Werner Herzog is one of the all time greatest directors, but his second feature film, "Even Dwarfs Started Small," is an absolutely puzzling film.
The story focuses on inmates of an insane asylum, who in the absence of the faculty, take over the complex and bring on chaos and anarchy as they see fit. The story is told with little to no linear sensibilities, and too the film's credit, it works. However, Dwarfs' failings and successes all stem from this story. It is that there is no story. Only the this chaos and anarchy, with some scenes featuring one authority figure failing to deal with the situation at hand. When watching the film, there are scenes featuring the inmates watering flowers with gasoline, driving a van in circles with no one at the wheel, a foodfight, and disdain for the farm animals kept at the asylum. And these scenes range from dark and disturbing, to darkly humorous, complete emptiness, or somehow all of the above.
The real problem I personally would hold against this film is that everything serves no purpose. And even if purposelessness is the intention, something has to be gleamed from it. And while it's clear Herzog was going for this, he instead created an empty void of drabness and dark humor. And from the few other Herzog titles I've seen, I can say even with a lack of story, his ability to have defined and memorable characters (such as his later work in Aguirre The Wrath of God, and Stroszek), cover up the minimal, and abstracted story. But Dwarfs, doesn't really have that same character, and that may well be the reason this film gets lost. But the actors and actresses are all good, the black and white photography is fitting, and the bad soundtrack fits nicely with the tone of the film. Plus the all dwarf cast makes for an interesting experience amid the dull void.
Herzog is a masterful director, and this second feature of him showcases his immense technical strength and skill, but ultimately ends up as a failed avant garde art film focused more on being gratuitous. I say Herzog fans and art film fans go ahead and check this out. The rest can go check out Herzog's more famous works.
The story focuses on inmates of an insane asylum, who in the absence of the faculty, take over the complex and bring on chaos and anarchy as they see fit. The story is told with little to no linear sensibilities, and too the film's credit, it works. However, Dwarfs' failings and successes all stem from this story. It is that there is no story. Only the this chaos and anarchy, with some scenes featuring one authority figure failing to deal with the situation at hand. When watching the film, there are scenes featuring the inmates watering flowers with gasoline, driving a van in circles with no one at the wheel, a foodfight, and disdain for the farm animals kept at the asylum. And these scenes range from dark and disturbing, to darkly humorous, complete emptiness, or somehow all of the above.
The real problem I personally would hold against this film is that everything serves no purpose. And even if purposelessness is the intention, something has to be gleamed from it. And while it's clear Herzog was going for this, he instead created an empty void of drabness and dark humor. And from the few other Herzog titles I've seen, I can say even with a lack of story, his ability to have defined and memorable characters (such as his later work in Aguirre The Wrath of God, and Stroszek), cover up the minimal, and abstracted story. But Dwarfs, doesn't really have that same character, and that may well be the reason this film gets lost. But the actors and actresses are all good, the black and white photography is fitting, and the bad soundtrack fits nicely with the tone of the film. Plus the all dwarf cast makes for an interesting experience amid the dull void.
Herzog is a masterful director, and this second feature of him showcases his immense technical strength and skill, but ultimately ends up as a failed avant garde art film focused more on being gratuitous. I say Herzog fans and art film fans go ahead and check this out. The rest can go check out Herzog's more famous works.
Tell Your Friends