Review of The Eagle

The Eagle (1925)
10/10
Silent film-making at its best!
4 July 1999
This is an astonishing film, breathtakingly shot by George Barnes, which reveals how powerful the silent film could be. Like many silents this film is not about its plot but about the minutia of human behaviour and emotion. The moment when Valentino touches Banky's neck you can feel her thrill - her eyes moisten with passion. This is the kind of moment that the talkies had trouble with - words spoil the ecstasy of first touch - as many of the silent screen's great lovers found when they entered talkies. But Valentino did not live to make a talkie - and his legend is probably grateful.

He is exceptional in this period romp through the Russia of Catherine the Great. Vilma Banky matches him superbly - she has the ethereal beauty of Garbo. James Marcus is fun as the baddie, but Louise Dresser is brilliant as Catherine the Great. The scene where she attempts to "take advantage" of Valentino is extraordinary - and a great step forward for female liberation.

Combine these performances with the genius of Clarence Brown, the costumes of Adrian (which are intentionally not quite of the right period having a distinctive 1920's feel), and the production design of William Cameron Menzies and you have a masterpiece. It will surprise you at every turn, and the tracking shots are truly magnificent - especially that banquet scene! Don't miss it - and if you get the version with Carl Davis' score you are in for a real treat.
15 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed