Code Geass is a series that is very much dependent on the audience not being smart enough to think. From the start, it is very clear that virtually no planning went into the overarching plot, as the main characters stumble into the main conflict completely by accident; but by the end the clumsy writers try to convince the audience that everything was planned despite absolutely no one's motivations aligning with their established personalities or beliefs. And throughout the series, clear plot holes that I would have caught as a kid pop up all over the place, yet the writers again try to cover this up by coming up with some ridiculous excuse that only makes this series' narcissistic fandom look even more gullible and totally break any suspension of disbelief.
For example, if Geass effects are absolute, why can they suddenly be broken by something as arbitrary as willpower? That's right--if you try hard enough, you can potentially resist a supposedly irresistible otherworldly power and not be an unwitting pawn in the ambiguously psychotic protagonist's hand.
Speaking of the protagonist, this may be the only series I have ever seen where I was legitimately rooting for the antagonists by the end. The vast majority of Code Geass's main characters are horribly one-dimensional. Lelouch is basically just an angsty psychopath who flip-flops between being maniacally pleased with himself as he even goes so far as to wipe out huge city blocks of civilians to confuse his enemies right before he becomes a misunderstood and tender-hearted freedom fighter who states to his classmates who are usually part of the agonizingly out-of-place high school Rom-com episodes that he and his resistance force don't kill innocents.
So you can see the main problem with the story and by extension the characters. There is no clear-cut direction for any of them, resulting in a cluttered mess that just shrugs off any semblance of logic and consistency or likable characterization in favor of edgy angst and ridiculous Deus Ex Machina plot twists. Alternatively, the other characters consist of a racist, hafu Japanese nationalist tsundere who uses the excuse of her servant mother suffering to shout racist one-liners at her enemies about how much she hates them before killing them in incredibly underhanded and dishonorable ways to make the common Japanese youth see her as a cool, morally ambiguous freedom fighter--which coalesces into her slaughtering a quartet of child soldiers who were totally defenseless in their current predicament; a bargain bin-bland kuudere whose sole personality traits are her pizza addiction and voluptuous butt the fandom is utterly crazy about; and a naïve but initially sympathetic deuteragonist who I honestly couldn't help but like because of his genuine attempts at establishing peace--which is later destroyed when he loses his mind thanks to Lelouch ultimately messing everything up, when he then joins Lelouch because by that point Lelouch and Lelouch alone is portrayed as the only one who could be right, so he willingly murders his own comrades who had never done anything to spite him and very likely had the political power to help change things for the better.
This brings me to the characters the series should have been about in the first place. Instead of a narcissistic and delusional angst-king the script is so intent on glorifying, how does this sound for compelling protagonists:
Monica Krushevsky: A young, beautiful, blonde knight who holds absolutely no prejudices in the slightest and uses her political influence to help make things better for the oppressed people of her country's empire. Her arc ultimately causes her to fall in love with with rebel Ace pilot Orpheus Zevon. Now, her loyalties are torn between wanting to help her country improve itself while protecting its people from terrorists and not wanting any harm to come to her newfound love and his comrades.
Nonette Enneagram: A mildly seasoned but still beautiful woman training her young protégé to be a knight. Her personality is loud, brash, and sometimes obnoxiously cheery. She is evidently quite the force on the battlefield, as even the esteemed Second Princess of Britannia respects her greatly and even fears her to a point.
Dorothea Ernst: A stunningly beautiful, dark-skinned, emerald-eyed woman whose people may also be among those who the Britannain government oppresses. Can her influence as a symbol of peace help to change Britannian opinions toward Numbers? In addition, her figure is way sexier than either C. C.'s or Kallen's, sporting the best butt out of any female character in the series. ;-3 In this version, she is quite the heartthrob among the fans, and truckloads of fan art is dedicated to her mesmerizing beauty.
Gino Weinberg: A young aristocrat who left his racist family after they threw out the servant girl he loved onto the street. Now, he hopes that his greater political influence than them as a Knight of the Round can help to change the system as Monica wants to.
Marika Soresi: A young teenage girl thrown into a war that is not hers, she fights to avenge her brother who was so dishonorably killed by the sadistic Ace of the Black Knights Kallen Statfeldt. Her tale is a morally gray one that combines a certain point of view's perception of justice with the struggle of people who are not old enough to even make their own decisions for their future.
Bismarck Waldstein: The leader of the Knights of the Round, he is an honorable and morally upright man who believes that violence should always be a last resort. Unfortunately, he holds a dark secret that will divide his subordinates and make him an ultimate villain in the coming civil war.
Do those characters sound more interesting and three-dimensional than any of the arrogant, stupid (constantly causing their own problems for the sake of the plot!), and hypocritical "freedom fighters" the series is actually about? TOO BAD! Most of them are going to be brutally murdered by our one-dimensional protagonists to simply get them out of the way before finally getting expanded upon canonically in later content. The other ones like Nonette, Gino, and Marika are either going to be spared from getting murdered because of getting a cult following from a game she was in only a few months before that awfully scripted episode aired, necessitating Dorothea's creation to keep the script unchanged; get literally no development like Gino so he remains absolutely one-dimensional unless one would read the novel he is in; or be permanently traumatized like Marika after fan backlash caused her to miraculously survive her mech's explosion when people realized that the scummy Kallen wiped out an entire family line with the event still being portrayed as "cool" by the arrogant producers and writers who did everything they could to flip a middle finger to the show's critics in the disastrous second season that is so badly written that anyone with a dash of knowledge about the show's troubled production history and extra content produced between the seasons will be able to piece together that Sunrise corporate pretty much sabotaged it in the very end just so it could end on a note worshipping its insufferably arrogant protagonist.
And that's the worst part of this show's wasted potential. For as many lazy plot holes as the first season had, its creators actually TRIED. The scale is huge, the stakes are real, more than one side's view is presented as feasible, and there is at least a hint of three-dimensional development for the main characters that could have grown. In the end, Code Geass became the most successful failure in anime history. The pacing is atrocious, its characters are flat and unlikable, and despite the heaps of praise the ending gets, it too is an absolute disaster. Lelouch just expects everyone to get over the bad blood among each other because he causes them to suffer together for a few months. In reality, he would have cooked up even more racial tensions as they all fought for resources to survive and blamed each other as scapegoats. Also, the plan, grandiosely titled "Zero Requiem," is basically just Lelouch throwing the biggest temper tantrum in history where he unleashes chaos onto the entire world and leaves the mess for everyone else to clean up.
Code Geass is written for an audience that thinks in black-and-white despite being disguised as morally gray. I can't recommend this to anyone older than 10 years old because only a child could be dumb enough to think this is intelligent, but then those children would be exposed to all of the edgy junk like purely gratuitous nudity and unnecessarily brutal violence. Do yourself a favor and don't buy into the hype. This just may be the worst popular anime of all time, and its toxic fandom is a testament to that since they scream at and harass anyone who gives the series any bit of valid criticism instead of letting something that is objectively good stand on its own merit. Instead, wait patiently for any news about the new series being written by an entirely new writing staff. Maybe with enough support, Monica and Dorothea can be revived and expose Suzaku as a false hero and execute him for murdering them and millions of innocents with Gino, Nonette, and Anya by their side and bring down Lelouch's fragile lie with their friends. If you would prefer a starter anime that is easy to get into over this drivel . . . Might I recommend "Sword Art Online"? Or, heck, "Legend of the Galactic Heroes." It is the masterpiece this pretender ripped off, anyway.
For example, if Geass effects are absolute, why can they suddenly be broken by something as arbitrary as willpower? That's right--if you try hard enough, you can potentially resist a supposedly irresistible otherworldly power and not be an unwitting pawn in the ambiguously psychotic protagonist's hand.
Speaking of the protagonist, this may be the only series I have ever seen where I was legitimately rooting for the antagonists by the end. The vast majority of Code Geass's main characters are horribly one-dimensional. Lelouch is basically just an angsty psychopath who flip-flops between being maniacally pleased with himself as he even goes so far as to wipe out huge city blocks of civilians to confuse his enemies right before he becomes a misunderstood and tender-hearted freedom fighter who states to his classmates who are usually part of the agonizingly out-of-place high school Rom-com episodes that he and his resistance force don't kill innocents.
So you can see the main problem with the story and by extension the characters. There is no clear-cut direction for any of them, resulting in a cluttered mess that just shrugs off any semblance of logic and consistency or likable characterization in favor of edgy angst and ridiculous Deus Ex Machina plot twists. Alternatively, the other characters consist of a racist, hafu Japanese nationalist tsundere who uses the excuse of her servant mother suffering to shout racist one-liners at her enemies about how much she hates them before killing them in incredibly underhanded and dishonorable ways to make the common Japanese youth see her as a cool, morally ambiguous freedom fighter--which coalesces into her slaughtering a quartet of child soldiers who were totally defenseless in their current predicament; a bargain bin-bland kuudere whose sole personality traits are her pizza addiction and voluptuous butt the fandom is utterly crazy about; and a naïve but initially sympathetic deuteragonist who I honestly couldn't help but like because of his genuine attempts at establishing peace--which is later destroyed when he loses his mind thanks to Lelouch ultimately messing everything up, when he then joins Lelouch because by that point Lelouch and Lelouch alone is portrayed as the only one who could be right, so he willingly murders his own comrades who had never done anything to spite him and very likely had the political power to help change things for the better.
This brings me to the characters the series should have been about in the first place. Instead of a narcissistic and delusional angst-king the script is so intent on glorifying, how does this sound for compelling protagonists:
Monica Krushevsky: A young, beautiful, blonde knight who holds absolutely no prejudices in the slightest and uses her political influence to help make things better for the oppressed people of her country's empire. Her arc ultimately causes her to fall in love with with rebel Ace pilot Orpheus Zevon. Now, her loyalties are torn between wanting to help her country improve itself while protecting its people from terrorists and not wanting any harm to come to her newfound love and his comrades.
Nonette Enneagram: A mildly seasoned but still beautiful woman training her young protégé to be a knight. Her personality is loud, brash, and sometimes obnoxiously cheery. She is evidently quite the force on the battlefield, as even the esteemed Second Princess of Britannia respects her greatly and even fears her to a point.
Dorothea Ernst: A stunningly beautiful, dark-skinned, emerald-eyed woman whose people may also be among those who the Britannain government oppresses. Can her influence as a symbol of peace help to change Britannian opinions toward Numbers? In addition, her figure is way sexier than either C. C.'s or Kallen's, sporting the best butt out of any female character in the series. ;-3 In this version, she is quite the heartthrob among the fans, and truckloads of fan art is dedicated to her mesmerizing beauty.
Gino Weinberg: A young aristocrat who left his racist family after they threw out the servant girl he loved onto the street. Now, he hopes that his greater political influence than them as a Knight of the Round can help to change the system as Monica wants to.
Marika Soresi: A young teenage girl thrown into a war that is not hers, she fights to avenge her brother who was so dishonorably killed by the sadistic Ace of the Black Knights Kallen Statfeldt. Her tale is a morally gray one that combines a certain point of view's perception of justice with the struggle of people who are not old enough to even make their own decisions for their future.
Bismarck Waldstein: The leader of the Knights of the Round, he is an honorable and morally upright man who believes that violence should always be a last resort. Unfortunately, he holds a dark secret that will divide his subordinates and make him an ultimate villain in the coming civil war.
Do those characters sound more interesting and three-dimensional than any of the arrogant, stupid (constantly causing their own problems for the sake of the plot!), and hypocritical "freedom fighters" the series is actually about? TOO BAD! Most of them are going to be brutally murdered by our one-dimensional protagonists to simply get them out of the way before finally getting expanded upon canonically in later content. The other ones like Nonette, Gino, and Marika are either going to be spared from getting murdered because of getting a cult following from a game she was in only a few months before that awfully scripted episode aired, necessitating Dorothea's creation to keep the script unchanged; get literally no development like Gino so he remains absolutely one-dimensional unless one would read the novel he is in; or be permanently traumatized like Marika after fan backlash caused her to miraculously survive her mech's explosion when people realized that the scummy Kallen wiped out an entire family line with the event still being portrayed as "cool" by the arrogant producers and writers who did everything they could to flip a middle finger to the show's critics in the disastrous second season that is so badly written that anyone with a dash of knowledge about the show's troubled production history and extra content produced between the seasons will be able to piece together that Sunrise corporate pretty much sabotaged it in the very end just so it could end on a note worshipping its insufferably arrogant protagonist.
And that's the worst part of this show's wasted potential. For as many lazy plot holes as the first season had, its creators actually TRIED. The scale is huge, the stakes are real, more than one side's view is presented as feasible, and there is at least a hint of three-dimensional development for the main characters that could have grown. In the end, Code Geass became the most successful failure in anime history. The pacing is atrocious, its characters are flat and unlikable, and despite the heaps of praise the ending gets, it too is an absolute disaster. Lelouch just expects everyone to get over the bad blood among each other because he causes them to suffer together for a few months. In reality, he would have cooked up even more racial tensions as they all fought for resources to survive and blamed each other as scapegoats. Also, the plan, grandiosely titled "Zero Requiem," is basically just Lelouch throwing the biggest temper tantrum in history where he unleashes chaos onto the entire world and leaves the mess for everyone else to clean up.
Code Geass is written for an audience that thinks in black-and-white despite being disguised as morally gray. I can't recommend this to anyone older than 10 years old because only a child could be dumb enough to think this is intelligent, but then those children would be exposed to all of the edgy junk like purely gratuitous nudity and unnecessarily brutal violence. Do yourself a favor and don't buy into the hype. This just may be the worst popular anime of all time, and its toxic fandom is a testament to that since they scream at and harass anyone who gives the series any bit of valid criticism instead of letting something that is objectively good stand on its own merit. Instead, wait patiently for any news about the new series being written by an entirely new writing staff. Maybe with enough support, Monica and Dorothea can be revived and expose Suzaku as a false hero and execute him for murdering them and millions of innocents with Gino, Nonette, and Anya by their side and bring down Lelouch's fragile lie with their friends. If you would prefer a starter anime that is easy to get into over this drivel . . . Might I recommend "Sword Art Online"? Or, heck, "Legend of the Galactic Heroes." It is the masterpiece this pretender ripped off, anyway.
Tell Your Friends