I've been on a month long Christmas movie quest and while in the midst of it, i've read a lot of reviews also. i don't understand why folks who obviously don't like Christmas movie would watch and review them.
An Evergreen Christmas isn't a bad movie. Actually, it's quite good, for what it is and that is a simple tale of coming home and remembering your past. The Christmas background was a pleasant bonus.
So, ignore the naysayers and get ready for An Evergreen Christmas. 6 out of 10.