"Wagon Train" The Jane Hawkins Story (TV Episode 1960) Poster

(TV Series)

(1960)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
An interesting cattle buying trip
bkoganbing17 July 2014
After Frank McGrath complains of a lack of meat for which he needs to cook his infamous Charlie Wooster stew, Robert Horton goes on a cattle buying trip. The owner of the local Ponderosa is Edgar Buchanan and that is who Flint McCullough has to do business with. But Buchanan is not in a mood for business as his only son has just been murdered and he's given out orders to bring in saloon girl Myrna Fahey dead or alive.

And that's when Horton steps into this business when he finds Fahey on the trail more dead than alive courtesy of a bullet from Buchanan's hired gun Sherwood Price. He brings her to the town doctor Whit Bissell who patches Fahey up but insists she not stay in his place.

This whole town is under Buchanan's thumb, they don't even have a sheriff. He rules by decree.

In the end there's a showdown between Horton and Price and the rest of the gunslingers. Look to the Frank Sinatra film Johnny Concho if you want to know how it comes out.

Big kudos to Edgar Buchanan who usually plays folksy rascal types even when he's occasionally a villain. Here there's nothing folksy about him. But he's what you'll remember from this Wagon Train episode.
13 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Robert Horton's Performance Packs A Wallop
strong-122-47888517 March 2018
Without a doubt (in this particular episode) - It's actor, Robert Horton (once again), as "scout" Flint McCullough, who delivers a top-notch performance as a true cowboy-hero who inevitably saves the day, as well as the entire town of Madeletville.

When it comes to having some really great lines to recite while confronting all sorts of hostility from the townsfolk (as he inevitably uncovers the truth behind the near-fatal shooting of Jane Hawkins) - Robert Horton certainly proved that his acting range (as a no-nonsense cowboy) ranked right up there as being one of the very best.

And that, in turn, has definitely earned my overall approval and admiration for Horton and kept me continually interested in watching this classic, TV Western from yesteryear.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Some Tremendous Performances
jlthornb5113 November 2020
This is an exceptional episode of Wagon Train. Mr. Edgar Buchanan gives what is nothing less than the most amazing dramatic performance of his career and it is a performance you will never forget. It is indeed the performance of a lifetime. This is an actor who puts everything into this role and it's absolutely shattering. The always superb Whit Bissell, underrated and often ignored, is also quite memorable in a role that fits him like a glove. Overall, this is an excellent episode that should serve as testimony to the talent and gravitas as an actor of Mr. Edgar Buchanan.
12 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed