Season 2 didn't touch the level of 1 at any point. Poor acting from most of the characters. Image of dodge completely ruined by Gabe. The only good actors were Duncan and the kid. Disgusted by some of the actors specially Gabe by his smirk. I understand you have to make a character evil but there are other ways to do it. It was a complete turn off throughout Season 2.
So in short Season 1 => 8 star Season 2 => 4 star.
So in short Season 1 => 8 star Season 2 => 4 star.