This show is ostensibly a competition between songwriters. Four of them come on the show and perform their original songs for a panel consisting of an established recording artist and three "producers". The end result will be that one song will be chosen by the recording artist for inclusion on its next album.
But first, the four-person panel offers feedback, constructive criticism, and notes about how each song might be improved or made more in the style of that week's recording artist. Three of the four songs are chosen to be workshopped by individual producers who shepherd the songs through further analysis and fine-tuning.
In the end, one song is chosen and a "final version" is presented at the end of the episode.
This process requires that the songwriters check their egos at the door, and most seem grateful for the attention their creations are given, despite the fact that the final versions might not sound much like the originals. Because the panels are comprised of respected and proven industry talents, the show seems instructive and inspirational for songwriters.
I think the show would be more enjoyable if the actual "prizes"---that is, the monetary rewards given to the winners---were detailed. And I am not sure everyone wants to watch "the sausage being made"; some might prefer just to hear the final results without knowing about the work process.
Still, good songs are about inspiration and this show illustrates that inspiration can take place at many points in the creative and production processes.
But first, the four-person panel offers feedback, constructive criticism, and notes about how each song might be improved or made more in the style of that week's recording artist. Three of the four songs are chosen to be workshopped by individual producers who shepherd the songs through further analysis and fine-tuning.
In the end, one song is chosen and a "final version" is presented at the end of the episode.
This process requires that the songwriters check their egos at the door, and most seem grateful for the attention their creations are given, despite the fact that the final versions might not sound much like the originals. Because the panels are comprised of respected and proven industry talents, the show seems instructive and inspirational for songwriters.
I think the show would be more enjoyable if the actual "prizes"---that is, the monetary rewards given to the winners---were detailed. And I am not sure everyone wants to watch "the sausage being made"; some might prefer just to hear the final results without knowing about the work process.
Still, good songs are about inspiration and this show illustrates that inspiration can take place at many points in the creative and production processes.