My 5* rating isn't indicative of quality, simply of what this short achieves. It's a well-made and suggestive short, with a heavy dose of creepiness. But it seems more like a trailer for a much longer movie than a complete narrative in itself. Ambiguity and what's left out can make for great horror, of course, but there doesn't seem any meaning to this short that can be worked out just from what we see. I'd very much like to see a longer version, which means the short did a good enough job to earn 5 stars even without anything concrete to really appreciate.