I'm all for a new take on something, but when you've managed to get tons of charities for disabled people upset because of a characteristic that the director decided to do differently from the book's depictions then you know you're off to a bad start.
The fact that it was switched to Alabama US instead of the UK seems an odd move, but then to change Grandmama from being Norwegian also removes some of the mystic charm of the Nordic angle of the story and (in my mind) betrays Dahl's heritage and experiences, too.
The final straw was race coming into it and remarks from the new (black) grandma that "witches only prey on the poor and wouldn't bother rich white people". We then almost immediately see them at the exact hotel she chooses to go to in order to avoid witches because 'it's full of rich white people' and the first child the Witches turn into a mouse is a rich white child!
It's scary and confusing for children and completely naff for adults. It's lost all the charm of the book, has ostracized people with disabilities and decided to bring class and race into the picture without any context and then in schizophrenic fashion turns that on its head anyway!
I can't find anything redeeming about it. Even the CGI was naff. Anne Hathaway does the best she can, but even that's not enough. Avoid.
The fact that it was switched to Alabama US instead of the UK seems an odd move, but then to change Grandmama from being Norwegian also removes some of the mystic charm of the Nordic angle of the story and (in my mind) betrays Dahl's heritage and experiences, too.
The final straw was race coming into it and remarks from the new (black) grandma that "witches only prey on the poor and wouldn't bother rich white people". We then almost immediately see them at the exact hotel she chooses to go to in order to avoid witches because 'it's full of rich white people' and the first child the Witches turn into a mouse is a rich white child!
It's scary and confusing for children and completely naff for adults. It's lost all the charm of the book, has ostracized people with disabilities and decided to bring class and race into the picture without any context and then in schizophrenic fashion turns that on its head anyway!
I can't find anything redeeming about it. Even the CGI was naff. Anne Hathaway does the best she can, but even that's not enough. Avoid.
Tell Your Friends