In a shocking twist, American Pie is kind of a slow burn. There's enough jokes to sustain itself but considering it's got the ideal run time for a comedy, it drags in places. The greatest strength is that there's a real sentimentality that is hidden beneath all the vulgarity that gets it a lot further.
Jason Biggs, Chris Klein, Thomas Ian Nicholas and Eddie Kaye Thomas work really well together. There's a genuine camaraderie between them when they actually open up to each other as well as when they're clearly enjoying seeing one of them suffer. Seann William Scott is more one note but it's counterbalanced by him having some of the funniest moments.
Directors Chris & Paul Weitz do a fine job, there's nothing inherently wrong with their direction but at the same time more stylistic flair would've given the film a bit more life. The soundtrack is the biggest highlight. It's so of the time in a good way and definitely the only aspect that gives the film any energy.
Jason Biggs, Chris Klein, Thomas Ian Nicholas and Eddie Kaye Thomas work really well together. There's a genuine camaraderie between them when they actually open up to each other as well as when they're clearly enjoying seeing one of them suffer. Seann William Scott is more one note but it's counterbalanced by him having some of the funniest moments.
Directors Chris & Paul Weitz do a fine job, there's nothing inherently wrong with their direction but at the same time more stylistic flair would've given the film a bit more life. The soundtrack is the biggest highlight. It's so of the time in a good way and definitely the only aspect that gives the film any energy.