"Law & Order" His Hour Upon the Stage (TV Episode 1991) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Human Popsicle
rmax30482323 November 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Two garbage men find a well-dressed dead body in a dumpster. The body has three bullet holes in it and has been frozen for five years.

The man was a big shot in the production of plays in New York. Ceretta and Logan untangle the diverse and often conflicting narrative threads behind the murder and present Stone's office with half a dozen suspects who might have been directly or peripherally involved.

All of them lie at first, of course, and it takes a lot of wheedling to get the truth out of them. In the end, justice is served.

There's nothing exceptional about the episode, meaning that it's quite good and up to the usual standards. The nucleus of the plot to eliminate the powerful but jealous producer is Finn Carter, the blond who was the dead man's fiancée and exploiter. She's sleek and sophisticated and desirable enough to kill for, or at least maim for. She's like one of those crystals that, dropped into a supercooled liquid, immediately freezes its surroundings into a solid and purposive mass.

But there were times when the plot was complicated enough that I got a little lost. I think there may have been three people involved in actually owning or driving the limousine in which the murder took place, perhaps more. At least one of the named was killed in prison.

Stone is given a cute little exit speech about the blond villainess, about how she never felt any real emotions. Everyone was only an actor on her stage and the victim wasn't really murdered. He just made a convenient exit. This is an established school of analysis in sociology, where it's known as the dramaturgical approach. One of its founders was the literary theorist and philosopher Kenneth Burke (1897 - 1993), q.v.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The Frozen Dead
bkoganbing30 June 2012
The frozen body of a fledgling Broadway producer is discovered after it's being dumped in a restaurant freezer and there for over five years. That makes it a homicide and those three holes in head and chest make it a homicide. Nobody likes cold cases especially Paul Sorvino and Chris Noth.

They zero in on the responsible parties which turn out to be the deceased's producing partner Frank Converse and the deceased girlfriend Finn Carter who became a star as a result of appearing in the last property the victim produced.

When it gets to the District Attorney it's a question of assigning the blame in portions and who gets the biggest share. It becomes obvious that Carter is the prime mover in the homicide and the motive turned out to be some shady financing of the show itself. For most of the episode Carter seems just out of reach. Not helping is the fact that the actual shooter was picked up on another charge and died in prison. But Richard Brooks is the one who makes the connection between Carter and the deceased hit man which nails her in court for Michael Moriarty.

Jerry Orbach says he loves it when they're stupid, I love it when they outsmart themselves.
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Life is but an icy stage
TheLittleSongbird12 March 2020
After a brilliant, season high point previous episode in "Heaven", which saw Season 2 back on form, it is hard not to expect a lot from "His Hour Upon a Stage" and certainly was for me on first watch to be honest. Also because the story on paper was one of the most interesting-sounding of all the stories for 'Law and Order's' second season, which generally was well done if not as consistent as the previous. Hard not to be grabbed either by the grand sounding title, which seemed wonderfully theatrical.

"His Hour Upon a Stage" is not a great episode or one of Season 2's best. It was a little bit of a disappointment after "Heaven", but namely because that episode was so good, and the synopsis is a little more interesting than the actual episode itself in my view. That does sound misleading and gives the impression that it is to me not a good episode. Not the case. There is more good than bad here and the good things are done very well indeed.

Good things that were also good things in all of the show's previous episodes. It still looks slick and doesn't feel too claustrophobic without trying to resort to overblown gimmickry. Do think generally that the look of 'Law and Order' improved even more in Season 2 than in Season 1, it seemed sharper and slicker while still in keeping with the show's tone. The music isn't constant or over-emphasised, even when something dramatic is happening. The theme tune is easy to remember and doesn't grate. Paul Sorvino has settled well and Carreta and Logan's chemistry gelled better with each episode, evident here.

The writing doesn't ramble and plenty of it really provokes thought. There is a good deal of talk but it doesn't feel too much. Stone's exit speech sums up the character of Leslie Hart to a tee. The story is nothing extraordinary and is not the most tension-filled or emotionally investable episode of Season 2 and even of the whole of 'Law and Order', but it still intrigues and has enough turns in the plot that one doesn't predict. Leslie Hart is an interesting character and Finn Carter is chillingly sophisticated in it. Still continue to like Stone very much as a character and Michael Moriarty has a lot of presence as him.

With all that being said, the story can be a complicated one and the second half at times does feel like too much being revealed in a short space of time and some of it is not so simple. So if anybody is a little confused on first watch at times, they can't be blamed. If it tried to do a little less and focused on one or two less characters, with only Hart being particularly well drawn of the supporting characters in my view, "His Hour Upon a Stage" would have been even better.

Although the story is enjoyable and well done, more tension and emotion wouldn't have gone amiss.

Summing up, solid episode but something a little missing and slightly over-complicated in the latter stages. 7/10
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Broadway
safenoe3 August 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I'm enjoying watching the early years of Law and Order and this episode, His Hour Upon the Stage, had lots of promise. I was hoping for more of a peek into any tawdry activities behind (or on the streets of) Broadway. Anyway, this episode was more of a he said, she said, he said, she said that kind of went on and on and on.

Dylan Baker guest stars in this episode, before he hit stardom. When watching this episode I was amazed by how the camera crew managed to film the scenes in a busy New York City, with passerbys in the background. Some were extras, especially the ones who walked in front of the stars.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed