I generally enjoy the series, and it's never bothered me that it is unrealistic, but this is one of the worst defenses of a fortification ever seen on television.
At first, they wait outside the walls for the enemy to start killing them with massive volleys of arrows, for no reason at all. Both sides have two sighted people among them (an absurdly large advantage against an army of blind people), but the good guys make no real use of them. Their leaders keep yelling out to each other, giving away their position each time to "just check whether you're still alive". Smart.
They are inside a walled city, but instead of using that to their advantage, they just do nothing while they wait for the enemy to ram down the gate, and when that takes too long they literally open the door to invite their enemies to come fight them inside.
There they could at least still have the high ground, but instead of just raining arrows and spears at them from the sides along the inside of the walls where they can't easily be hit themselves, they have one bowman and three guys throwing spears from a position where they can readily be shot by a bunch of blind crossbowmen from beyond the gates, and the rest is all down in the trenches with the enemy where they can easily be picked off in melee combat.
At one point one of the sighted has the enemy leader in her crosshairs but doesn't shoot because her gf (who is with the enemy) is looking at her funny. The enemy also has two sighted people (who are apparently fine with fighting for people who want to burn them alive for having eyesight), but instead of making it a priority to render them harmless, they seem to ignore them altogether as one of them - a kid - leads a band of crossbowmen with somehow perfect blind aim based his on vague directions on a killing spree through the trenches, until about halfway through the battle when someone finally gets the bright idea to tackle the guy carrying him around. Then one of the two sighted takes himself out of the battle to hold his buddy's hand as he slowly dies (and for a good while after that) while the bad guys slaughter their people around them.
They hold back a large contingent of their forces and drive the enemy into a dead end where they are walking on ice (conveniently hidden from sight by the snow so that the one sighted person with them doesn't notice, of course), then they crack the ice with large rocks as they scurry up the walls on ropes. The obvious thing to do would've been to at that point use those reinforcements to attack from the rear, maybe with some sort of shield wall or something, and drive the enemy into the freezing water. Of course, they don't do that. The reinforcements are just kind of standing there, watching the spectacle unfold. Well, it's a good thing those guys showed up in the nick of time, otherwise who could've possibly lowered all those ropes!
I admit I am not well versed in strategy and tactics, especially for two blind armies fighting one another in a kind of pre-medieval-type setting, but most of these things are simple common sense. It annoys me that they have such an interesting concept and they still can't do anything more interesting with it than "they walk around using their swords as canes, and they snap their fingers, because they're *blind* you see".
Instead maybe show how such a world might really work, like maybe it would be interesting if they did *not* have perfect aim - because, yaknow, they're blind - and they had to cleverly adapt to that, and they used this as a battle tactic by quietly luring the enemy into various traps that would not work on sighted people. Just have the writers put some minimal effort into not insulting the intelligence of your audience and produce something that does not consist of one long string of generic tropes, that's really all I ask for.
At first, they wait outside the walls for the enemy to start killing them with massive volleys of arrows, for no reason at all. Both sides have two sighted people among them (an absurdly large advantage against an army of blind people), but the good guys make no real use of them. Their leaders keep yelling out to each other, giving away their position each time to "just check whether you're still alive". Smart.
They are inside a walled city, but instead of using that to their advantage, they just do nothing while they wait for the enemy to ram down the gate, and when that takes too long they literally open the door to invite their enemies to come fight them inside.
There they could at least still have the high ground, but instead of just raining arrows and spears at them from the sides along the inside of the walls where they can't easily be hit themselves, they have one bowman and three guys throwing spears from a position where they can readily be shot by a bunch of blind crossbowmen from beyond the gates, and the rest is all down in the trenches with the enemy where they can easily be picked off in melee combat.
At one point one of the sighted has the enemy leader in her crosshairs but doesn't shoot because her gf (who is with the enemy) is looking at her funny. The enemy also has two sighted people (who are apparently fine with fighting for people who want to burn them alive for having eyesight), but instead of making it a priority to render them harmless, they seem to ignore them altogether as one of them - a kid - leads a band of crossbowmen with somehow perfect blind aim based his on vague directions on a killing spree through the trenches, until about halfway through the battle when someone finally gets the bright idea to tackle the guy carrying him around. Then one of the two sighted takes himself out of the battle to hold his buddy's hand as he slowly dies (and for a good while after that) while the bad guys slaughter their people around them.
They hold back a large contingent of their forces and drive the enemy into a dead end where they are walking on ice (conveniently hidden from sight by the snow so that the one sighted person with them doesn't notice, of course), then they crack the ice with large rocks as they scurry up the walls on ropes. The obvious thing to do would've been to at that point use those reinforcements to attack from the rear, maybe with some sort of shield wall or something, and drive the enemy into the freezing water. Of course, they don't do that. The reinforcements are just kind of standing there, watching the spectacle unfold. Well, it's a good thing those guys showed up in the nick of time, otherwise who could've possibly lowered all those ropes!
I admit I am not well versed in strategy and tactics, especially for two blind armies fighting one another in a kind of pre-medieval-type setting, but most of these things are simple common sense. It annoys me that they have such an interesting concept and they still can't do anything more interesting with it than "they walk around using their swords as canes, and they snap their fingers, because they're *blind* you see".
Instead maybe show how such a world might really work, like maybe it would be interesting if they did *not* have perfect aim - because, yaknow, they're blind - and they had to cleverly adapt to that, and they used this as a battle tactic by quietly luring the enemy into various traps that would not work on sighted people. Just have the writers put some minimal effort into not insulting the intelligence of your audience and produce something that does not consist of one long string of generic tropes, that's really all I ask for.
Tell Your Friends