Undressing Extraordinary (1901) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Stop-Motion Trickery
JoeytheBrit27 November 2009
Robert Paul is a largely forgotten name today, but he was a major pioneer of British cinema, and was quick to grasp the commercial potential of cinema in ways that better known pioneers such as William Friese-Greene were not. He was more of a mechanic than a filmmaker making, with Birt Acres, his own camera on which to shoot films in 1895, and also Britain's first projector, the Animatograph, with which to screen them in 1896. Early in the 20th century he had a custom-made studio built in Muswell Hill.

For the time, Undressing Extraordinary, at three-minutes long, almost qualifies for epic status. It's a comedy film made by Walter Booth – who may conceivably be the performer in the film – at Paul's Muswell Hill studio. The young chap in the film is slightly the worse for drink. He tries to undress for bed, but keeps finding himself in a series of different costumes. It's a nonsensical story which was clearly intended simply to show off the stop-motion technique that makes it very reminiscent of a Melies film.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Amusing Trick Film
Cineanalyst31 December 2007
"Undressing Extraordinary" is one of many trick films made by Walter Booth and Robert Paul at Paul's Animatograph Company. Most, if not all, major film companies, and most notably Georges Méliès, were making trick films by this time. The earliest still available one by Booth and Paul seems to be "Upside Down, or the Human Flies" (1899). "Undressing Extraordinary" seems noteworthy to me, however, for its effective (for its time) stop-substitution effects and the forceful performance by its sole actor. (Although the film is essentially a little improved remake of Méliès's "Going to Bed Under Difficulties" (Le Déshabillage impossible).) The film lasts about three minutes in its full form, but was also available in a shorter version for the frugal exhibitor. Its entirety is played out before a fixed camera position from a then typical long shot framing. It's about a tired traveller (as the longer title makes clear) unable to get undressed due to new outfits appearing on him as soon as he dispenses of his former clothes. The filmmakers employed stop-motion, which they touched up by splicing, to effect costume changes and other tricks perpetrated by inanimate objects upon the traveller.

It is suspected by historians that the traveller may be Walter Booth, the director and trick film wizard behind the film's construction, although this is uncertain because there are no known photographs of Booth. The same actor, however, appears in other films by Booth, as well. Whoever the actor is, I think he's the highlight of this little film. His energetic performance is further enchanted by the deception that the film is a three-minute long take. Overall, it's briefly amusing.

Alice Guy, of Gaumont, also remade Méliès's film as "How Monsier Takes His Bath" (Comment Monsieur prend son bain) (1903).
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Decent Melies Rip-Off
Michael_Elliott3 January 2011
Undressing Extraordinary (1901)

** 1/2 (out of 4)

If someone was to start study early cinema then the master Georges Melies would be name they'd have to become very familiar with. Once you checked out his terrific films you'd then have to check out all the rip-offs coming from various studios including Edison and Biograph in America. This one here comes from Britain and director Robert W. Paul. I always find these Melies rips to be rather interesting for a number of reasons no matter if they're good or bad. This one here is somewhere in the middle as the tricks are neatly done and at least they're not just thrown together like so many others. What works are the trick shots, although at just under 4-minutes the subjects grows a little bit tiresome as it goes along. What doesn't work is the actor playing the part of the man who is trying to go to bed but each time he takes off a piece of clothing it is replaced with another piece. Melies did this type of film several times to better effect and what hurts this film is that our actor simply isn't charming enough to make what's going on funny. One thing I did enjoy here is that all the extra clothing remains on the floor after being taken off by the man.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed