"Midsomer Murders" Hidden Depths (TV Episode 2005) Poster

(TV Series)

(2005)

User Reviews

Review this title
15 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
"Being locked in a cellar by a triple murderer is a better excuse than the car broke down." Another fine Midsomer Murders mystery.
poolandrews6 December 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Midsomer Murders: Hidden Depths is set in the village of Midsomer Magna & starts as troubled solicitor Nicholas Turner (James Weber-Brown) is found dead after having fallen from the roof of Sandford House, an old renovated country manor turned into an apartment block where he lived with his wife Felicity (Lucy Russell). DCI Tom Barnaby (John Nettles) & Sgt. Dan Scott (John Hopkins) are on the case, at first they have trouble establishing whether Nicholas' death was suicide or murder. Sandford House gardener Steve Hope (John Lightbody) claims to have heard Nicholas shouting shortly before he took a dive of the roof & upon further investigation Barnaby discovers that Nicholas was in dire financial trouble & stealing his clients money, £150,000 to be exact. Shortly after rival solicitor Otto Benham (Oliver Ford Davis) is murdered in bizarre fashion, add that to the fact one of Nicholas' neighbours Jack Wilmot (Matthew Flynn) has mysteriously disappeared along with the discovery of fake vintage wine bottle labels, talk of secret underground cellars & Barnaby has a real puzzle on his hands...

Episode 6 from season 8 this Midsomer Murders mystery was directed by Sarah Hellings & this is yet another great entry in this generally excellent British crime drama series. The script by David Hoskins has plenty of twists & turns in it, in fact the whole story is turned on it's head in the climatic revelations. There's also some nice humour here with Barnaby & Scott locked in a wine cellar for the majority of the second half & the two have a nice little dig at each other in the final scene. The plot here is actually quite straight forward to follow, the final revelations are very clear & concise with really good use of flashbacks, in fact unlike many Midsomer Muders episode I think you would be able to catch the final fifteen minutes & pretty much 'get' it because the flashbacks literally spell it out so well. Hidden Depths surely features two of the most memorable, outrageous, silly & far fetched murders in the whole series, one guy is drugged, laid out on a lawn with a huge white target drawn on it with him in the middle being held down by croquet hoops & then he is murdered by having lots of bottles of wine shot at him from a medieval wooden catapult! The second murder consists of someone having a hollow TV set with a hole in the bottom placed over their head & asked questions while the killer drowns him by pouring wine into the set! While they are undoubtedly silly they are also very entertaining & pretty funny. On the negative side I thought the process with which Barnaby solved the case wasn't the best, he sure made a lot of leaps in logic, put a lot of things together in exactly the right way & made a lot guesses which just happened to be right. Then there's the way in which the killer disposes of his victims, it's all well & good making a statement & trying to be clever but all they end up doing is draw attention to themselves & their motives. There's also a really neat con trick in Hidden Depths which starts everything off & that too is explained in a really clear & well done series of flashbacks.

As usual shot in Oxfordshire & Buckinghamshire Hidden Depths looks great with very high production values, the usual effective music & fine photography. There are three murders in this altogether although none are particularly graphic they are certainly memorable. There is a little scene when one of the character's is seen to meet Princess Diana, the scene was maybe shot with a double (looking at the cast list this is confirmed) & is seen on a TV screen but this did surprise me a bit since the topic of the late Princess Diana is still a thorny subject over here & in the wake of her immediate death there was a blanket ban on any type of reference to Diana which has obviously been relaxed since but she still generates a lot of feeling here. The acting is really good as usual from a strong cast.

Hidden Depths is another great Midsomer Murders episode with enough incident, plot twists & memorable murders that should satisfy fans & armchair detectives in general everywhere.
39 out of 41 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Well Crafted and Quite Bizarre
Hitchcoc24 March 2016
Other have done a fine job of evaluating this episode. My two cent's worth has to do with the creativity of the murders, the nice pairing of Barnaby and Scott in the wine cellar, faced with literally carving their way out (and not being missed by anyone). The murder victims are crass and unkind people and seem deserving of their fates. Of course, the mechanics of their demises is a bit far fetched. How someone could put together the incredible machinery and have it work so successfully is hard to fathom. But, then, that is how the gauntlet is thrown down. It would seem that someone so adept at accomplishing these results would take a bit more care when it comes to being caught. This is about gamesmanship and this is not an terribly unusual plot element throughout moviedom. I have to say I was taken in and the writing is fine here. I also enjoyed Barnaby's wife having the time of her life without him. It should give him pause.
32 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
One of the best Midsomers - with an incredible ending
safenoe6 March 2016
Warning: Spoilers
This has to be one of the best and intriguing Midsomer Murder episodes - the twist ending which is revealed only in the last 5 minutes or so is worth the watch. I would never have guessed in a million years who the murderer was, and kudos to the writer for coming up with an amazing plot point. Who would have guessed?

One hilarious and knowing moment was the send-up of the royal gala greeting where you saw Princess Diana (portrayed by Nicky Lilley, who was a professional impersonator of Princess Di) greeting the jocular Mike Spicer). This came up when Mike was reflecting on his past glories as a TV celebrity with his glories fading fast amidst the framed magazine covers and photos in his house where he lives alone after his wife left him.

But one thing I couldn't understand was why Jack Wilmot, Otto Benham and Mike Spicer required the huge amount of money from Nick Turner to profit from the scam - maybe I missed it amongst all the minutiae and accents.

The murders were grizzly, especially the one with Mike Spicer and the TV set and wine.

Dan Scott is always looking out for a date and he does so with Sara, the bartender. I think Dan should get a spin-off called UnPC, where he plays the politically incorrect police chief in the rough part of London and unleashes (in a witty way that brings in the audience who miss the political incorrectness of Midsomer Murders following the departure of the executive producer) his politically incorrect comments about minorities, women, GLBT and anyone with left-of- centre views (between cigarettes of course). Scott could be partnered with a sensitive female junior office who has more squishy politically correct views, and they play off each other with Scott getting the upper hand of course.
18 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Absolutely brilliant.
Sleepin_Dragon24 August 2018
Hidden Depths has to be one of the very best episodes of Midsomer Murders, it combines all essential elements needed for a murder mystery, and just when you think it's done its job, it surprises you even more, with an unbelievably good ending.

The story is excellent, it's a clever, twisted tail of deception and revenge. The murders are among the best in any episode, it's about now that the writers were looking for more bizarre and obscure killing methods, sometimes they went completely overboard, but here they manage to stay within the limits of reality. The wine bottle murder is perhaps the best in the show's history, and the fact that a relative is made to watch makes it all the better. It's amusing too, Joyce has some great moments, as does Scott.

I really enjoyed the performances of Oliver Ford Davies and Robert Daws, they play two of the most obnoxious, loathsome guys ever seen on the show, but they both do so brilliantly. Nancy Carroll is also excellent, whatever drama she appears in there seems to be a running joke about her husband being spoken about, but always absent, will we ever see Lady Felicia's husband Monty (Father Brown.)

It's creative, twisted, funny, it's a classic, 10/10
32 out of 35 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Back to "classic" 'Midsomer Murders'
TheLittleSongbird3 February 2017
After being hugely let down by the previous episode "Second Sight", which to me is one of the low-points of 'Midsomer Murders' and actually didn't feel like it at all, it was such a relief for "Hidden Depths" to epitomise what 'Midsomer Murders' is all about and what makes it so great when on form.

To me, "Hidden Depths" is the best episode of Season 8 and a strong contender for the best Barnaby and Scott episode. It is notable personally for three things. One, the chemistry between Barnaby and Scott is as delightful as one can hope. Always have enjoyed their spirited chemistry, and their scenes in the cellar in "Hidden Depths" will have fans relishing them with glee. John Nettles is superb as Barnaby and John Hopkins is a perfect contrast.

Secondly, the deaths in "Hidden Depths" are among the most deliciously elaborate, grisly and imaginative of the entire show, the second murder in particular is among the greatest 'Midsomer Murders' scenes. Thirdly, the final solution is one of the show's cleverest and most ingenious, one that is revealed later than most episodes before it and one that leaves one absolutely floored, plus it is very easy to follow and explained very clearly and neatly. Sure, the way the murderers are caught is somewhat too easy but not in a jarringly bad way.

Production values are top notch, with to die for scenery, the idyllic look of it contrasting very well with the story's darkness, and quaint and atmospheric photography. The music fits perfectly, and the theme tune one of the most memorable and instantly recognisable of the genre.

Meanwhile, the script is smart and thought-provoking with some nice quirky humour, a grimness and with characters that are colourful and eccentric. The story is very absorbing, never simplistic, never confusing and the maturity that 'Midsomer Murders' has when on form is more than evident here. All the acting is very good indeed.

Overall, brilliant episode and a perfect example of how to return miraculously to form after hitting rock-bottom. 10/10 Bethany Cox
33 out of 38 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Outstanding - best Scott episode by a mile
Schweizer8524 February 2021
Absolutely love this episode, by far the best episode to star Scott.

The plot and script are probably the most intricate and clever we've ever seen in Midsomer Murders. It's a proper murder mystery rather than just the crowd pleasers that sadly some episode fall into the trap of

I love how we see Barnaby and Scott actually solve the case themselves bit by bit rather than the conclusion just coming to them. The scene in the cellar is just great. We often get the impression that Barnaby has little patience with Scott; his methods and his eye for the ladies, so it's good to see this kind of scene which actually shows a good working relationship between the two colleagues.

The conclusion is ingenious, not to mention the gruesome methods of murder. This episode is a must see, a real highlight of the series
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A highly entertaining Midsomer Murders episode
wjspears26 December 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Other reviewers have done a good job highlighting the bizarre and inventive nature of two of the three murders in this episode. The spectacle and presentation of the murders definitely deserve all of the "applause" they are given.

I would add that this was a really well constructed and clever script all around. It did a good job of keeping us puzzled, interested, and putting us "in the shoes" of Barnaby and Scott as they started to piece together what was going on.

The actual con itself was fairly brilliantly conceived by the con artists. It felt fairly believable, at least until the "accident" that sent Nick's (the "mark") money up in flames.

The writers/director did a wonderful job of allowing us to share in Barnaby's budding realization of why all these murders were happening--the only difference being that we weren't trapped in a wine cellar!

I agree that this is a particularly well written and performed Midsomer Murders episode.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
One of the best episodes of Midsomer Murders
Latvian-male3 October 2022
Warning: Spoilers
This was without a doubt one of the best, if not the best, of the Midsomer Murders. A very original plot and revenge-driven murders. There are often villains who get murdered in Midsomer, but this time I even felt the satisfaction of seeing the victims get the payback they deserved. Indeed, each of them deserved their death for the insane crime of fraud against the murderer. The killing of Otto was especially original, unrealistic, but interesting and funny. Please note that I am talking about dark humor and I do not recommend watching this movie with children. Overall this episode was pretty tragic, I even felt sorry for the killer because the victims had ruined his life, but at least he managed to kill all 3 of them. It is cruel and inadequate, but on the other hand it is fair.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Fun story elements, but poor police work and silly behavior.
yerwan13 July 2020
The plot line is good, but the detectives' sleuthing is pathetic, and the Barnabys have a brain freeze and act stupidly out of character. If you like bizarre murder stories and bad detective work this is for you.
3 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Fans of the series and those who enjoy a good whodunit should on no account miss this.
jamesraeburn200321 January 2022
Warning: Spoilers
A solicitor called Nick Turner (played by James Weber Brown) falls to his death from the roof of his home. The big question is: did he fall or was he pushed? Chief Inspector Barnaby (played by John Nettles) and Sgt Scott (played by John Hopkins) learn that Turner was in debt and his best friend, Jack Wilmot, has disappeared. In addition, local historian and fellow solicitor Otto Benham (played by Oliver Ford Davies) had been putting rumours around about Nick claiming that he had been stealing from his clients' funds because he was unhappy at losing some of his own best clients to his law practice. After Otto is murdered by being shot with bottles of his priceless vintage wines from a replica Roman catapult, Barnaby and Scott decide that they are dealing with a revenge killing, but revenge for what? A lead appears when Wilmot's wife, Antonia (played by Nancy Carroll), tells them that a secret wine cellar, supposedly filled with priceless vintages, is rumoured to exist somewhere on the grounds of their home and that he had been obsessively trying to find it before he disappeared. This revelation coincides with the discovery of fake wine labels in Otto's safe. Was there some kind of scam going on? Does it explain the deaths and disappearance? In addition, is Turner's wife, Felicity (played by Lucy Russell) really the grieving widow she appears to be? Otto's best friend, the former TV quiz show host, Mike Spicer (played by Robert Daws), is murdered and Barnaby and Scott are themselves put in grave peril before they finally solve this complex case...

Fans of this long running series and those who simply enjoy a good whodunit should on no account miss this. It is cleverly scripted by David Hoskins who ensures there is plenty of intrigue to keep you hooked and the characterisations are all interesting. You get the idea that almost everyone is either not what they seem or have something to hide and this adds to the enjoyment of the story. It plays fair with the audience and the denouement, when it comes, is surprising and satisfying. As we have come to expect from this series, the rural locations are attractive and well used, the casting is first rate and the direction (here by series regular Sarah Hellings) is spot on. John Hopkins, who replaced Daniel Casey's Sgt Troy as Barnaby's sidekick, has by now established himself firmly in the role of Sgt Scott and developed an on screen chemistry with John Nettles' veteran detective, Chief Inspector Barnaby, which is engaging to watch. Of the supporting cast - they are all excellent - but Oliver Ford Davies and Nancy Carroll are standout.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
"The Sting", Midsomer Murders version
lewis-516 January 2024
This highly rated episode strikes me as highly unlikely -- to put it mildly.

"The Sting" is a classic movie starring Newman and Redford in which an elaborate scheme is produced to swindle a rich man out of a lot of money. The authors of this episode of Midsomer must have been inspired by that.

But the rather unlikely swindle is only part one here. Some might call the murders in part two creative, but I call two of them off-the-wall bizarre. No one would go to such lengths for revenge in real life, especially when they are risking being discovered and ruining the whole point. Producing the machinery involved would be nearly impossible.

But if you can get past the unreality, you will find a uniquely entertaining episode.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Easily my favorite "Midsomer Murders".
harrykivi6 May 2020
Warning: Spoilers
There have been many great episodes in "Midsomer Murders". "Written in Blood", "Death's Shadow" and "Dead Man's Eleven" come to mind immediately. "Hidden Depths" is an episode, which stands out in many ways. Here's 5 reasons why I think it's the best of the series.

1. The production values are wonderful here with an awesome direction, beautiful music and great cast. All of the acting is good, but the standouts are Nancy Carroll (she's always good to look at), Oliver Ford Davies (whose character is extremely juicy and arrogant) and Robert Daws- who is very fun to watch and whose character could have been played as an annoying freak, which Mike Spicer actually isn't.

2. The death scenes of Otto Benham and Mike Spicer are easily the show's most ingenious and brutal. One is catapulted with wine bottles, other drowns in a claret with a TV on his head...

3. The story of "Hidden Depths" is hugely compelling. Nothing felt convoluted and every clue had a place in the narrative. The character are, as said, colorful and twists and turns keep coming and coming.

4. The part in the story, when Scott and Barnaby are trapped in an old wine cellar, is indeed engaging. The difference of their characters is very visible during those scenes.

5. The final solution of "Hidden Depths" is in my mind the best of the series. It's so clever that leaves one truly floored. (It's got to do with the first victim not being dead in the first place).

I have only one issue with this episode. It is that some characters like Jane don't have much to do after Barnaby is done with his interviews.

Overall, love "Hidden Depths".

9,5/10 HK
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Don't forget the yogurt sir.
vitoscotti16 November 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Amazing story with a surprise ending. Barnaby, Scott, and Joyce all shine. Look for Joyce dancing to "Rock Around the Clock". Joyce ,Zara, and the police station not missing the guys is hilarious. This episode mingles in witty humor with intriguing murder mystery. Don't get the scream of "No for God's sake" on the roof. There was no other man there besides the gardener who heard it far off. The screamer would be a missing witness. Though, a well written script certainly a classic in my opinion. Vito S 11-16-19
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
It doesn't get better than this
boxyfella10 August 2021
Warning: Spoilers
For me this is the best episode of them all. It's certainly the most memorable with two of the most bizarre methods of murder the programme has ever come up with and a fabulous twist ending that left me speechless the first time I saw it.

It's hard to believe this followed the appallingly bad Second Sight. It's Scott's best episode without a doubt.

The con itself is ingenious. The scenes when Barnaby and Scott are trapped in the cellar and Joyce is having a good time are hilarious.

Otto Benham and Mike Spicer are loathsome. Never have two characters deserved more to die and I almost wanted the killers to get away with it.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A favorite episode
luvdlcame14 May 2024
Warning: Spoilers
This is one of my favorites. It's one of the first episodes that I can think of where I didn't feel bad for any of the victims..yes, murder is a very bad thing of course.. however they were all terrible and scandalous. And of course, so were the murderer(s). It also seemed to be one of the only episodes where the innocent people really were innocent which is always refreshing. Sure, the one woman wasn't sorry to see her verbally abusive husband get murdered (even semi assisting..in a somewhat humourous way).. and she even admitted to Barnaby that she wasn't sorry to see him go.

On a different note, I miss Troy.

Also, why don't Mr. And Mrs. B kiss one another hello and goodbye?
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed