This is a well-crafted film, and the DVD documentaries reveal cast and crew that are intelligent, non-sensationalist and committed, both to the filming process and storyline.
The film is a mixture of two genres - one is the horror genre, in which Jennifer Carpenter gives a very good (and chilling) performance as Emily Rose. The colours, the musical score, and (surprisingly) muted and in-obvious special effects work very well indeed.
The other genre is the courtroom drama. Based on actual happenings, the writer does not waste time trying to look at which side is right. The perennial problem of faith and doubt is examined. Examined in a way where "evidence" is presented. The audience, like the jury, must weigh up the matter.
Laura Linney as the defendant is well-cast. She gives her character the right blend of authority contrasted with confusion. The dignity she brings to Erin is excellent. Likewise Tom Wilkinson, as the accused neglectful priest. Campbell Scott, as a church-going "believer" is impressive as the prosecution. At no time does the film approach the TV courtroom drama genre. That this film works is thanks to these actors, as well as to Mary Beth Hurt, who imbues the judge with the right touch of authority and humanity.
This is an intelligent, thought-provoking film, which should engender animated, lively and thoughtful discussion. Don't miss it.
The film is a mixture of two genres - one is the horror genre, in which Jennifer Carpenter gives a very good (and chilling) performance as Emily Rose. The colours, the musical score, and (surprisingly) muted and in-obvious special effects work very well indeed.
The other genre is the courtroom drama. Based on actual happenings, the writer does not waste time trying to look at which side is right. The perennial problem of faith and doubt is examined. Examined in a way where "evidence" is presented. The audience, like the jury, must weigh up the matter.
Laura Linney as the defendant is well-cast. She gives her character the right blend of authority contrasted with confusion. The dignity she brings to Erin is excellent. Likewise Tom Wilkinson, as the accused neglectful priest. Campbell Scott, as a church-going "believer" is impressive as the prosecution. At no time does the film approach the TV courtroom drama genre. That this film works is thanks to these actors, as well as to Mary Beth Hurt, who imbues the judge with the right touch of authority and humanity.
This is an intelligent, thought-provoking film, which should engender animated, lively and thoughtful discussion. Don't miss it.