowledgeable, temperamental, witty and continually chomped a cigar, but only sometimes smoked it. His signature style was based on Mr. Thomas' own Catskills club, Borscht Belt stand up rhythm. Example:

Nate: (head waiter in the hospital cafeteria): My thumb. (Nate flexes his thumb in front of Jules' face) It hurts every time I do that.

Jules: Then, don't do that.

The only thing missing was a drum riff after a joke. Ba-dum-ting!

The work squad was comprised of Dr. Bedford's nurse, Molly, played by long time great character actress, Dena Dietrich, and his receptionist Helen, played with Gracie Allen style bubbleheadedness, by soon-to-be beauty school drop out from the motion picture "Grease," Didi Conn. Also helping out was Lenny, an intern at The Practice, played by the better known of the two Lionel Jeffersons from that Norman Lear series, Mike Evans.

Also practicing medicine was Dr. David Bedford, Jules' son, played by David Spielberg, who had a fancy Park Avenue shingle. The two Bedford doctors would share stories about their cases and commiserate about the patients they had to deal with over lunch in the cafeteria where Dad worked, but would also be derisive about their practices, as the younger Bedford catered to a wealthy clientele and the elder Bedford treated "regular people." There definitely were some value judgments when it came to that. Also, the son and the father provided further fodder for funny, as Jules still treated his kid like a child, and David sulkily reminded Dad that he was a full grown adult.

David's wife Jenny was played by Shelley Fabares, who of course grew up on television as the daughter on the long running "The Donna Reed Show." David and Jenny provided Jules with his two grandsons, Paul and Tony, played by Allen Price and Damon Bradley Raskin.

New York played a part because there are a lot of sick people in this town (though some of them are hypochondriacs), and with Dr. Jules still making house calls, there were plenty of places for him to go to check up on patients.

Let's also note this show was created by Steve Gordon who, several years later, would also write and direct "Arthur," the film starring Dudley Moore (who made this NYC 400 list at #377 with "Dudley").

There was an interesting blending of that old style comedy that Mr. Thomas was used to (and likely personally injected into the scripts), and the more modern elements that were starting to happen for sitcoms as we approached the 1980s.

And from the Old School, Danny's friends dropped in for guest shots, people like Lucille Ball, Jayne Meadows, his own daughter Marlo Thomas and Bill Dana (though not playing José Jiménez, as Dana did on "The Danny Thomas Show").

And we can't talk about Danny Thomas and medicine without noting his philanthropy work and how he founded the St. Jude Children's Medical Research Center, which is inarguably his biggest legacy, still going strong today. The concept of helping out families of kids who were going through some devastating medical issues and making sure those families didn't have to pay the costs of treatment and rehabilitation was both genius and needed.

"The Practice" (1976) maybe would have worked better as a brief sketch on a variety series, because it had that sort of off-kilter, cheap joke, go for the laugh sensibility, that had been seen on shows like "Sonny and Cher" and "The Carol Burnett Show" where the premise mattered less than the funny. If they had pulled out all the stops and made it into a complete farce, it definitely would have been a more memorable sitcom.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Here and Now (1992–1993)
7/10
NYC 400 - #324 - "Here and Now"
1 May 2024
"The Cosby Show" already had a spinoff during its run: "A Different World" followed Denise Huxtable (Lisa Bonet) to an HBCU for some higher learning, where she met classmates, and forged friendships (including a character played by Marisa Tomei).

After Ms. Bonet announced she was going to have what turned out to be her Nepo Baby, Zoe, with her then partner, Lenny Kravitz, the decision was made to pull Denise out of "A Different World" because a Huxtable as an unwed mother on campus just wasn't a good look, according to executive producer Bill Cosby, and that's all I'll say about that topic, for now.

When "The Cosby Show" was winding down, there was a discussion of having a spinoff series with Theo, the Huxtable son, played by Malcolm-Jamal Warner. Mr. Warner really didn't want to keep playing Theo, and though he was interested in continuing to work, he wanted a different character with different challenges to expand his horizons and maybe challenge his acting chops. That set up this series.

Alexander James, the lead in "Here and Now" was working on his masters degree at Columbia University and majored in Psychology. Theo majored in Psychology as a college student. "A. J." as the character in this series was often called, worked at a Youth Center in Harlem. Theo also worked at a youth center. Both characters had that glib sensibility and the comic wit you'd expect from a sitcom star. So, even though it wasn't a spinoff, at heart, it really was.

Mr. Warner played A. J. a little bit hipper, a bit more street and a lot more controlled and suave than Theo, and really tried to make this character as different from his previous role as he could.

For some reason, despite the setting of Harlem for this show, the theme song chosen for the program was Arrested Development's hit single "Tennessee." The show's focus was on A. J. and his studies, his dating life and his work with the kids at the Youth Center, a bunch of boys that were as energetic and comedic as you might have hoped.

Also playing a part were a company of great actors: Charles Brown played A. J.'s "Uncle" Sydney (not an actual blood relative), who let the student stay in his apartment while he was earning his M. A., S. Epatha Merkerson who ran the youth center A. J. worked at, Daryl "Chill" Mitchell, who was another counselor at the center, and Rachael Crawford as Danielle, Sydney's daughter, who had a constant undercurrent of a love/hate relationship with A. J. as they shared the same living space.

New York played a part because there's always a need for good counselors for kids, especially in fringe neighborhoods, and there's always issues that need to be faced in a city, plus the challenges of attending an Ivy League school and the constant psychoanalysis of NYC residents were all elements that were direct to the storylines.

Perhaps this would have worked better if it were an actual spinoff with Theo Huxtable. With the focus on the community center, some of the suits at NBC weren't finding the concept as funny as they had hoped it would be. And one of the choices made was to place the show, not on the expected Thursday night time slot that "The Cosby Show" relinquished the season before. Instead, the network scheduled "Here and Now" on Saturdays at 8pm ET.

In case there was any doubt about NBC's lack of interest in this show, when the series that took "The Cosby Show'" timeslot flopped, they didn't belatedly move "Here and Now" to Thursday at 8pm ET... they moved THAT show to right after "Here and Now" on Saturday! "Here and Now" was a case of a network sandbagging a series, turning what might have been a hit show into a trivia question.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Jim Gaffigan Show (2015–2016)
8/10
NYC 400 - #325 - "The Jim Gaffigan Show"
1 May 2024
"Jim Gaffigan" has already been on this list of The 400 Most Notable Television Shows Set in New York City. He was an Indiana weatherman on a New York based morning show with Christine Baranski as his producer, Sara Gilbert as her assistant and Rocky Carroll standing in for Bryant Gumbel on "Welcome to New York," back at 389.

We're still dealing with "Jim Gaffigan," only one that's a whole lot more seasoned, this time around.

We've turned the clock forward fifteen years from that initial sitcom, where, back in Y2K, fresh faced Jim was basically doing the David Letterman story, despite the fact that he too was from Indiana and was a stand-up comic, just like Dave. Jim was just too green to insert his influences and ideas that might have helped "Welcome to New York" work better, be more about him and be more funny.

This time, we're letting Gaffigan be Gaffigan, as this sitcom was completely based on his own real life circumstances: his stand up routines were the basis of the plots of these episodes, and his homelife actually paralleled the genuine article, as Jim and his wife Jeannie (played here by Ashley Williams) really did have five kids and actually lived in a two bedroom apartment in Manhattan as they were getting started.

With his real life wife as a consultant (she was originally going to play herself in the series, but bowed out at the last moment which allowed Williams to take the part), they told the factual tales of having this gaggle of kids in a too small for their family apartment and how they attempted to make things work, ever so comedically.

Helping out was Jim's best friend, adviser and fellow comic Dave Marks, played by Adam Goldberg... and Jeannie's former beau, who eventually realized that he was gay, Daniel Benjamin, played by Michael Ian Black. And, of course, the five reasons why this all got so crazy, the five kids.

Also, spoiler alert: turning up along the way are a variety of real-life comics and TV personalities. I won't go into the details, in case you want to view the program yourself, but there is a running gag with a particular personality that is always pretty amusing.

I don't mean to call in Dr. Freud, but Mr. Gaffigan is seen in a lot of scenes, eating something. Oral fixative elements aside, it helps explain why the Jim Gaffigan of this show is putting on the L. Bs, compared to the earlier Gaffigan. They are almost unrecognizable! But they do share that lilting voice, that wry approach to life and neither "Jim Gaffigan" wanted to deal with problems, even though problems are all they get.

New York played a part because of the comedy scene, the TV scene, and the Real Estate Market, where you're supposed to have at least two bedrooms for the kids, one for the boys and one for the girls: even pseudo-architect Mike Brady knew that! I wonder if this "Jim Gaffigan" is related to, or the same guy as that earlier "Jim Gaffigan" and how that might have informed this series. I'd like to believe there was a little truth to that possibility.

The show was made all the more absurd because of the five actual kids they have and the maneuvering and compromises the Gaffigans made throughout. Is it a cautionary tale or a "how to" program? Maybe it's both? Either way, it's a whole lot funnier than "Welcome to New York" was, and just that much more worth viewing.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Beautiful People (2005–2006)
7/10
NYC 400 - #326 - "Beautiful People"
1 May 2024
If you are living a life that is beautiful, things just have a way of working out. That's where we find a little family as this series begins.

The Kerrs - Mom, Lynne (Daphne Zuniga, veteran of "Melrose Place") her brainiac younger daughter Sophie (Sarah Foret), and Sophie's lovely and popular eighteen year old sister Karen (Torrey DeVitto) were residing in a small town in New Mexico, when they ran into a problem. Dad decided to ditch his marriage and parental responsibilities to run off with Karen's bestie, leaving the three women to figure out what to do now that they're on their own.

Let me state that a different way: the father of this family abandoned them for his teenage daughter's best friend. That's devastating in several different ways all at once, but hey, let's not dwell on it.

In better news, Sophie got accepted for a scholarship to an elite school for gifted students in New York. These Kerrs needed to get out of town anyhow, but this meant that Karen suddenly had an opportunity to go to New York to pursue her dream of being a fashion model. And that also meant that Lynne could finally see if her long deferred dream of becoming a designer might come true in The Big Apple!

When you're three fish out of some backwater New Mexico town and are hitting the biggest spotlight in the nation, of course there are going to be problems. The first is finding work. I mean, sure, there's a decent alimony settlement, but it's New York in 2005. Both Lynne and Karen need to get jobs to cover their costs as they move toward their eventual fashion goals. And Karen, in her haste to get in good with the people who can help her, might be sliding into a lifestyle that isn't so healthy, like needing to diet to lose weight, and taking drugs to help. See also, 373's "The Agency" for source material from an actual Model house that inspired that storyline.

Let's not forget younger Sophie, who though she loved the concept of this school on paper, suddenly sees the shortcomings of the personalities involved, most especially her classmates and their parents, who were elitist snobs and disparaging bullies. Those ugly cretins are, in fact, the "Beautiful People" of the show's title! How's THAT for a twist?

New York played a part because it's the super wealthy of the school board making demands of their kids and not letting Sophie in on their Reindeer Games that provide drama. One of Sophie's classmates, we're told, is from the family that owns the Empire State Building! And the ever-present fashion world is always an appropriate backdrop for any series set in NYC. Plus that more sinister world of nightlife, parties, clubbing, with controlled substances aplenty, that "low road" that many end up traversing, is continually is a threat.

But lets remember that ABC Family was where you could watch, so those threats were mostly exactly that. Also, there were so many women in this series, it was a real boon for actresses at the time, quite a bit like "Gilmore Girls" which was concurrently running with this show.

In the end, "Beautiful People" was perhaps just a little too light on the drama and not as much fun as it could have been, as they tried to shoehorn the soap opera elements into the plots and make things about those snobs at the school. Maybe this would have worked better with more comedy, like "Gilmore" displayed, since there were far more moments where a lighthearted tone would have fit better?

Conversely, a show like this one might have helped inspire (or at least gotten network execs to greenlight) a different drama with many of the same themes, that being, "Gossip Girl."
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Squirt TV on MTV (1996– )
8/10
NYC 400 - #327 - "Squirt TV on MTV"
1 May 2024
Public Access cable channels in the late 1980s through the 1990s were similar to what streaming services like YouTube, Instagram and Twitch are now, except they were only shown in your local area. You needed to live in a certain place to be able to go to your nearby cable TV provider, show your ID to verify your place of residence, then use their studio or hand them your videotape and let them show what you created at a time you selected on their schedule.

That's where we get started with this.

In 1989, "Saturday Night Live" cast members Mike Meyers and Dana Carvey threw on some wigs, dressed in tee shirts and jeans and did a sketch for the first time, that became a phenomenon. "Wayne's World" spawned a successful movie and a not quite as successful sequel, introduced the word "Schwing!" into the vernacular, revitalized the image of the AMC Pacer and turned the number one epic, Queen's "Bohemian Rhapsody," back into a hit, all over again. "Wayne's World," in case you didn't know, was the story of two teens in a basement doing one of those public access cable shows about stuff in and around their neighborhood of Aurora, Illinois.

Now, I don't know for a fact that this sketch was the influence for "Squirt TV," but it's hard to think otherwise. Some time after the second "Wayne's World" movie was in theaters, a kid named Jake Fogelnest got some camera equipment, set up a little TV studio in his bedroom and started making tapes shown on Manhattan Neighborhood Network. I'm not being cheeky when I say he was a kid. Jake was in 9th grade in 1994 when he started this project.

His basic cable show was mostly him riffing on the stuff he liked and didn't like either in his personal life or, as his popularity grew, entertainment stuff. He actually got stand up comic Gilbert Gottfried as a guest on this public access show, which suggested he had some legit show biz cred.

Jake had a style, a sense of humor and I don't know if his classmates were aware of what he was doing, but other kids his age were paying attention, because suddenly a bunch of high schoolers started doing shows on MNN, all about the same time as Jake's show, and all with that same "I'm bored with stuff" attitude that was so prevalent for that age group in the 1990s.

The difference here was, Jake actually had an agenda, actually had something to say and actually was pretty funny, which I guess is how MTV found him a couple of years later and took his little show from the no-budget low level thing he was doing to one of their standard shows... which was, essentially, the exact same no-budget, low level thing. Only, officially, they were calling it: "Squirt TV on MTV."

The biggest laugh of it was that the network intentionally changed as little as possible. The MTV version of the program was still being filmed in Jake's bedroom, although I think they got an interior designer to redo the space, upgraded some of the decorations and likely placed products in prominent locations to be seen during the telecast. And, they brought in some pretty cool guests from the era: I mean, Kevin Smith and Joey Lauren Adams, Liz Phair, Cibo Matto with Sean Lennon, The Fugees, members of The Kids In The Hall, members of Wu Tang Clan... it was a network talk show in a kid's bedroom... and frankly, Jake was getting better guests than David Letterman had when Dave first started on NBC!

And there was a sidekick - "Frankie" who would film segments at events around town, interview people on the street and sometimes try various fads that were happening for the camera all to provide more nonsensical content to amuse the viewer.

Jake was a kind of company shill also: he promoted MTV shows. But, he mercilessly roasted them as well - unashamedly skewering these other programs as the meaningless fluff they were, and would constantly point out the worst moments of those shows and play clips to prove his harsh criticism. How the MTV execs were okay with this, I'm not sure, but I guess it was the "there is no bad publicity" concept that allowed it.

Conversely, the guests on the show were treated like the visiting royalty they were, dropping into Jake's room like they were friends, hopping on his bed, checking out the digs and plugging their projects, as that was the point of their visit, for sure.

New York played a part because where else would a worldly teen even think to do a show out of their own bedroom (and did he even ask his parents for permission before he started)? And that attitude, the humor, the references and the top name guests he would eventually get were all NYC.

Depending on who you ask, the show ended either because his parents got sick of it, because Jake got a little too irresponsible when it came to taping episodes, or perhaps MTV had their fill of Jake's superstar attitude. Maybe it was all of the above? Still, the fact that some random teen did a local show from his room and then got a legitimate network program because of it is very notable, indeed!

In 2024, Mr. Fogelnest is a writer and (of course) a podcaster and he has a Patreon, if you want to see what he's doing and help support him. In some ways, it's just like his MTV days, only he's married and a dad, and doesn't have any suits from Viacom breathing down his neck, anymore.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
NYC 400 - #328 - "Best Friends Forever"
1 May 2024
The concept of "Best Friends Forever" is incredibly simple. Lennon Parham and Jessica St. Clair, the creators of the show (and both alums of improv comedy troupe, The Upright Citizens Brigade Theatre), play Lennon Walker and Jessica Black, two, obviously, best friends forever, who live on opposite sides of the country, after Jessica moved out of Brooklyn to start a life with her husband.

But when Jessica gets served divorce papers, it's Lennon to the rescue, insisting that her BFF move back to NYC and move in with her so they can help heal her heart. There's just one small snag: Lennon now has a live in boyfriend, Joe Foley (Folly?) played by Luka Jones.

Lennon's commitment to Jessica clearly supersedes her romantic relationship, but, you know, she doesn't not care for Joe... it's just that... Best Friends Forever! So most of the comedy is coming from the friction of how these two very different relationships wore on each other.

Joe is a video game creator and is often lazing around the house doing stuff that's more appropriate for a teen to do, which doesn't help things, since he seems to always be there at the wrong moment when Lennon and Jessica are working some things out. Lennon is bending over backwards for Jessica. And that definitely cuts into Lennon and Joe's lovey-dovey time. What are they to do, (that could be shown on a prime-time network sitcom)?

New York played a part because all of their friends, relations and relationships are floating around in this orbit, all of their habits and foibles and peccadilloes are related to the bars they go to, the restaurants they frequent, the people they run into and the ghosts of their past, including Jessica's ex, who has to turn up just to complicate things that much more.

It's also worth mentioning that the director of every episode of the series was famed child actor from "The Wonder Years," Fred Savage. His pedigree in comedy was well established by this time.

According to the Press Kit, the program also was influenced by another show: a particular episode of "Laverne & Shirley," a comedy about two friends who shared an apartment (but without one of their boyfriends living with them). While that may have been the case, the BFFs have a lot more seriousness to deal with in 2010s New York than that previous pair did in 1950s Milwaukee.

Don't get me wrong, there are definitely some funny circumstances that happen as a part of all of this, and there is some truth about the meaning of friendships and how the dynamic between a long-time, close as can be relationship pairs with a relatively newer romance, that's close enough to share a living space but isn't deep enough to reach that friend's bond.

In fact, this friendship went so deep that, when this series ended, Ms. Parham and Ms. St. Clair retooled the concept, relocated the show to nearby Connecticut and retitled it "Playing House" which ran for a couple of seasons longer on USA network, and even Mr. Savage returned and directed a couple of episodes of that one, too... but that wouldn't, doesn't and can't count for this list.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A Nero Wolfe Mystery (2001–2002)
8/10
NYC 400 - #329 - "A Nero Wolfe Mystery" (2001)
30 April 2024
At the turn of the millennium, a full twenty years after the first television incarnation of this character (and starring William Conrad), we had this newer, or should I say, older approach to the characters created by Rex Stout.

Timothy Hutton was all over this adaptation of the series, acting as producer and star, and even directing several episodes, himself. Hutton had a pedigree when it came to NYC detectives, as his dad, Jim Hutton, played the title role of "Ellery Queen."

It seemed like this version of the Wolfe story sought to correct all of the problems the 1981 series had. First, they went to the Rex Stout books and mined all of those plots. Every episode was adapted faithfully from the original text. But, why not? That was why the character became so beloved.

Next, they were truer to those characters. Nero Wolfe was clean shaven, unlike William Conrad in his 1980s persona. Maury Chaykin's Wolfe was brash, snooty, and didn't care what anyone thought of him, not even his assistant Archie, played by the aforementioned Hutton. And the style, the vernacular, the approach was as close to the books as they could make it.

Finally, this version was set as a period piece: with the action set during the mid-1950s, keeping the timing of the stories as close as possible to the writing of the source material. The authenticity was a sticking point for the program, and A&E spared no expense, with each episode having a million dollar budget.

Another element that was unique to this series was the use of a de facto repertory company of actors, playing the parts of the characters for that week's episode. Unlike most mystery series of this sort, which would have had various guest stars coming in for that script, there were a group of regular players that would rotate parts and embody different characters over a series of episodes. That helped with the chemistry of the actors, who worked well with each other throughout the run, and likely saved a lot on the already straining budget!

New York played a part because this was the authentic setting and style of the stories and Stout's work was never adapted better, at least not so far. And, of course, the focus on a wealthy guy with a brilliant mind in The City, the involvement of the FBI, who, lead by J. Edgar Hoover, was on the trail of surveilling just about every American citizen for any hint of Communistic tendencies at the time, and the continual crimes that are bound to happen when you have about seven million in the same space were all factors in the plots.

Much like 333's "100 Centre Street," A&E just didn't have the budget or the method to widely promote this series. Considering the capital they were putting into it, why didn't they figure out some way to let people know about it? Both "100 Centre" and this show, both from that same broadcast era, the early 2000s, deserved a whole lot better than they got. Had those shows appeared on HBO, which was becoming the go-to network for scripted entertainment at this point, they both might have been in the top 100, or maybe even higher. The quality was there, after all the scripts were by Rex Stout, the acting was impeccable, and the cinematography and authentic look brought by the crew of this show took you into and immersed you in that version of NYC.

I guess the next big mystery might be, who will be involved in the NEXT adaptation of Nero Wolfe?
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Nero Wolfe (1981)
6/10
NYC 400 - #330 - "Nero Wolfe" (1981)
30 April 2024
Nero Wolfe was an amateur detective character created by novelist Rex Stout in the 1930s and Stout continued to write novels, novellas and short stories featuring that character through 1975, four decades of stories.

Originally, the producers of this program wanted Orson Welles to be its star. That made sense because Welles fit the character like a glove. But Mr. Welles was too much of a Diva to be cast in the part and the demands he was going to put on the production would have skyrocketed their costs. So they went looking for another actor and came upon William Conrad.

There are two programs that TV historians would remember William Conrad for. The first is "The Adventures of Rocky and Bullwinkle," a low budget cartoon series that featured a flying squirrel that made jet engine noises and sonic booms while in the air and a moose who walked on hind legs, was often mentally challenged and who constantly needed Rocky's support. The narrator of that show was Conrad's distinctive voice.

The second would likely be "Cannon" (A Quinn Martin Production) where Conrad spent the better part of the 1970s playing the titular character, a private detective based in Los Angeles, a former cop out to solve cases before the LAPD could. It's interesting to note that during that series, Conrad packed on an additional 30 pounds from the start of the program to its conclusion.

Conrad, much like Welles, was a good fit. He had the body type, as Wolfe was, shall we say, a Stout man? Wolfe was a wealthy gent who lived in a brownstone on West 35th Street, according to the printed material, and he absolutely wanted to stay at home, tending to his orchids and being served fanciful dishes prepared by his chef, Fritz (George Voskovec).

Since Wolfe generally eschewed doing the legwork needed to solve the crime, his assistant Archie (Lee Horsley) handled the bulk of that. Between Archie and Nero, you had one nearly perfect P. I.

Oddly, though, most of the scripts for this adaptation were not taken from the Rex Stout stories (occasionally a title was used, but then the plot didn't fit or varied greatly from the original story), and many fans of the book series were disappointed in how that was being handled.

Another issue was that this Nero Wolfe was set in the contemporary 1980s, rather than any time between the Stout writings of 1934 to 1975. Fans were split on the concept of having Wolfe be a current detective. Some thought it helped modernize the character and make him more accessible. Others thought it was untrue to the spirit of the original plots and weren't happy with it.

New York played a part because it's a city filled with crimes that the New York Police Department just couldn't solve on their own. Inspector Cramer (Allan Miller) continually brought cases to Wolfe's doorstep, sometimes begging the detective for help solving the crime.

This version is lower ranked than the second because of the lack of reverence to the original novels, the style of the program was a little too similar to every other detective show of the era - it could have been "Cannon" only with a nicer wardrobe and setting - and the writers didn't showcase Wolfe's superior mind... he was supposed to have been the American Sherlock Holmes, whereas Conrad's portrayal was very run-of-the-mill.

The focus on the likeability of the character and the wide variance from the original writings helped to bring this show down, but also was NBC's choice to program the series opposite one of the hottest shows of the day, the CBS action adventure, "The Dukes of Hazzard."
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Working It Out (1990– )
6/10
NYC 400 - #331 - "Working It Out"
30 April 2024
On my list of the 400 Most Notable TV Shows Set in New York City, I posted "Amos 'n' Andy," (at #399), as a show that we, in the 21st Century, would find problematic for more than one reason.

Likewise, there are some performers that we, as viewers, would have a problem with because of things they have done. This is the first example of that, and we can't not talk about those elements, even though they don't relate to the program itself.

Let's begin with the show and the first question that must be asked: is this a kind of continuation of the sitcom "Kate & Allie?" "Working It Out" was created and directed by Bill Persky, who directed most, if not every episode of "K&A." And it stars Jane Curtin, the Allie of that previous series. Heck, even the show's theme song was written and performed by John Loeffler, the same musician that did the theme for "Kate & Allie."

This was 1990, and at the time, there was something called "The Learning Annex." That was a service that began in NYC and branched out to a lot of major American cities through this era: it was a free catalog that listed a wide array of classes that, for a reasonable fee, you could take to become proficient in, as a way of enhancing your life. It was those "Handbooks For Dummies" before they existed. The idea was for people to take classes in activities to develop a new hobby, get a new skill, maybe even start a new vocation. But the subtext of all of this was here's a chance to meet someone who shared at least one of your interests, whom you might find attractive and begin a relationship with them as part of the deal.

The concept was sound: You were in a class, purportedly to learn this activity, so the focus was on that, and if you happen to hit it off with a classmate, there was far less pressure than being on a "date." (For the record, The Learning Annex seems to have shuttered around 2017, though their website is somehow still partially available to examine in the Spring of 2024).

The 2020s version of this are those "Master Class" online seminars, where you can learn how to act from Natalie Portman, or how to play tennis from Serena Williams... but there's precious little interaction with anyone else, not even the instructors, aside from a message board where you can post and read comments about the course from your fellow students viewing it... No realistic dating opportunities, there!

But, back in the Nineties, our former Allie Lowell, Ms. Curtin, is Sarah who meets David, played by Stephen Collins, in a cooking class. Sure, we all can cook, but we can all cook a little better.

Sarah and David are both single parents and are both a whole lot reluctant about getting back into the relationship scene, based on their previous marriages. They get some advice (or kibbitzing) from their friends along the way and the kids have to have their say, too.

New York played a part because of all the things The City has to offer and all the ways you can avoid dealing with your feelings because there are so many other things you can do instead of figuring out what you really want when it comes to love.

I think the reason why this show didn't have the same level of success as its immediate predecessor is that it just didn't have an agenda that engaged as many viewers. Sure there are people who are reluctant to start dating after a messy split with a previous partner, but not everyone relates to that. Also, just a couple of years before, there was a similar series on Fox called "Duet," where they promised a "romance in real time" between the lead characters. But that's a slow go, and nobody really cared to watch that. This had a lot of those same elements.

And, let's be very clear: it's difficult to deal with the issue of Stephen Collins. He was recorded on an audio tape in 2013, talking about sexually abusing a minor. Then, in a People Magazine article in 2014, he admitted to molesting three different girls. Collins was never even charged, let alone faced a trial, because the Statute of Limitations had run out. However he has never worked in any form of show business, since.

A problematic actor's off screen behavior is a difficult one to deal with and I am the first to say that it absolutely does change how you view their work. The most popular series that Collins appeared in, "Seventh Heaven," is another show that simply isn't seen anymore because of those admissions.

But here's the thing. It is not fair to the series, to the other actors who appeared and to all of the creative effort by the professionals that made those shows to attempt to ignore or excise that program because of those circumstances. But it certainly pushes these titles lower than they might have otherwise been, especially when it means those programs are no longer readily available to view on any platform.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Leap of Faith (2002)
7/10
NYC 400 - #332 - "Leap of Faith"
30 April 2024
Sometimes a show can have every possible advantage and it still doesn't work. "Leap of Faith" is an example of that.

This sitcom was created by Jenny Bicks. She was a writer for "Sex and the City." That's kind of important and you'll understand why in a moment.

This show also landed the best possible half hour on the TV schedule, when it debuted: Thursday Night at 8:30pm ET. That was the time slot that immediately followed the highest rated show on television at that time: "Friends." The lineup of "Must See TV," as the Peacock billed it at the time, was unstoppable. Well...

This show was about Sarah Paulson's character, who decided to ditch her engagement (for no clear reason other than she wanted to see what would happen if she did) all for what life still had in store for her as she moved back into the dating scene with her pals. The name of the character is Faith, so you see the double meaning of the title.

The point of the show was to present an "SATC" environment but more "family friendly" for prime time broadcast network scheduling. Yet, they were still covering the same ground as that TV-MA series, with a whole lot of talk about sex (since they couldn't be seen having any on the National Broadcasting Company)!

Despite the "leap" being taken here, Faith seems oddly unsure of herself, questioning every decision and doubting her own best efforts. I guess the TV trope being played on here is the intellectual woman with the low emotional IQ. This was, at the time, being handled a whole lot better on Fox's "Ally McBeal" but as an additional flavor, it was just another thing to try and hook an audience for this program. Isn't that a cute character trait? Keep watching!

New York played a part because it's "The City" and everybody is on the lookout, on the make and ready to hook up. Unlike "Friends," there was a realistically diverse cast being represented here, though nobody played a stereotyped character. But everybody did talk in one-liners and standard sitcom jokey dialogue, which was a bit of a miss from the dialog on the HBO series this was trying to mimic. How did Ms. Bicks not give her characters something a bit more clever to talk about?

Really good cast, what with Lisa Edelstein, who likely would have missed "House, MD" if this had succeeded, Regina King, who was beginning to branch out into voiceover work, Tim Meadows, long time SNL player doing his occasional appearances in sitcoms at the time, and of course Ms. Paulson, who always does the best she can with the material she gets. Her next stop would be an even higher profile show: the all-star cast of Aaron Sorkin's return to episodic television after "The West Wing," "Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip," which I thankfully don't have to discuss for this list.

Some people enjoyed the toned down level of material presented here, while others thought it was trite, dull and derivative. The show actually got decent ratings, but "decent" is far from what was expected on NBC's biggest night of the week.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
100 Centre Street (2001–2002)
8/10
NYC 400 - #333 - "100 Centre Street"
30 April 2024
The justice system in our country is getting a pretty thorough examination in 2024, and the methods by which the scales tip for every citizen of the country that faces the law, is a topic of discussion among everybody at the time of New York's 400th anniversary year.

The address that serves as the title of this program, houses the Supreme Court and the main Criminal Court for the city and state of New York, one of a complex of courts and legal offices in Lower Manhattan.

We can't even start to talk about this series without noting that it was created by Sidney Lumet. Lumet's career seemed centered on New York from the very beginning. Starting as an actor in stage plays, Mr. Lumet then transitioned to film, becoming a writer and director and continually trying to capture the flavor and the facts of The City in every production he was involved with.

This was Mr. Lumet's attempt to give a true picture of Criminal Court in NYC, the people who work there and the people who come through the system. Lumet either directed or wrote the bulk of the episodes for the series.

Alan Arkin was Judge Joe Rifkind (with focus on those last four letters) - a kind and fair judge, not willing to overtly punish those that really don't deserve it. He had homespun wisdom, stories about his family, observations on NYC changes through his life and how that informed his rulings from the bench. He continually saw the good in people.

Paula Davicq was Assistant District Attorney Cynthia Bennington, continually locking horns with another judge in the courts, Attalah "Atilla the Hun" Sims, played by LaTanya Richardson. Their constant battles are the friction of non-fiction. If you were facing charges, you absolutely wanted to wind up in Judge Rifkind's, NOT Judge Sims' courtroom.

The balance of storylines and characters is what was so compelling about the program. These were characters that had depth, a backstory, personal lives and interests that related to who they were and what they did, and that is always a great way of hooking an audience, helping them care about those people. But the overarching element was the court itself, the cases and how the staff dealt with the docket. Is now a good time to mention that Margo Martindale turns up as a regular in this series? She was also an important cog in 334's "A Gifted Man."

New York played a part because nobody knew NYC like Sidney Lumet - his understanding of the geography and the economy, the various crimes that were likely to occur, the people doing them, the circumstances that created the need for justice and the humanity of treating people with respect and kindness was second to none. Apologies to Dick Wolf! And a lot of the time we were on the streets, witnesses to the events that brought these suspects into the titular building.

I have to think that if this show had aired on a major network and not basic cable A&E (which, I checked just now, and yes! The network still exists!) this might have had a longer run. There wasn't nearly enough promotion for the series, not nearly enough focus on the elements that might have attracted an audience and A&E chose to run the show at, of all times, Saturday Nights at 10pm ET! That's hardly fair for this kind of gritty, realistic show about crime and punishment and the New York people involved.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A Gifted Man (2011–2012)
7/10
NYC 400 - #334 - "A Gifted Man"
30 April 2024
A possible reason why so many films and TV shows are set in New York is the feeling that just about anything can happen here. And when you have that element working for you, it becomes a wide open canvas on which the characters in the story can play. This is an example of a program trying to be both realistic and fantastic all at the same time.

Patrick Wilson played Dr. Michael Holt, a quintessentially arrogant but renowned Manhattan neurosurgeon, whose practice was making money hand over fist because all of his patients had Blue Cross/Blue Shield coverage.

One night, he bumped into his ex-wife, Anna Paul, portrayed by Jennifer Ehle, who also happened to be a doctor, but a lot more down to earth: she ran a free clinic in Alphabet City. Michael and Anna instantly hit it off, just like old times, back in Alaska where they struggled when they were first married. So just when Holt thinks he might be rekindling things, he learns a horrible and bizarre truth: Anna died two weeks before he saw her that night.

The initial reaction was that Michael maybe should have a visit to the doctors on 379's "3 Lbs." and gotten a brain scan (if they could have done a crossover episode). In fact, he was seeing and connecting with the spirit of his former spouse and she had a bunch of stuff to share with him and some unfinished business of her own.

This changes everything for Dr. Holt who starts "taking meetings" with Dr. Paul, finding some empty room so he could talk to her about various elements of his job and about her former practice - it seems she left the Alphabet City patients in disarray and the staff needed access to her computer to make sense of some things. Some of the time, this is amusing as Holt is talking to himself as if he is speaking to another person. Other times it seems like the doctor is having a breakdown to the people around him.

Meanwhile, Julie Benz played Michael's sister Christina, who believes in the supernatural and is encouraging Michael to explore the factors involved in what he can see and how this is something that is both meant for him to be a part of and is proof of her philosophy. And it wouldn't hurt if Michael became less of a total jerk, with Anna's spiritual influence.

New York played a part in that classic "haves and have nots" way, with the wealthiest people who need medical help waltzing into Michael's gleaming hospital wing with every new medical device to help enhance or save their lives, and the people of the Lower East Side, barely able to cover their costs, struggling to get some doctoring for their health concerns at Anna's overcrowded clinic.

The always capable Margo Martindale played Michael's assistant and added some much needed gravitas and humor to the mix and Pablo Schreiber was a shaman Michael met, who worked part time at the Lower East Side clinic, and who helped Michael understand the elements of the spiritual, and was an ex of his sister.

Let's note the pedigree of the behind the scenes players on this series: Susannah Grant, who created the program, wrote the screenplay to Julia Roberts' Academy Award winning performance of "Erin Brockovich" and Jonathan Demme was one of the program's producers and directors.

I think it's difficult to have such an unsympathetic character at the center of a series. Yes, Dr. Holt is brilliant, but his bedside manner sucks and he treats his co-workers like meaningless underlings for the most part, even as he was learning to find his humanity again through his pro bono medical work. Maybe if he were a quicker study in human nature, more people would have been attracted to him, and to this show, which was, if you could stomach Dr. Holt, pretty good.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Married People (1990–1991)
7/10
NYC 400 - #335 - "Married People"
30 April 2024
There are certain dividing lines in New York City that clearly split neighborhoods. In fact, there was a song from the soundtrack of a "Blaxploitation" film, sung by Bobby Womack called "Across 110th Street," with the area north of it being Harlem.

But that was the title song of a film from the 1970s. Turn the clock forward to 1990, and you have this series: "Married People."

110th Street is right, as that was the setting for this sitcom about three couples sharing a brownstone. Nick and Olivia Williams (Ray Aranha and Barbara Montgomery) are the owners of the building and live on the first floor. Harlem was going through a "gentrification" period at the time, they bought and refurbished the brownstone and rented out the floors above.

Living on the second floor were Elizabeth and Russell Meyers (Bess Armstrong and Jay Thomas) who were somewhat unique for TV as she was the more successful of the two, being an attorney, and he was a freelance writer.

And on the top floor were the newlyweds, Cindy and Allen Campbell (Megan Gallivan and Chris Young) who worked out an arrangement where Allen attended college while Cindy supported them both by waiting tables at a local restaurant.

Really though, it wasn't called "110th Street" and it wasn't even referred to as "Cathedral Parkway." Here, the street was known as "Central Park North," which is technically true, as it is the northern border of the park, but New Yorkers never call it that... unless, of course, they are Real Estate Agents!

Nick was the main antagonist. He was gruff and grumpy and since he was the landlord, was the guy everybody went to when there was any problem. Olivia kept him from being too rough on everyone else and smoothed over any rough patches with her warm and sweet personality. Cindy and Allen were playful and learning what married life was all about with the give and take they had to use to get through those early years.

And we have a couple of actors we've already seen, making a return appearance to the list of the 400 Most Notable TV Shows Set In NYC: Bess Armstrong was in 381's "On Our Own," and Jay Thomas was in 355's "Love & War." There are just some actors that help bring the flavor of The City to a program and that is a crucial element in making a show a bit more realistic, and these two fit the bill, though an extra addition is Elizabeth's baby bump, as she and Russell are expecting their first child.

New York played a part because the community was, at that point in time, one of the more diverse in the city, as that somewhat controversial word, gentrification (which we could talk about at length, but that wouldn't be appropriate for a discussion about a comedy show!) brought people seeking affordable housing into particular parts of the city, and any property bordering Central Park, no matter where it was, was a good place to be.

"Married People" varied from week to week as the main plot focused on one of the couples, while the other two had some differing and amusing subplots to play off of the top storyline that week.

The program offered up some genuine laughs with these three diverse couples, their generational and class differences making them focus on separate elements, and played up a lot of the problems they faced, many of them specifically related to New York, but also the willingness of all of the couples to work together to find solutions to those difficulties... they started to seem a bit more like a family than random tenants sharing a building. That's pretty high praise, I think.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
C.P.W. (1995–1996)
7/10
NYC 400 - #336 - "Central Park West"/"CPW"
30 April 2024
For the widening landscape of television history, there are a few names that just keep turning up. Norman Lear, Carl Reiner and Garry Marshall have all already appeared in this list of the 400 Most Notable TV Shows Set in NYC. Here's another for that "multiple appearances" list: Darren Star.

Mr. Star had a surprise hit with "Beverly Hills, 90210" which followed the lives of a couple of teens from Minnesota who moved with their family to their new and fabulous SoCal Zip Code. He followed that up with an even more adult look at a geographically close area, when he examined the lives of the residents at an apartment complex located on "Melrose Place."

With those two shows concurrently running, Star was living up to his surname as far as the suits at Fox were concerned. Then came this.

"Central Park West," as it was originally known, focused on an industry closely associated with The City: Publishing.

Stephanie Wells (Mariel Hemingway) who created Body Magazine and turned that into a major success in the fitness world, and her husband, freelance writer Mark Merrill (Tom Verica) are the Brenda and Brandon of this series, moving from their peaceful digs in Seattle, because Stephanie landed the job as Editor-in-chief of Communique, a pop-culture magazine headquartered in the Flatiron Building.

The "Central Park West" of the title comes from the location of the new home of this couple, where the woman is far more successful than the man, and they have a duplex with spectacular Park views for three-thousand dollars a month ("a steal!" Stephanie tells her spouse in 1995). Meanwhile, that property in 2024 wouldn't rent for less than 25K a month, plus utilities.

Stephanie runs into a buzzsaw at work, dealing with Carrie Fairchild (Mädchen Amick) who gets an enormous salary for writing a column about the nightlife scene and who just happens to be the stepdaughter of the magazine's owner, Allen Rush (Ron Liebman). There is an immediate dislike between the two, which gets amped up as Carrie decides to wreck Stephanie's marriage by seducing Mark.

Apparently this runs in the family as Carrie's brother Peter Fairchild (John Barrowman) is also a libidinous sort, continually on the streets or in the sheets with some starlet or model, when he wasn't being a corporate lawyer. His barrister boss is sick of the "Page Six" publicity and wants him to tone down the mattress trampolining.

Nikki Sheridan (Michael Michele) can help Peter settle down? She's Peter's old friend and a gallery owner who is part of Carrie's beat for her column, and who inadvertently introduces him to Alex (Melissa Errico) who turns up at a Central Park softball game she arranged where Alex and Peter both have a "love at first sight" moment.

And Peter's pal Gil (Justin Lazard) is an investment banker who lost his girlfriend's entire bank account on a bad deal, and now she's out to get him back.

Carrie and Peter's mom, Allen's wife, is played by the stately Lauren Hutton, to add that air of regality that every nighttime soap needed. Meanwhile, Allen arranged for Mark to get a job teaching English at a prestigious prep school, just so he actually had something to do besides sitting in coffee shops trying to write his novel. But Mark implicitly understands that Allen, being on the School board, just pulled those strings so he could get wifey to edit his periodical and balks at the circumstances.

New York plays a part because it's everything: the downtown scene, the uptown style, the worlds of art, print and of course sex are all about everything that's going on. And the pressure of turning a profit on an issue of this monthly mag is important even back when people actually bought magazines, so this is a job.

What I believe went wrong was that the show drew in the same audience that loved Star's other two programs. However, "Central Park West" had the same sort of flavor as those 1980s nighttime soaps like "Dallas" and "Dynasty," and really "Berrenger's." That was a completely different tone from "90210" and "Melrose," and is a clear reason why they didn't capture that demographic.

CBS pulled the show and retooled it. Mariel Hemingway left the cast after that first season and Raquel Welch came in. The show went the other way and totally leaned into the concept of those 80s soaps at this point. Though, to try to stay hip, they sort of changed the name to "CPW." They still kept the full name of the show but mostly referred to it using the initials, maybe as a way of connecting to Star's other program which got reduced from its full name to that five digit number?

If you loved those previous nighttime soaps, you probably would have liked this one also, but the villainy wasn't nearly as earth-shattering and the passion wasn't nearly as steamy, which would have made sense for Darren Star's high school cast, but not so much for full grown adults in Manhattan.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
NYC 400 - #337 - "The Redd Foxx Show"
29 April 2024
The year was 1986. Comedian and actor Redd Foxx had a tremendous success with the Norman Lear series "Sanford and Son" and started getting offers to do other things, when that show wrapped. He tried a variety series which flopped. He returned to that earlier role in a continuation of his hit series, called "Sanford," but that didn't work and he even did some specials where he could do some of his "sanitized for television" stand up routines and some sketch comedy bits.

But this was a true return to a sitcom setting for Mr. Foxx. It was a departure from the Sanford character and from his stand up bits which was a different direction in his career, at that point.

Here, Redd Foxx played Al Hughes, the owner of a midtown diner with a newspaper kiosk attached to it. Helping run the joint was his counter waitress Diana, played by Rosanna DeSoto.

Al had a track record of helping underprivileged boys in the area by becoming an adoptive parent to those juvenile delinquents, and he had a lot of success for turning their lives around. So, when the local social worker insists that this next kid needs to find a home or would wind up in the lock up, Al agreed to meet.

It turns out that the new kid is a graffiti artist with some serious talent, played by Pamela Segall. But, based on the method of dress, the vocal intonations, the age and the look, Al believed that this was a boy, too.

Once Al found out that it wasn't Tony, it was Toni, of course a lot of the challenges (and the bulk of the humor) was based on the gender elements, as Al had never ministered to a girl before. But also, the laughs focused on the generational differences, the attitude and the energy between these two. There were a lot of different kinds of clashes going on at any given moment and they ranged from getting the newsstand set up for the day's customers and keeping the floors of the diner and the kitchen clean, to all the pop culture references dropped in, that someone of Al's advancing age likely never would have gotten.

Al was gruff, but he was a softee too, so he never really held the upper hand, but he did want things to go smoothly, so as long as they did (which they rarely did) he wasn't grousing or griping.

New York played a part because you had the yuppie businessmen off to their glass towers coming through, the rando tourists looking for a bite to eat on their way to various landmarks, college students with their mid-80s downtown style showing up and the threats of crime that Toni wanted to help resolve.

Ultimately, Toni left, without so much as a goodbye, off to subway tunnels unknown, presumably to paint some new murals? Or maybe she decided to use that unique voice of hers to give life to some animated characters? It's very unclear.

In place of Toni, Beverly Todd joined the cast as Al's ex wife, Felicia. She had Al's foster (and full grown) son Byron, played by an up and coming comic that went by the mononym, Sinbad.

The focus of the show changed drastically, the continual issues with Byron and Felicia involving themselves in Al's life may have been true to the situation, but they didn't add much comedy.

Ultimately the show didn't quite find the right chemistry to make it work and the abrupt changes in the cast didn't do it any favors.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

Recently Viewed